4 ms·
You've changed your argument, just so we're both aware of the fact. The initial argument was that oil is under-priced relative to its full cost of formation.
by dredmorbius 5y ago
You've changed your argument, just so we're both aware of the fact.
The initial argument was that oil is under-priced relative to its full cost of formation.
You're now arguing that we can synthesize oil given sufficient energy.
The principle value of fossil fuels has been somewhat less their chemical properties than the stored energy that they represent. This is rather like saying one can satiate one's hunger by eating one's arm. The problem isn't filling the belly, the problem is growing and operating the arm.
If we do find a viable means of creating synthetic hydrocarbon-based fuels (I've suggested this myself fairly frequently: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adredmorbius%20synthetic%20hydrocarbon&sort=byPopularity&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...), what we'll find is that a properly-functioning market will price those according to their true opportunity costs. Those will reflect the energy and capital inputs.
If I understand the research correctly, stored energy will net about 50% of the input. Returned energy from thermal mechanical or generating applications will be about 15--25% of the original input. The cost is a great deal of lost energy, the gain is storage, portability, and availability when needed.
The reason oil is "cheaper" to pump out of the ground is, as I began this thread noting, because economics ignores the full costs. And, as I've said previously, under free-market conditions, prices fall to the marginal cost of extraction only (equivalent to the bus fare to the bank), which in 1930s east Texas hit a low of $0.02/bbl. (At the time, $1/bbl was considered a reasonable price.)
Note that at the time, the geology and chemistry of formation were poorly understood. The age of the Earth itself had only been firmly established as being in the billions of years, rather than the 6,000 of biblical estimation or perhaps a few hundreds of millions by geological and physics estimates (Lord Kelvin concluding the latter, in the absence of knowledge of radioactivity which could explain the sustained inner heat of the Earth and the Sun's own power source).
You might care to avoid bringing the discussion back to previously addressed and dismissed points.
- WalterBright 5y ago> The initial argument was that oil is under-priced relative to its full cost of formation. You're now arguing that we can synthesize oil given sufficient energy. But isn't that relevant to the "true" cost of formation? The cost to synthesize it puts a maximum price on it. > The principle value of fossil fuels has been somewhat less their chemical properties than the stored energy that they represent. Long term, it is their ability to store energy in a relatively safe, compact and lightweight form. If our energy production transitions to nuclear, solar, fusion, etc., all those are unsuitable for things like jet aircraft. But using that energy to create jet fuel is quite viable. I.e. we needn't worry about running out of geologic oil. > If we do find a viable means of creating synthetic hydrocarbon-based fuels We already have, haven't we? I'm no chemist, but with all the chemical engineering expertise, I find it hard to believe we cannot product gasoline on an industrial scale given energy, carbon, and hydrogen. There's just no point to doing it right now because it's cheaper to pump it. I.e. the two things that matter are the extraction cost and the cost to synthesize it.
- dredmorbius 5y agoOn synfuels / "true" cost of formation: synthetic fuel creation would provide an alternate cost path (using different inputs and methods) to the same ends (liquid / gaseous hydrocarbon alkanes). It's not so much that this relates to the true cost of production of fossil liquid hydrocarbons as that it may afford a lower cost (and higher rate of production) alternative. One reason I hammer the false price basis of present petroleum consumption is that if the true formation costs are accounted for, oil production becomes economically dead. You can't pump out $5 million and sell it for $1 and run a positive balance sheet. That's what so-called rational economic man has been doing since the 1850s (Galecia, the Eastern European one, beat Titusville to the oil industry by about a decade: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galicia_(Eastern_Europe)#Oil_and_natural_gas_industry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galicia_(Eastern_Europe)#Oil_a...) If our energy production transitions ... "If" does some exctremely heavy lifting in that sentence. I've been familiar with this question for most of my life, I've done some (mostly minor) work in the field, and I've been exploring the literature and state of the art fairly heavily for over a decade, including both current and older predictions and observations. Solar power, and its derivatives (wind, hydroelectric, biomass) is all but certain to be our major energy stream going forward, though hydro and biomass are already nearly fully tapped out. There's good prospects for considerable additional contribution from intensive geothermal (that is, from active geothermal zones, not "enhanced" lower-grade geothermal), though at the cost of formations now considered natural parks. Nuclear fission will probably play a role, but that comes with numerous problems and constraints, including limited natural uranium. Thorium and breeder systems offer the option of centuries to millennia of power, possibly, though again with risks. I'm pretty confident human-controlled energy-positive fusion will never happen. we needn't worry about running out of geologic oil. How long do you propose burning a resource accumulated over a period of ~300m years at a rate 5 million times its rate of formation? I'd linked this paper earlier which details the efficiencies (or lack) in natural kerogenesis --- how petroleum is formed (also coal and natural gas). The process is extremely inefficient. However, it's already happened, and economists, accountants, and policymakers have been eager to ignore and/or deny the costs in time and biomass. I strongly urge you to read it. "Burning Buried Sunshine', Jeffrey S. Dukes, 2003. https://dge.carnegiescience.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.pdf https://dge.carnegiescience.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.... (PDF) In the strictest literal sense, yes, there will be petrolueum in the Earth until the last of it is either subducted through tectonic processes or boiled off as the Sun consumes the Earth. Practical exhaustion will have occurred long before then, probably in coming decades, though precise timing dpeends on numerous factors (demand, technological capabilities, voluntary or forced transitions) and can't be precisely specified. In the practical sense of providing a primary energy source (rather than, say, a material feedstock), petroleum is useful only where it can be extracted for a small fraction of the total energy delivered by that extraction. The term is EROEI -- energy returned on energy invested, coined by Charles A.S. Hall. The days of gushers spouting hundreds of feet into the air seem largely over, as are the days of a single well delivering tens of thousands of barrels a day over a span of nearly 90 years. (See the First Oil Well, Bahrain, as an example, which blew out in 1932: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Oil_Well,_Bahrain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Oil_Well,_Bahrain ). Current fracked wells are expensive to drill, require constant maintenance, and typically have about a 10 year life or so, with rapid fall-off in production after the first few years. Early oil wells delivered a 200:1 EROEI --- 200x the energy output to input. Present operations are in the 20:1 to 10:1 range. Much below 10:1 simply becomes infeasible for energy. That's when the oil stops. It's not a matter of economics, it's a matter of thermodynamics. (Again: I'm omitting pollution and carbon emissions here, they only make the story worse.) The chemistry for synfuels has long been worked out. The molecules cooperate. The process is a variant of what occurs naturally. Because among other issues our fouled-up pricing of petroleum, however, the economics haven't been deemed viable. The Google (Alphabet) Project Foghorn venture was shut down when economic viability proved unattainable. And large-scale production, at a scale sufficient to supply a city or state, let alone nations, has not been developed. But yes, given sufficient energy, fuel for applications in which it cannot be viably substituted should be possible. I've compiled a bibliography of much of the research from the 1940s through the mid-2010s: https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/22k71x/us_navy_electricitytofuel_synthesis_papers_and/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/22k71x/us_navy... https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/29ihl7/us_doe_synthetic_fuel_history_coaltoliquids_and/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/29ihl7/us_doe_... https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/28nqoz/electrical_fuel_synthesis_from_seawater_older/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/28nqoz/electri... I'd updated many of those links in a recent HN comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28970111 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28970111