6 ms·
As a parent who got 6 months that barely fucking scratches the surface of the time it take to raise a human. Subsidize me until they are in public school and I
by refurb 5y ago
As a parent who got 6 months that barely fucking scratches the surface of the time it take to raise a human.
Subsidize me until they are in public school and I’ll high five you.
- jbreiding 5y agoI would argue we just need to bring public school earlier. We don’t need this tied to an employer like health insurance as this is something that benefits us all.
- jbreiding 5y agoMy word choices might not have been the best here. But consider if everyone was able to take the first year at some percentage less of regular salary. Then public funded care available with learning included? My wife would have preferred this to having exhausted fmla just before giving birth because of early complications. Returning to work was not an option for her, 6 years later returning to work was one of the most emotionally draining experiences for her.
- belorn 5y agoPlato suggested that the state should have communal rearing of children. We could have a society were children goes to public school as soon they can take formula.
- mattferderer 5y agoI would suggest a compromise of "until they have all of their primary teeth". There is no sleep until all those **** are in.
- echelon 5y ago> Subsidize me until they are in public school and I’ll high five you. I know this is an exaggeration, but it drew my interest. This expects that the rest of us have to work to subsidize you having children for five to six years. I'm wholly on board with helping parents raise children. Children are our future. But at some threshold of subsidization this equation tips and actively offloads the entire burden onto those without children. Both of my parents had jobs when I was growing up. Why are we suddenly expecting this to change? Childcare can be paid for at rates under minimum wage in aggregate. Look at our school system and daycare businesses. Just because you think your child deserves only the best does not make it economical, and lots of people make this work. Thousands of years of child rearing has happened in suboptimal conditions. Raising children has been an incredible chore more often than not throughout history. It's only been briefly punctuated by moments of ease, and even then, it wasn't evenly distributed. Children are not easy. I think modern parents are seeing their childfree peers and remarking on the delta in quality of life. I honestly don't mean this as an attack. I'm just interested in the varying perspectives on this.
- Apes 5y agoThere are many children where you have a choice: * Subsidize them with 15 years of child care for a relatively small amount now, and they will become productive members of society. * Do nothing now, and in 15 years be forced to subsidize them via crime, the justice system, and outreach programs for the remainder of their life.
- anoonmoose 5y ago> offloads the entire burden onto those without children Are you including "people with children over the age of five to six years" in this group? Because it seems like they would be helping to raise others people's children (in your words) but would also have benefitted. According to the first Google result I found it looks like in 2018 only 15% of women age 50 were childless. A first-order approximation assuming younger generations have kids at the same rate and it's the same for both genders (neither of these are guaranteed but it's a starting point) would lead me to believe that more than most people have children and would benefit from a policy like this over the course of their lives. People without cars help pay for roads, people without children pay for public schools...I'm not really seeing much here to suggest there's an undue burden on those without children.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoWhat has changed is that due to labour mobility and contemporary society generally the extended family has become a non-thing for so many of us. If we're expected to move wherever for work, then that wherever needs to provide support. Because right now I'm hours from my sole remaining inlaw and a whole country apart from my own parents and brother, and it's been hell raising children like this. And not just young children; my teenagers' mental health would be much better if they were to have their uncle and grandma nearby.
- Terr_ 5y ago> But at some threshold of subsidization this equation tips and actively offloads the entire burden onto those without children. True, but on a long enough timeframe one could also view it as a repayment from the people who (with or without children) were once children-being-subsidized themselves.
- _bixt 5y agoYou are asking for an incredibly high amount of welfare, essentially "everyone else in society should pay me for 5 years because I chose to have a kid". I'm choosing to have a kid too, but I'm taking the personal responsibility path of saving and paying for it on my own. Perhaps there is some middleground, but 5 years is absolutely absurd.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThis actually highlights a major misunderstanding in parental leave discussions: Most government-sponsored paid parental leave programs in other countries aren't paying 100% salary during the leave. Sweden has one of the more generous programs that pays up to $41K/year (USD equivalent) or 80% of your income, whichever is lower. That amount is actually quite good if you're living modestly, but it may not be what people earning $100-150K have in mind when they see "paid parental leave". Definitely better than nothing, though!
- croo 5y agoUhh, it's 3 years where I live (though the welfare money for the last one and half year is very low and lots of mother go back to work before that) I would say 3 year is pretty good as kids starts to gain a lot from socializing after that age. Why would this be absurd? It's perfectly normal. Looking after a toddler is hard 7/24 work with little time to spare. Of course you can go to work and instead pay for a house cleaner and a baby sitter to look after your house and your kid because.. work is more important? Or what is your argument here?
- _bixt 5y agoI believe in taking time away from work to raise kids. In fact, I am taking several years away from work now for that purpose. What I disagree with is who should pay for it. I'm paying for my living expenses and raising my child from my savings that I earned at my generous paying job. I think the government should pay for up to perhaps 3 months for raising kids (and it shouldn't be based on your salary, but tied to some universally agreed upon basic living wage), but any more than that should be self-financed. There is a set amount of handouts society can give out before it implodes, and there are far better uses for that money than giving you the privilege of a plush lifestyle while you choose to stay at home with your toddler.
- sokoloff 5y agoIs there anyone who wouldn’t high five someone who pays them for five years without needing to go into work?