3 ms·
- Clean (carbon-free) - Not dependent on weather - Economically viable Pick 2
by paxys 5y ago
- Clean (carbon-free)
- Not dependent on weather
- Economically viable
Pick 2
- nix23 5y ago- Clean (carbon-free) Nuclear and a mix of available sources (wind, water, ground etc) - Not dependent on weather Nuclear, ground and dam's (aka water batteries) - Economically viable Nuclear and a mix of available sources (wind, water, ground etc) BTW: Nothing is carbon free AtM
- colinmhayes 5y agoNuclear is not even close to being economically viable atm. Making it economically viable probably isn't politically viable.
- ch4s3 5y agoThis seems to largely be because we build new designs for almost every reactor, and change the regulation faster than projects get finished, so they have to get refitted part way through. The regulatory framework also makes it infeasible to finance small reactors. If we could build the same design over and over in a bunch of locations, with a common regulatory regime it would be much cheaper and much faster. That nuclear is slow and expensive to build is an artifact of infrequency and bad regulation.
- colinmhayes 5y ago> If we could build the same design over and over in a bunch of locations, with a common regulatory regime it would be much cheaper and much faster. This not being possible is why I said making nuclear economically viable is not politically viable.
- ch4s3 5y agoI'm not so sure that's the case. I think the big push now in France and China could open the path to more nuclear elsewhere. I also think that if places start to have issues with grid stability or intermittency of power, they'll be inclined to give it a second look. That said, there could be some heretofore unexpected leap forward in battery tech, but that's not necessarily going to happen. The political situation in all of the West is moving rapidly and in unexpected ways lately, so the realm of what's possible could easily change.
- pjscott 5y agoChina and South Korea can build nuclear plants at a per-megawatt capital cost similar to coal plants, so I agree that the problem looks political.
- rewgs 5y agoAlright, I'm game. Assuming that you truly have to pick 2: We very simply must go towards clean/carbon-free as much as we can, so that's my #1 pick. It must be economically viable for it to, you know, actually happen, so that's #2. Pretty easy then, actually: our energy sources must be dependent on weather. Sucks, but it is what it is. The choice is even easier when you think about the fact that going this route is with the purpose of avoiding even more extreme/unpredictable weather. If we want stable weather, we must go with energy sources that are dependent on weather; the weather being stable is important to using sources that are dependent on weather. Bottom line: lean hard into solar and wind, and go really hard into better energy storage tech.
- nix23 5y ago>and go really hard into better energy storage tech. Yes! Building dam's/silos (pumping water up when energy is available drain it when it's not) no need to build them 'into' rivers, artificial fjords where current is strong, batteries/hydrogen where nothing else is viable, create heat pumping into the ground, pump it up when no heat from other sources are available etc.
- rewgs 5y agoFor sure. It is so very obvious to me that there's one way forward: on the smallest levels possible, replace what energy production a given area can with some sort of creative renewable(s) implementation. And over time, replace fossil fuels not from the top down, but from the bottom up. Essentially a modular grid of small, bespoke-for-its-area energy producers.
- anonuser123456 5y agoThere is still an awful lot of room at the bottom.