3 ms·
> Instead of beating the children for being stupid, you set up schools. Instead of attacking the infirm, you develop technologies to enable them to overcome the
by andai 5y ago
> Instead of beating the children for being stupid, you set up schools. Instead of attacking the infirm, you develop technologies to enable them to overcome their physical limitations.
So what do we do with apparently malicious governments?
- JoshCole 5y agoI can tell you what we have done historically when governments were malicious by consulting a history book, but I can't tell you what we will do in the future. The halting problem makes it formerly provable that it is impossible for me to tell you what we will do. To borrow a term from Wolfram, the problem is computationally irreducible. You're asking me for prophecy. I won't give you one. Also, as a minor point: I said the true statement that sustained incompetence is not the same thing as malice. You quoted me giving examples of sustained incompetence being met with judgement. However, you asked me about situations pertaining to apparent malice rather than sustained incompetence. The situations you quoted aren't alike to the situation you asked about. Even if they were alike they have no bearing on my claim that sustained incompetence is not equal to malice. Equality doesn't exist when there is a union. Equality exists when there is no disjoint. There is one potentially valid interpretation of your question: instead of what do we do you could mean what ought we to do with apparently malicious governments. I admit I'm not an expert on this topic. You would be better off asking people who have studied political science, especially in the context of warfare wherein malice is more common.
- 0des 5y agoI think the person you're replying to is implying the use of the second amendment as what some would characterize as a 'teachable moment'.
- JoshCole 5y agoI have no idea why you think that. You're getting really confused. This really is trivial. So don't continue to do this thing where you inject politics into something for the purposes of confusing yourself for no gain whatsoever. Instead, lets break it down into math so you can see my point more clearly. Let A be the set of things that are a pattern of incompetence. Let B be the set of things that are malice which appear to be incompetence. My claim was that if A = B then the answer is no they are not different and A != B and therefore they are different and that since A != B therefore they are different. He responded by saying that the union of A and B contains elements. I responded with a specific example of elements in the disjoint. If the disjoint of two sets is not the empty set than the two sets are not equal. Get out a pen. Write out the sets. This is simple. The sets aren't equal so I'm not actually asking you to do something impossible that will take a long time. Please. Just try enumerating them. After thirty seconds or so of coming up with examples for each set, just look at the two sets. Are they equal?
- JoshCole 5y agoAlso if this is a meta-level play where you're going to intentionally act incompetent while being malicious in doing so: 1. That is brilliant and funny. 2. The guidelines of discourse on Hacker News demand that I assume you are dull rather than malicious.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]