4 ms·
GNOME 3 is truly phenomenal, not enough people give it credit for being a nearly perfect touchscreen OS with powerful desktop options front-and-center. By compa
by smoldesu 5y ago
GNOME 3 is truly phenomenal, not enough people give it credit for being a nearly perfect touchscreen OS with powerful desktop options front-and-center. By comparison, the new GNOME 40 release feels like a lazy attempt at trying to be MacOS, which is definitely not what GNOME meant to me. Now that the majority of extensions are broken again, it's even harder to tune it for my personal workflow. I had to ditch it for KDE, unfortunately. I hope they head in a more interface-agnostic approach, for the future.
- 24t 5y agoGNOME has a major governance problem; the devs don't seem to care about anyone else in the GNOME ecosystem. Thumbnails in the file picker is such an egregious example it's become a huge joke in the linux community. It amazes me that GNOME is still the default DE on so many distros, especially as KDE has so many sane defaults and makes for a smoother transition for users coming from Windows.
- md8z 5y agoI see many comments to this effect, but I think it's a misconception. I really doubt changing the governance is going to get issues like thumbnails fixed. From my perspective, what is actually missing is a lack of money and/or qualified volunteers.
- bacchusracine 5y ago>a lack of money Maybe if they'd quit genuflecting to boondoggles like OPW to the point of bankruptcy they'd have more money? And even better, maybe more people would donate? https://lwn.net/Articles/594583/ https://lwn.net/Articles/594583/
- md8z 5y agoI don't understand how this is related, the FAQ explains that was a one time accounting error that was resolved. "As a result of these issues, we have only just now finalized our 2014 budget. In the meantime, we made assumptions based on previous years' incomes and expenditures, and we authorized expenditures for this year based on those assumptions. Those assumptions proved to be more optimistic than reality. In addition, while our outgoing payments to interns must be strictly timed, the incoming payments from sponsoring organizations are very fluid, thus we have had to front the costs of OPW. Fronting these costs has resulted in a budget shortfall. "The situation has already improved as some 2014 Advisory Board fees and outstanding OPW invoices have been paid. The board expect more to be paid within the next 4 weeks. If there are no unexpected issues and no delays, the freeze should be lifted by July." The foundation didn't go bankrupt. Also: 1. The foundation doesn't (currently) even fund any developers despite having resolved those issues, because developers are pretty expensive. 2. I wasn't referring to the foundation specifically anyway. If you don't want to support the foundation you can just donate to a developer/project individually, if they are open to it. 3. I don't think the issue can be reduced to lack of donations. Donations are good but aren't really a reliable funding source. A healthy project usually needs other funding sources than just donations.
- nvarsj 5y agoThe lack of backwards compatibility with extensions is probably my number one issue with Gnome. Every release breaks every extension. I wish they would commit to stable APIs.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> Now that the majority of extensions are broken again, it's even harder to tune it for my personal workflow. I had to ditch it for KDE, unfortunately. This is what pushed me to KDE from GNOME after spending more than a decade hating it. Turns out that I love Plasma Desktop. My tolerance for being unable to use my desktop at all because GNOME developers decided to break their extension API again is gone.
- smoldesu 5y agoI was pushed to Plasma after the 40 update too, and I've been really happy with how things are turning up these days. Great features are being added in weekly, they actually address bugs instead of tagging decades-old problems as wontfix, and it's way more flexible than GNOME. I can create more elaborate desktops with bog-standard Plasma than is possible with modded GNOME, and I can trust they'll work more reliably than an out-of-the-box GNOME install. Unfortunately, it's still not a great option for tablet/touchscreen PCs, but I can see a lot of progress coming down the pipeline with Wayland. Overall though, it's quite lovely. I can near-perfectly recreate Mojave with extra bells and whistles, plus perpetual 32-bit support and long-term support.
- nyanpasu64 5y agoI want Plasma to be good. I'm frustrated at kwin's breakage and lag on Nvidia (https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=443951 https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=443951 fixed), the years-old data-corruption heisenbugs I've encountered (kxmlgui toolbar corruption: https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=395497 https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=395497) and the instability of some apps (plasmashell crashes occasionally, plasma-systemmonitor crashes quite often when processes terminate in tree view). And it's difficult to fix these bugs because many KDE apps suffer from complexity in apps and libraries (any app involving both QML and C++ code), often accompanied by legacy code sometimes misusing inheritance (kxmlgui) and misused or no longer understood (kxmlgui, libksysguard), or churning and replacing mature code with untested rewrites (plasma-systemmonitor). I'm trying Xfce on my desktop now (after using it a bit on my laptop). It's a refreshing experience so far, with a panel written in a compiled language rather than QML/JS with unreliable GPU acceleration, and it seems relatively stable so far. They've added window snapping with Super+Arrow or mouse dragging, and the docklike plugin (https://gitlab.xfce.org/panel-plugins/xfce4-docklike-plugin https://gitlab.xfce.org/panel-plugins/xfce4-docklike-plugin) is a good replacement for KDE or Windows 7+'s icon-pinning-based taskbar. There are some issues (like the long-standing https://gitlab.xfce.org/xfce/libxfce4ui/-/issues/1 https://gitlab.xfce.org/xfce/libxfce4ui/-/issues/1, which I hope can be fixed but don't know for sure). But I feel Xfce is much more stable to begin with (in my experience so far, at least), meaning that fixing them is less urgent. I hope the codebase is understandable enough for me to work on it (I think Xfce apps are written in C, which I can read but I'm not super fluent in writing). I also don't know if Xfce will survive in a future Wayland-based world.
- pjmlp 5y agoI used GNOME 1.0, since the early days, even tried to contribute to Gtkmm back in the day, and now run XFCE on my travel netbook despite my usual C rants. Because having a JavaScript driven desktop, and being forced to install extensions even for basic stuff is a no go for me, I rather use something that fully embraces C.