3 ms·
How do you justify burning assets for tax purposes then? It’d be much better if they could simply give the planes to the taxman if they couldn’t pay the tax.
by baq 5y ago
How do you justify burning assets for tax purposes then? It’d be much better if they could simply give the planes to the taxman if they couldn’t pay the tax.
- phreeza 5y agoIt's possible for a policy to result in an net positive even if it entails some individual negative examples.
- baq 5y agoit's a given for any policy, but we aren't talking about generalizations here; in the end, it's the particular that matters.
- phreeza 5y agoIt depends on the alternative you are suggesting. No taxes? A bureaucracy so vast that can handle all imaginable edge cases? Individual discretion of the tax assessor? I think all these could fix this particular problem but might lead to worse outcomes overall.
- baq 5y agoi suggested the solution right there - forfeiture of the assets that the taxman can't get the tax for.
- phreeza 5y agoUgh I must have been half asleep when writing the original comment (toddler woke up at 4am). I mistook your comment for a knee-jerk libertarian reaction, but what you propose does make a lot of sense. I stand corrected.