3 ms·
Should discussions about the history of Smalltalk mention Objective-C? Was it the most successful Smalltalk-inspired language after Java? Ironic that because of
by Apocryphon 5y ago
Should discussions about the history of Smalltalk mention Objective-C? Was it the most successful Smalltalk-inspired language after Java? Ironic that because of the quirks of corporate decisions, both became the initial languages for the most successful smartphone platforms- previously most mobile systems from Palm to Symbian were developed in C++.
- cout 5y agoEither Objective C or Ruby, yes (imo). One could also make an argument for javascript being a Smalltalk-derived or inspired language.
- retrocryptid 5y agoI'd argue Javascript is based on Self, but Self was very much inspired by Smalltalk, so my argument is really a small nit.
- jjtheblunt 5y agoIsn't Javascript awfully close to Scheme (in subset) but with C-ish (algol-ish, java-ish) syntax?
- bodhiandphysics 5y agoNot really? JavaScript doesn’t have conses so it’s not very lisp like in practice. What is gets from scheme is closures with lexical scoping (real closures). It’s closer in style to self, but js is textual instead of image based so that’s very very different. The other aspect of js that’s very different is it’s massive commitment to a synchronicity, which smalltalks generally don’t have
- chipotle_coyote 5y agoI think so, yes. My impression is that Smalltalk fans lament the loss of the tooling around the language more than the language itself, so they're not as likely to focus on Objective-C's success -- but I suspect there's a case to be made that the underlying object and message-passing concepts Obj-C borrowed from Smalltalk enabled a lot of NextStep's rapid interface builder technology to be as good as it was in the 1990s, and that technology kept them alive long enough to be bought by Apple, rejuvenated the Mac, and laid the foundation for iOS.