3 ms·
The only potential problem I can see with a deaf team is that they would seem more likely to miss the referee stopping play. For example, a receiver for the non
by tzs 5y ago
The only potential problem I can see with a deaf team is that they would seem more likely to miss the referee stopping play. For example, a receiver for the non-deaf team fumbles a pass, a deaf player recovers and is running for the goal getting ready to try to plow through a couple opposing players who are in the way, and the ref blows their whistle to stop the play because the receiver did not have possession before fumbling so it was really just an incomplete pass.
If the deaf player does not know the play has stopped they might still try to plow through those other players who did hear the whistle and are no longer ready to take a hit.
The article says that the refs are asked to wave their arms around when stopping play in addition to the usual whistle blow, but that requires the player to be looking at the ref.
In a pro stadium or top level amateur league stadium, where the whole damn field is going to be encircled by animated advertising at field level, it would be possible to make something that detects when the ref stops play and flashes "STOP PLAY!" in some hard to miss color scheme. That should be noticeable by any player who is still standing (and players who are not standing aren't going to cause problems if they miss play stopping).
- Ajedi32 5y agoMaybe they could point some bright colored lights at the field and flash them when the play ends? That seems like a pretty low-budget way of achieving the same thing.
- chaoz_ 5y agoGood point, what about asking ref to press some button when the foul is detected. Then, some small watch could vibrate and notify a player. Sounds like a simple enough idea to implement.
- Kalium 5y agoI am reminded of when the NHL tried to use a wirelessly trackable puck. It worked until the tech involved wasn't up to the rigors of being slapped around by professional hockey players. In the same vein, I have some doubts about the ability of a watch to stand up to the forces at play on the field.
- Ichthypresbyter 5y agoNFL (and college football) players already have electronics in their gear- the quarterback has a radio in his helmet, the players have RFID trackers in their pads, and there is one in the ball. Some teams also use wearable GPS athlete monitoring devices like the STATSports Apex [0]. They seem to work. I imagine that a hockey puck is subjected to much harder acceleration than a football, never mind a player, due to the nature of its collisions with the wall. [0] https://pro.statsports.com/football/ https://pro.statsports.com/football/
- kerblang 5y agoTo the best of my recollection American Football does not wrap the playing field in animated ads like European Football/Soccer does. I assume that's partly because everybody just hates the idea for every possible reason... Noise can be a problem in really large stadiums and college/pro fans will sometimes successfully disrupt the opposing offense by making it too loud for them to hear each other in the huddle.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> To the best of my recollection American Football does not wrap the playing field in animated ads like European Football/Soccer does. I assume that's partly because everybody just hates the idea for every possible reason... No, just that ground-level perimeter displays are too pedestrian for American football. https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/29868399/sofi-stadium-videoboard-eighth-wonder-world-targets-genz https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/29868399/sofi-stadium-vi...
- NobodyNada 5y agoAt least at the football games I've been to, the videoboards aren't primarily used for ads but to show score information, close-up camera shots, instant replays, gimmicks to hype up the crowd, etc. There's some advertising but it's usually in the form of the announcer saying "now let's watch the best plays of the year, brought to you by some random insurance company!" Most of the ads are old-fashioned paper billboards placed next to the videoboards, and not in distracting places like on the sidelines. Televised football is totally different -- the ads are absolutely obnoxious. But I guess if you actually buy a ticket then they're incentivized to actually give you a good experience. Maybe NFL stadiums are worse than college stadiums, or maybe my school is just unusually pleasant, I don't know.
- jaywalk 5y agoThe video board at SoFi (or any other NFL stadium) is not primarily used for ads. There are ribbon boards along each seating level of the stadium that are primarily used for ads, which is much more similar to the European field-level ads.
- 5y ago
- JackFr 5y agoI played football in college against Gallaudet University (which is a school for the deaf.) They used a very large drum (6 ft diameter) on the sideline for their snap count as well as whistle plays dead. But referees warned us that they were not going call late hits on the other team unless they were egregious and that we should keep aware on the field and protect ourselves accordingly.