4 ms·
Justification: We have 2 billion people who need energy. They are going to get that energy, whatever it takes, because we want them to have a decent standard of
by roenxi 5y ago
Justification: We have 2 billion people who need energy. They are going to get that energy, whatever it takes, because we want them to have a decent standard of living.
That is easy to see. Nobody should need to spell that out for the COP26 delegates.
- cinquemb 5y agoI'd like to see the Cop26 president go to rural EM's and personally tell the people, where few to none (state run) corps are really looking to build out any infra for anything, green or not, that they cant use things like coal… Might as well write the eulogy now…
- pavlov 5y agoWhy the assumption that coal is always the cheapest and most easily available? Modern solar is so affordable, it's probably a much more realistic option for those rural areas.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoBecause I can personally buy several kilos of coal for cheap and burn it to produce heat without requiring anything but a pile of it and a ignition source. It can be the middle of the night in a blizzard and I can keep warm without anything special required. Are you really so sheltered to not be able to conceptualize this?
- rPlayer6554 5y agoSure, it's possible that the cost on paper of solar is cheaper. But what about the infrastructure? For instance many people I'm sure live in extremely basic homes that aren't setup to be heated using solar. That alone would cost massive amounts of money they don't have.
- adtac 5y agoIs that without subsidies? Because subsidies are just make believe money to push people in some direction, the money for the infrastructure still has to come from somewhere.
- cinquemb 5y agoSo people who make less than ~$2/day are supposed to now save up (and spend less on food/water/etc) for these "so affordable" panels? And even if they could, how are you going to get those panels (or parts replacements for these "so affordable" systems when they will degrade and break down) to these places that have bad or no roads at scale and struggle to get __anything__ to their regions? And completely eschew local mines and resources that are easier to access with less (upfront) capital? Nuts. I worked remotely for a nigerian fintech that had to do intergrations between the big banks in western africa (and crypto markets) and farmers trying to sell their crops and they pretty much had to get access to capital (which is hard for most people not already intimately connected to wealth/power) to fund __infrastructure__, even before doing anything else (market places local producers/traders getting access global commodity markets via crypto). Even the big banks in nigeria don't even want to fund infrastructure stuff… Same is true for many places i've visited within Indonesia (been living thru ME to east asia since 2016), its crazy to see local news about new airport being built in an area with pretty much nothing there for most people who are quick to overlook these types of things because they take it for granted in their everyday life.
- mayama 5y agoSolar is only cheap when sun is shining bright. Just batteries needed for cloudy days or nights is multiple times more expensive than burning coal. solar+storage might become cheaper than coal by the end of this decade.
- celloductor 5y agoit's not just upfront cost, but the practical costs of using coal is much lower than having to set up a solar infrastructure.
- dredmorbius 5y agoCoal is cheap, available when needed, requires minimal capital (a mud or brick stove), and is used not just for thermal power generation but industrial use (steel production) and direct thermal heat. In areas with minimal infrastructure, all these are compelling advantages. There's that long-term downside of destroying the planet. If your planning horizon is next year, or next month, or next week, that might not be a major consideration. Those who do have a long-term planning horizon must take into consideration those who do not.
- throwoutway 5y agoThe initial cost of installing panels are not cheap, when compared to the continued use of existing coal plants
- Jansen312 5y agoCop26 people live in high castle. Poor people is an ugly sight to them. To them poor people should be driving Tesla and eat from wholefood. If they can't is because they are lazy.
- cinquemb 5y agoCastles of glass and convinced they are made from stone…
- 9999px 5y agoNot to mention a vast percentage of their energy usage is spent on manufacturing for the West. We're essentially off-loading our carbon output to less developed countries then blaming them for it.
- rgbrenner 5y agoThat was true years ago, but China now imports almost as much as it exports. India is a net importer, because their growth strategy isnt focused on manufacturing.
- rocknor 5y ago> That was true years ago Uhh, no. What the parent comment said is true. https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/eys0iw/per_capita_co2_emissions_based_on_consumption_and/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/eys0iw/per...
- yorwba 5y agoThat chart puts China between Greece and Spain in terms of consumption emissions per capita.
- bakuninsbart 5y agoChina is changing extremely quickly, but it isn't enough to simply look at imports vs. exports, but also the kinds of products being exchanged. China still produces more cheap and dirty products than it imports, so the net emissions considering imports/exports are lower than gross emissions. The trajectory is clearly in the direction of more emissions for consumption though, which makes sense as China is still growing richer quickly.
- vimy 5y agoOnly 13 % of Chinese emissions are caused by production for other countries. That 13 % isn’t just the West but the whole world. > "Despite the large total of CO2 imports and exports, US emissions are only 6% higher and Chinese emissions are 13% lower when CO2 transfers are taken into account."https://www.carbonbrief.org/mapped-worlds-largest-co2-importers-exporters https://www.carbonbrief.org/mapped-worlds-largest-co2-import... Twitter thread: https://twitter.com/_HannahRitchie/status/1454410126207721479 https://twitter.com/_HannahRitchie/status/145441012620772147...
- zionic 5y agoIs that really a “justification”? “We bred out of control to absolutely bonkers amounts, and taking X% of the earths resources is non-negotiable”? Imagine if, in the face of climate change, the US response was a movement of 6-8 children per woman. What would that US policy be called?
- thunderbong 5y agoThat isn't quite correct. A lot of population growth in these two countries has been due to improved medical infrastructure which resulted in reduced deaths, for both infants and adults.
- rocknor 5y agoIdiotic comment. The proportion of world population from India and China has been almost constant throughout history. They have not "bred more" than the rest of the world. 6-8 children was the norm even in developed countries in the past, economic prosperity and education changed that. European colonization actively prevented both from occurring in these countries, keeping birth rate high. Post independence, both countries have decreased birth rates drastically, India is at replacement and still decreasing, China below replacement. Stop using that stupid racist argument.
- smnrchrds 5y ago> 6-8 children was the norm even in developed countries in the past I would say that's on the low end. Jean Chrétien was the prime minister of Canada from 1993 to 2003, so politically contemporary with George W. Bush. He was born 18th of 19 children.
- nix23 5y agoLong Winters = Many Children's :)
- dredmorbius 5y agoChina enacted population controls for most of 40 years that frequently attract sharp criticism. India has made family planning widely available, through far less harsh measures. Globally, population growth peaked in 1969, and has fallen fairly consistently since. The largest population growth presently is in Africa, not Asia. Mostly in countries which are desperately poor and which have low past and present carbon emissions. And, as noted, India and China's populations have historically been high. As have their relative shares of global GDP prior to the industrialised era (as calculated in reconstructions, largely by Angus Maddison at the University of Gronigen). https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/#pastfuture https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/#pastfuture https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/?lang=en https://www.rug.nl/ggdc/historicaldevelopment/maddison/?lang...
- dredmorbius 5y agoThis has been the tenor of international discussions on global limits (initially with a focus on population and resource availability, over the past several decades with an increased focus on environmental impacts, most notably climate change) for the past 50--60 years. I'm familiar with discussions dating to the 1970s, in which the Global North (then "first world countries) and the Global South ("third-world", "undeveloped", or "developing" countries) battled over where and how sacrifices should be made. In the interim, China, and to a lesser extent India, have emerged as global economic powers. Both have done so by dramatically increasing their consumption of both energy resources (much of that from coal and other fossil fuels) as well as other natural resources and extreme amounts of ecological disruption and contamination. Much as Western Europe and North America before them. China and India also have some rather sharp history with the UK specificially, which the president of COP26 hasn't referenced, though I'm fairly certain domestic coverage in both countries will play up. Questions of ethics, morality, and justice notwithstanding, what remains is quibbling whilst the world burns, literally and metaphorically. And that quibbling's been going on for well over a half-century (again, with different foci). I'm digging through an excellent 1970s treatment of the general issue, William Ophuls, Ecology and the Politics of Scarcity*. The international dimension begins at roughly page 200. The book as a whole is excellent, as are many of the author's subsequent works, exquisitely researched, argued, written, and referenced. Ophuls's bibliographic notes are a treasure unto themselves. The work is available for purchase, or at the Internet Archive. I recommend it strongly. Originally published in 1977 it was updated in 1994. I somewhat prefer the original in that the track record of its predictions and observations can be checked against a longer span of subsequent history, and with formidable accuracy. https://archive.org/search.php?query=ecology+politics+scarcity+ophuls https://archive.org/search.php?query=ecology+politics+scarci... https://www.worldcat.org/title/ecology-and-the-politics-of-scarcity-revisited-the-unraveling-of-the-american-dream/oclc/260142804 https://www.worldcat.org/title/ecology-and-the-politics-of-s... http://libgen.rs/search.php?req=ophuls+ecology+politics+scarcity&lg_topic=libgen&open=0&view=simple&res=25&phrase=1&column=def http://libgen.rs/search.php?req=ophuls+ecology+politics+scar... The author maintains a website at which he's published numerous more recent essays directly: https://ophuls.org/ https://ophuls.org/
- samarthr1 5y ago