2 ms·
The problem with looking to past energy crises is that humanity's largely solved that by turning to a less-sustainable alternative, either in terms of accessing
by dredmorbius 5y ago
The problem with looking to past energy crises is that humanity's largely solved that by turning to a less-sustainable alternative, either in terms of accessing a fixed stock (e.g., fossil fuels, literally, "fuels dug from the ground" --- fossil bones and remains are so called for similar reasons, though that definition has overtaken older meaning, see: https://www.etymonline.com/word/fossil#etymonline_v_11836 https://www.etymonline.com/word/fossil#etymonline_v_11836).
Foraging and hunting (nomadic, low overall land impact) gave way to farming and forestry (soil depletion, deforestation, salination), gave way to peat (a living resource but extacted at rates greater than those of formation --- peat is something of a proto-coal), coal, oil, and gas.
Critics of limits ... ignore this fact, with stunning brashness and an utter lack of empirical basis or reason. An example from a 1978 lecture by Milton Friedman, to an audience of Standard Oil of Ohio employees (legacy of the benefactor of his alma mater, for what that's worth). After quoting a passage from William Stanley Jevons's 1865 book on the inevitable exhaustion of coal from Britain (production in fact peaked in the early 20th century), in which Jevons notes that the fairly recently-emerged petroleum was itself not only 1) finite but 2) less abundant than coal, Friedman, with a simpy grin and in absolute sincerity says:
We are now talking about how coal will save us from the shortage of oil, and he was talking about how oil could not save us from the shortage of coal.
https://web.archive.org/web/20150717170416/http://0055d26.netsolhost.com/friedman/pdfs/other_commentary/BP.1978.1.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20150717170416/http://0055d26.ne... (PDF)
That is: "we're solving the problem of petroleum scarcity due to a fixed stock by looking to the solution of the previouse scarce, fixed-stock resource, which was identified as a finite and exhaustible resource well over a century before. (Jevons wasn't the first to remark on the finiteness of coal, that discussion traces back to the late 18th century.)
And wherever I've turned to cornucopians ... that's pretty much the tenor of what I've found --- logical absurdities, denial of empirical evidence, namecalling, cheap rhetorical tricks, and for the most part, dogding the question. And that's trying to steelman the arguments and find the strongest and most respected (among the cornucopians) advocates. See: https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=cornucopians&restrict_sr=on https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/search?q=cornucopians&r...
You're committing a similar set of fallacies in your own arguments, which are largely non sequitors.
The question is "can we find an abundant, renewable, or at the very least, inexhaustible over any possible course of consumption, store or stream of energy?".
- Britain (and before it, mainland Europe, Italy, Greece, Asia Minor, and the Levant) stripping themselves of forests are cases of overutilising a renewable resource. Coal, as a nonrenewable resource is not a sustainable solution, it's at best a stop-gap. By switching to coal and hugely increasing rates of energyconsumption, Britain made its eventual problem WORSE. (Note that the story of felling forests is literally the oldest written literature of humanity, in the Epic of Gilgamesh. Lebanon was where pharonic Egypt went for wood. There are no longer abundant forests there.)
- Petroleum lifting hunting pressures on whales does not make petroleum a renewable resource. It's completely irrelevant to the fact of petroleum scarcity.
- Fusion is a pipe dream and has been for nearly a century now. Practical fission energy systems were developed within two decades of the theory of sustainable fission reactions. In 1934 the possibility was first discussed, in 1938 the first "atomic pile" running a sustained nuclear fission reaction was created under the stadium of the University of Chicago (there it is again) by Enrico Fermi, and by 1954 nuclear power was operating the USS Nautilus submarine and the Obninsk nuclear power plant in the USSR. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power Fusion power was proposed in the 1950s, and despite development as armaments, sustained energy-positive fusion remains out of reach some 70 years later. It is a vastly more difficult problem.
If you're interested in the history of energy and its impacts (for good and bad) on human history, Vaclav Smil's Energy in World History (1995) and Energy and Civilization (2017) are excellent (the former focuses a bit more on the history, the latter on the energy, latter is something of an update, though there's also a more recently released edition under the formal title). Smil writes on numerous resource topics in a non-ideological, technical manner. Bill Gates, not someone I always agree with, is a huge fan. His books are excellent.
They're also bookstops --- long and dense. I'd probably recommend the older title over the newer as the situation's changed little and the structure and presentation of the older is superior in my view. Both are worth reading, as are others by the author.
https://www.worldcat.org/title/energy-in-world-history/oclc/469280610 https://www.worldcat.org/title/energy-in-world-history/oclc/...
https://www.worldcat.org/title/energy-and-civilization-a-history/oclc/1178979700 https://www.worldcat.org/title/energy-and-civilization-a-his...
An older title (1977, revised in 1994) is William Ophuls, Ecology and the Politics of Scarcity. That's somewhat more strident, though IMO objective. The author is a former Foreign Service officer (US), awarded a PhD in political science from Yale. The book is based on his dissertation. Though the 1977 edition is slightly dated, it is valuable for making predictions (resources, population, energy, pollution, politics and geopolitics) whose track record can be traced. It is also exquisitely researched and its bibliographic notes are a wealth of references to discussion by both limits and no-limits voices dating from about the 1950s to its publication date. In particular, the book is written as a tightly-reasoned though readable argument and has some of the most concise presentations of the limits-to-growth argument (and various rebuttals) I've read anywhere. The discussion of political challenges, both within and among countries, in addressing limits, is excellent. (I'm re-reading that presently.)
I strongly recommend the book, as well as others by the author.
https://www.worldcat.org/title/ecology-and-the-politics-of-scarcity-revisited-the-unraveling-of-the-american-dream/oclc/260142804 https://www.worldcat.org/title/ecology-and-the-politics-of-s...
https://archive.org/search.php?query=ecology+politics+scarcity+ophuls https://archive.org/search.php?query=ecology+politics+scarci...
http://libgen.rs/search.php?req=ophuls+ecology+politics+scarcity&lg_topic=libgen&open=0&view=simple&res=25&phrase=1&column=def http://libgen.rs/search.php?req=ophuls+ecology+politics+scar...
- WalterBright 5y agoPerhaps I wasn't clear. I was pointing out that whenever humanity ran into a limit to growth, humanity found a way around it. Consider the inconceivable amount of energy the sun rains down on use every day. Now consider all the energy that misses the Earth. Are energy collecting orbital stations too fantastic to postulate? How about putting them on the moon? Then there's all the geothermal energy contained within the earth. There's plenty of reason to be optimistic.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'l borrow a phrase from the world of finance: past performance is no guarantee of future returns. Technology and resources are constrained by laws of nature and specific mechanisms of effect. They're not governed by past lucky breaks, though there's a shape to those (Ophuls discusses this, hint: sigmoid functions feature heavily). He also specifically addresses space-based solar power. I'll refer you to his comments in Ecology and the Politics of Scarcity for that. My own first encounter with that notion was in T.A. Heppenheimer's Colonies in Space, which I read with wide-eyed enthusiasm shortly after it was first published. My eyes and enthusiasm have narrowed somewhat in the intervening decades. I've mentioned geothermal previously. Consider that the Yellowstone supercaldera might be good for a few GW of continuous output, at considerable impact to the National Park associated with it. I'm somewhat in favour of that exchange. It's still only a small fraction of present US electrical consumption, though as a reliable baseload / dispatchable source, it would be a valuable contribution. Tom "Do the Math" Murphy's series exploring various alternatives remains excellent: https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/ The super-abundance of solar power (terrestrial, or with the addition of orbital power) still leaves us with a finite energy budget on Earth, if only through thermal shedding. The terrestrial surplus is far less considerable when increasing standards of living for the ~4 billion global poor, another 2-4 billion projected souls by 2100, storage, and ecosystem requirements are considered. It starts cutting quite thin by the time all of these are considered. I've calcualted that bonus as only 20x, not 7,000x, given numerous known practical limitations, and even that is probably exceeding generous. Some of that expressed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21476882 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21476882 Looking at human population against incident solar power by unit land is interesting: https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/_bi5uhywbdyukhfy-eayjw https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/_bi5uhywbdyukhfy-eayjw