3 ms·
Maybe you're just the part of the population that loves constant change. I hate it because I see my software as a tool, not a fashion statement, and I don't nee
by userbinator 5y ago
Maybe you're just the part of the population that loves constant change. I hate it because I see my software as a tool, not a fashion statement, and I don't need my tools changing all the time.
- rgrmrts 5y agoI wouldn’t say I love constant change. I think the tool is better and more functional now. It’s more consistent and less distracting.
- pseudalopex 5y agoHow are the new tabs more consistent?
- Barrin92 5y agothere's a pretty clear trend towards flatter, cleaner design with more space both within Firefox and other software. Whether you approve of it or not, it's hard to argue that the changes to the Firefox UI including the tabs don't make it look more like modern UIs in general. Be that Windows or Gnome, or web-based desktop apps etc...
- pseudalopex 5y agoThe new tabs look less like tabs in Chrome or any other app.
- josefx 5y ago> cleaner design with more space Why would I want the UI to take up more space? I am using it as a browser, most of the space should be available for the page I "browse" or serve as an efficient way to navigate pages. > don't make it look more like modern UIs If making something look more modern is the goal just take a dump in the middle of an art gallery, that is plenty of modern and about as functional. > Be that Windows or Gnome Edge still has proper tabs, so are you just making shit up now?
- Barrin92 5y ago>Why would I want the UI to take up more space? I don't care what you want, that wasn't the question. The question was how it is consistent. Preferences are notoriously subjective, plenty of people like less clutter, it tends to make things more readable. >Edge still has proper tabs, so are you just making shit up now? On my machine in edge and chrome both unfocussed tabs are flat and divided by like a 1 pixel grey-ish divider or something. I can't really tell much of a difference between that and firefox.
- josefx 5y agoOn my system Firefox tabs are only divided by space, there is no obvious "this tab ends here". I would prefer the one pixel wide divider "or something". The active tab looks like a button, it has no connection to the content at all, while on edge I still have a clear connection. That might just trigger an ingrained mental "fuck another incomplete UI framework" response in me, it looks wrong and that the tabs actually still behave like tabs is more surprising than expected, why would anyone expect a button to behave like a tab? Last point, as the new tab style takes up more space than the old style I had it disabled. Of course that didn't work long but somehow the option still fucked up highlighting of the active tab. With that fixed it is at least slightly lighter gray on light gray instead of just light gray for all. Still missing an option to fix that waste of space. > The question was how it is consistent. Then why does it take up more space then the bookmarks? Both are just an Icon with a line of text. Hah, just comparing both lists in the UI makes it clear that consistency is not something Firefox devs. have ever heard of. Note: This is not meant as a request at the Firefox designers to fuck up the bookmarks.
- rgrmrts 5y agoNot really the new tab look, but menu bars and other interface elements are more consistent now. Things like the settings hamburger and the “allow mic/camera” popup. There are still some elements that lack a consistent look and feel (I’m personally not the biggest fan of the search on page bottom bar and prefer how Chrome does it).
- pseudalopex 5y agoThe menus are less consistent with other apps now. I guess removing all color from other elements made things more consistent in a way.
- tshaddox 5y agoConstant change? The fundamental UI of desktop browser tabs has been largely unchanged in all major browsers for at least 10 years. Sure, sometimes the UI changes slightly and it annoys people who are annoyed at even the slightest visible change. But complaining about "constant change" or concluding that any time you are eagle-eyed enough to spot a visual change that constitutes "software being a fashion statement" is just a bit extreme.
- wtallis 5y agoThe threshold for what kind of UI changes are worth complaining about should not be set at drastic fundamental reorganization as you seem to want, nor at the "any visible difference" you impute to Mozilla's detractors. Rather, the threshold should generally be at any change that requires existing users to re-train or otherwise detracts from the productivity of experienced users. Mozilla in recent years has been flagrantly ignoring the usability costs of their changes and has shown a willingness to make gratuitous changes. Many of these changes could make sense if Mozilla expected their user base to be on an exponential growth trend, such that the existing users who are alienated or annoyed by changes will soon represent a small portion of the overall username. But that's obviously not the situation Mozilla is in.
- shakna 5y agoIt's actually a case of the opposite of eagle eyed - it's a case of being partially vision impaired which means that things are now harder to grasp as quickly, increasing cognitive load.
- jonnycomputer 5y agoExactly that.
- userbinator 5y agoSure, sometimes the UI changes slightly and it annoys people who are annoyed at even the slightest visible change Considering that the visual processing model of the human brain is based on change detection (hence why animations will get your attention and are distraction), all unnecessary changes do is add mental noise and force reaccommodation, wasting countless hours of trained behaviour. Once a UI becomes familiar, you don't need to pay attention to it and can focus on the content instead. But when it changes, it attracts attention for as long as it takes to changes one's long-term-memory of it. I haven't done any studies on it, but it wouldn't surprise me if those who hate these sorts of changes the most are also the ones with the best long-term memory and observational skills.
- Fnoord 5y agoI take it you run ESR then :-)
- userbinator 5y agoCorrect! That and a few CSS rules to reduce the excessive amount of space even there.