2 ms·
While I agree that family leave is a good thing and needs some discussion about how to implement/fund it, I really dislike the title. It's a real stretch to cla
by giantg2 5y ago
While I agree that family leave is a good thing and needs some discussion about how to implement/fund it, I really dislike the title. It's a real stretch to claim that if she didn't have paid leave that she might be dead. The real root of the issue is that she should have been paying attention to her symptoms. One could even make the arguement that if she needed to go back to work sooner, that the symptoms would have been more disruptive and could have lead to addressing them even sooner. There are good arguments for family leave, but her story and the way she tells is not one of them.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI agree, the only way the author's premise makes sense is if she was given bad information, and she did not bother to research anywhere else. With both of my wife's pregnancies on both coasts of the US, we were told to immediately call the doctor if bleeding persisted after a couple weeks. You are even told exactly what the bleeding should look like and how its characteristics should change over time, and if it deviates, to call the doctor.
- 999900000999 5y agoGiven my working class background, she's spot on. If you don't have paid leave, you don't have time to see the doctor. Thousands of people die every year just because they don't have time to see a doctor since they're too busy making Subway sandwiches or whatever. She supported her point rather well, post pregnancy complications are extremely common and it shouldn't be a shocker to say you should have time to handle those.
- giantg2 5y ago"Thousands of people die every year just because they don't have time to see a doctor since they're too busy making Subway sandwiches or whatever." I don't think this story shows that. This story involves a call to the doctor. The doctor says it's life threatening. Any person would choose to take off rather than die. In fact, in my experience the people who die because they didn't see a doctor didn't know how serious their condition was, or didn't know they even had a condition. If anything, this story is a good argument for better patient education. After all, she had time off and still didn't pay attention to her symptoms - symptoms which were almost certainly required to be covered with the discharge instructions. So this is really an example of what paid leave looks like and how patient education needs to be improved. "post pregnancy complications are extremely common and it shouldn't be a shocker to say you should have time to handle those." This shouldn't be specific to pregnancy. This same logic can be applied to other medical issues. Is there really any reason to differentiate on causation when talking about medical recovery? There may be childcare issues that could support maternity leave, but those were not really covered here. So I would say this was an article mostly focused on appeal to emotion and theatrics (just look at that intro), not a well reasoned argument.
- 999900000999 5y agoIn a better world you'd also get paid time off after a car crash , heart surgery, etc. America's the only county that doesn't offer parental leave, it's not radical to say this leads to poor outcomes. https://www.vice.com/en/article/g5g8eq/amazon-denied-a-worker-pregnancy-accommodations-then-she-miscarried https://www.vice.com/en/article/g5g8eq/amazon-denied-a-worke...
- giantg2 5y ago"America's the only county that doesn't offer parental leave, it's not radical to say this leads to poor outcomes." You mean paid parental leave? You should be able to take unpaid parental leave under FMLA for medical reasons. America is not the only country. It depends on if you mean developed country or some other missing adjective. Also, you said parental leave. Many countries only offer maturity leave, and not parental leave (maturnity + paternity). These also have other impacts/reasons than the medical point the original article makes. I'm not sure why you linked that article. Maturnity leave refers to post delivery. Pre delivery would be prenatal leave, which isn't discussed here. They do discuss some medical leave here, which brings me back to the point about not making this solely about maturnity leave, and that the original article is more about medical side and not the other aspects of parental leave.
- 999900000999 5y ago>You mean paid parental leave? You should be able to take unpaid parental leave under FMLA for medical reasons. No working class person can just take 6 months off and still make rent. In many countries you can take leave before having a kid or after. America lacks any such framework, or general worker protection. A family member of mine missed significant time from work due to a difficult pregnancy. Lucky the kid was fine, but her employer just fired her. *Yes this was illegal, but their wasn't any real recourse she could take* Most of us here are very privileged. But no normal person can sell some RSUs and take off half a year
- giantg2 5y ago