4 ms·
Portugal proposed law tries to sneak in biometric mass surveillance
- mig39 5y agoWhat are the chances this law actually passes before the assembly is dissolved and there's an election? The government is a minority government, running the country in a failed coalition. Does it have the votes to ram this through?
- throwaway59553 5y ago[dead]
- squeral 5y agoThere's still a chance as some media are painting it as a good security measure.
- pessimizer 5y agoIn the US, legislation like this is supported by both administration and opposition, the actual danger to it passing is public notice. What you want to do it hide it in emergency legislation that passes on a voice vote in the middle of a group of quick voice votes with no debate. According to the description by another commenter (who calls this post "pure propaganda"), this seems a lot like that sort of a messy process, and is being deemed necessary in order to enable police body cams (which seems like a wokewashing.) edit: a sign would be if this legislation as sold as being both so important that it has to be passed now, and so trivial, procedural, and boring that there's no reason to discuss it.
- luluganeta 5y agoIMHO, the suggestion of wokewashing is off the mark. Here in PT there have been recent instances of police violence, but they were not accompanied by a movement to force police to wear cameras. The government presented a single law package covering police bodycams, wider surveillance, AI, biometric and police drones. I can only understand this mixing together of disparate issues as a way to diminish public debate and perception around some of them. The bodycam issue ended up capturing most of the media attention, in part because it involves labour issues, whereas AI or biometrics are much more technical and harder to approach journalistically. I think this is why you find the drive to pass police bodycams -- they're trying to pass a lot of things under the rug, and bodycams just happen to be a convenient talking point to remove focus from others.
- luluganeta 5y agoRight now, it's still unclear. Initially, it seemed like a done deal because of the likely support of the major opposition (PSD, centre-right), which has advocated for wider surveillance in other contexts. Its leader also has a history of being strong on policing and surveillance as former mayor of Porto. However, in the last few days the PSD is apparently distancing themselves from government, e.g. recently u-turning and siding with the left opposition to approve compensating pensions for the disabled against the ruling party's (PS, centre-left) position against it. Today, the PSD demanded that only the bodycam mandates and wildfire monitoring portions are put forward in order to vote favourably. This means putting aside the AI, biometrics and surveillance provisions. If this stands, the most concerning parts of the law would not go forward. But in Portugal we're now in a pre-election moment, where positions might flip and statements easily get reversed, so we're bound to have a thrilling few days ahead until the final vote by the end of the month.
- BaRRaKID 5y agoThat article is pure propaganda and not factually true. To give some background, the Portuguese government failed to get the annual budget approved, the president dissolved the parliament due to that, and scheduled new elections that will happen in a few months. Due to that the current government asked the leaders of all political parties to give urgent treatment to 7 diplomas / laws that are almost finished and should not have to wait until after the new elections to be approved. There is no secret move being made here, everyone knows that this is happening. Regarding the "biometric mass surveillance", one of the 7 laws that where requested to have urgent approval was about allowing the use of video surveillance by the police. The wording of the law was a bit too vague and as such did not get approval from the National Data Protection Commission. Also, it's worth to mention that the government can't approve the law by themselves and needs support from other (and opposing) political parties. As it sits now the government has to change the wording of the law to be more specific and ensure that it complies with data protection laws (as in GDPR), and even after that the opposing parties are only willing to approve the use of body-cams by police, and the use of video surveillance to prevent wildfires (which are a major issue in Portugal).
- BaRRaKID 5y agoBiometric data gathering is officially out of the text [0] (no English source, sorry). [0]https://www.publico.pt/2021/11/16/politica/noticia/ps-corta-ambito-videovigilancia-quer-sistemas-esquadras-1985141 https://www.publico.pt/2021/11/16/politica/noticia/ps-corta-...
- JetSpiegel 5y ago> To give some background, the Portuguese government failed to get the annual budget approved, the president dissolved the parliament due to that, and scheduled new elections that will happen in a few months. Technically, the government did not resign, and the president did not dissolve the parliament yet, it's fully functional. The dissolution will only happen later this month.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vmception 5y ago
- sschueller 5y agoWouldn't such a law be considered illegal by the EU?
- MonkeyClub 5y agoNot yet or not exactly. The EU parliament has voted on the issue[1][2], but member nations have to implement the laws following a central directive. [1] https://reclaimyourface.eu/our-voices-have-been-heard-ep-calls-to-ban-bms/ https://reclaimyourface.eu/our-voices-have-been-heard-ep-cal... [2] https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20210930IPR13925/use-of-artificial-intelligence-by-the-police-meps-oppose-mass-surveillance https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20210930IP...
- mistrial9 5y agoif I recall, Portugal is one of the few countries in the West that has already implemented "No Net-Neutrality" .. pay-for-service over the open Internet. I have a screenshot of pricing for "social media tier" and others.
- luluganeta 5y agoIndeed, Portugal was rightfully highlighted for zero-rating practices by some operators (not charging for some services, e.g. Facebook or Youtube). But recently the EU indicated it might move to crack down on the practice: https://www.engadget.com/eu-zero-rating-net-neutrality-ruling-132559309.html https://www.engadget.com/eu-zero-rating-net-neutrality-rulin...
- rlf_dev 5y agoAnd it was Mobile plans only, since it's illegal to have zero-rating plans on fixed plans.