4 ms·
Trademark law wouldn't apply here.
by rmc 15y ago
Trademark law wouldn't apply here.
- kragen 15y agoPresumably "Deus Ex" is Square Enix's trademark, no? If GameStop is passing off what's left after they tamper with the box as Deus Ex Whatever, wouldn't that be trademark infringement?
- rmc 15y agoDepends. GameSpot could claim the game itself is Deus Ex. They could pull a hunter off the street and ask what they would define as 'Deus Ex', the punter might say the game. Twould be different.t if the box said 'Comes with a voucher for D'oeuvres on the box. Though in that case normal consumer rights law about accurate descriptions comes into play and GameSpot are in a very weak position then. What would be more interesting is if Square Enix and GameSpot have some contract for how to sell these games, and GameSpot are breaking this.
- kragen 15y ago> They could pull a hunter off the street and ask what they would define as 'Deus Ex', the punter might say the game. I think that traditionally it's the trademark owner who gets to define what their trademark is allowed to be applied to, not a "hunter off the street." (Did you mean "punter"?) This sometimes has deleterious effects — for example, Saran Wrap no longer contains any Saran, and Kaopectate in the US no longer consists of kaolinite and pectin — but by and large it's a sensible policy, in light of the information asymmetry between consumers and producers that makes trademark law a reasonable bargain in the first place. ("Information asymmetry"? I mean, if you knew how to make flawless replacement cylinder heads for your Ferrari, you'd likely make them yourself instead of buying them from Ferrari; and if you knew how to identify flawless cylinder heads, you wouldn't need the Ferrari trademark to ensure that the ones you bought were flawless. The reason the trademark benefits you as a consumer, or for that matter Ferrari as a producer, is that it allows you to delegate that decision to Ferrari's engineers, machinists, etc., even when you're buying the part through a reseller; and then Ferrari can charge a premium for their reputation.)
- rmc 15y agoThe opinion of the general public is important. That's how trademarks are genericised and lost. (and yes I meant punter, Damn you autocorrect)
- kragen 15y agoYes, the opinion of the general public is important in genericizing trademarks, but I don't think there's any serious question of whether "Deus Ex" has become a generic category of video games — it hasn't. The opinion of the general public is not important in the issues at hand.
- dsl 15y agoYou are pretty much saying "Well the earth has gravity, so gravity must apply here." No, trademark has nothing to do with this. If anything, right of first sale (remember GameStop buys games in bulk from publishers) protects them.
- kragen 15y agoI didn't realize there was a "right of first sale" in trademark law (obviously I'm not a lawyer) but what Wikipedia says about it is this: > With reference to trade in tangible merchandise, such as the retailing of goods bearing a trademark, the "first sale" rule serves to immunize a reseller from infringement liability. Such protection to the reseller extends to the point where said goods have not been altered so as to be materially different from those originating from the trademark owner. It seems to me that removing coupons from the box is "altering goods so as to be materially different from those originating from the trademark owner".
- corin_ 15y agoAn OnLive coupon is absoolutely nothing to do with the trademark it is a seperate item that happens to come with it. They may have broken their contract, we don't know, but this has absolutely nothing to do with trademarks.