8 ms·
China and India will have to ‘justify’ watered down coal pledge–Cop26 president
- Avalaxy 5y ago> Mr Sharma told the BBC: “I wouldn’t describe what we did yesterday as a failure – it is a historic achievement.” I don't know... On one hand; getting so many parties to agree to _something_ is indeed an impressive achievement, but that fact that we have to have discussions for so long and then settle for a lame watered-down pledge that isn't nearly aggressive enough is really sad. Time is running out, we truly can't afford to play petty politics and think about nationalistic goals. Everyone has to do everything they can to stop the climate change. No more discussions and "blah blah" as Greta calls it.
- Eelongate 5y ago> “But, ultimately, of course, what we need to ensure is that we continue to work on this deal, on these commitments, and on the issue of coal, China and India are going to have to justify to some of the most climate vulnerable countries what happened.” 'Have to', or what? What leverage does he or his organization have over these sovereign nuclear armed nations? If he said 'should' I would not have batted an eye, but talking as though you're in a position of power when you really aren't just makes you seem weak and out of touch. I think this matters, because we need to be realistic about the limitations of a diplomatic/political approach to solving this problem. I am becoming increasingly convinced that a technological solution is more viable than a diplomatic one. A solar sunshade would cost hundreds of billions of dollars, which is not an insurmountable amount of money given the magnitude of the problem. It would not solve the acidification of our oceans, but it would address rising sea levels and temperature-driven severe weather. It's not a great solution, but it might be the best solution that doesn't hinge on diplomatic impossibilities.
- roenxi 5y agoJustification: We have 2 billion people who need energy. They are going to get that energy, whatever it takes, because we want them to have a decent standard of living. That is easy to see. Nobody should need to spell that out for the COP26 delegates.
- cinquemb 5y agoI'd like to see the Cop26 president go to rural EM's and personally tell the people, where few to none (state run) corps are really looking to build out any infra for anything, green or not, that they cant use things like coal… Might as well write the eulogy now…
- pavlov 5y agoWhy the assumption that coal is always the cheapest and most easily available? Modern solar is so affordable, it's probably a much more realistic option for those rural areas.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoBecause I can personally buy several kilos of coal for cheap and burn it to produce heat without requiring anything but a pile of it and a ignition source. It can be the middle of the night in a blizzard and I can keep warm without anything special required. Are you really so sheltered to not be able to conceptualize this?
- rPlayer6554 5y agoSure, it's possible that the cost on paper of solar is cheaper. But what about the infrastructure? For instance many people I'm sure live in extremely basic homes that aren't setup to be heated using solar. That alone would cost massive amounts of money they don't have.
- adtac 5y agoIs that without subsidies? Because subsidies are just make believe money to push people in some direction, the money for the infrastructure still has to come from somewhere.
- cinquemb 5y agoSo people who make less than ~$2/day are supposed to now save up (and spend less on food/water/etc) for these "so affordable" panels? And even if they could, how are you going to get those panels (or parts replacements for these "so affordable" systems when they will degrade and break down) to these places that have bad or no roads at scale and struggle to get __anything__ to their regions? And completely eschew local mines and resources that are easier to access with less (upfront) capital? Nuts. I worked remotely for a nigerian fintech that had to do intergrations between the big banks in western africa (and crypto markets) and farmers trying to sell their crops and they pretty much had to get access to capital (which is hard for most people not already intimately connected to wealth/power) to fund __infrastructure__, even before doing anything else (market places local producers/traders getting access global commodity markets via crypto). Even the big banks in nigeria don't even want to fund infrastructure stuff… Same is true for many places i've visited within Indonesia (been living thru ME to east asia since 2016), its crazy to see local news about new airport being built in an area with pretty much nothing there for most people who are quick to overlook these types of things because they take it for granted in their everyday life.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoI find it very hard to shame China over this considering they have one of the most aggressive rollouts of Solar and Nuclear energy in the world, while the US sits around with its thumbs up our collective butts.
- jdhn 5y agoNo they won't. Does anybody think that the West can shame China into doing anything? India may be more receptive to overtures, but China does its own thing, and at this point doesn't care what the West thinks.
- dqpb 5y agoHere’s my concern - if you believe that people are a real critical ecological threat, then there are exactly two options: coordinated behavior change, or less people. If there is no hope for behavior change, then that means there’s an upside to people dying. Generally, bad things happen when there is an implicit upside to death.
- Jansen312 5y agoChina is a unique case. Shaming do work because of the "face culture". Based on current behavior governing elite in China, I would conclude, it is working to some extend.
- HKH2 5y agoHere's a real example in China: local governments providing a variety of recycling bins, and it all getting thrown into general waste regardless. Does 'saving face' work in that example? How about exporting recycling to China and letting them bury it? You feel good and they earn money. Does it fix anything though? When you get caught, pick a fall guy and continue on your merry way. That's how China has been operating for quite a while.
- powerapple 5y agoplease do not talk about anything you don't understand. Recycling is a process. Putting recycling bins are to educate people and prepare for recycling. Then you build recycling factories to process rubbish you collected. You DO NOT build a factory now and put out bins tomorrow assuming everything will come in place.
- deleted 5y ago
- rahulgoel 5y agoIndian politicians who don’t deliver basic, essential energy will be voted out.
- FridayoLeary 5y agoCop26 president is justifying his title. I imagine this issue is keeping all the world leaders up at night.
- adtac 5y agoI think it's unfair that countries with relatively little cumulative emissions historically (India, China) are made to comply with the same restrictions as countries that have already built a lot of infrastructure with emissions over the past 150 years (e.g. Europe and North America). I know nature doesn't give a fuck about borders and what's fair, and that everyone on this planet is fighting against the same threat, so I don't know what the solution is. I just know this is a problem.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- makotech222 5y agoChina is the only country building nuclear plants in any significant way right now. All western countries have abandoned them, and are only building natgas/coal/oil
- rp1 5y agoUsing the energy to build infrastructure is just the finders fee. Doesn’t make sense to keep doing something known to be unsustainable. That’s a tragedy of the commons
- adtac 5y agoI don't disagree, but I just wish there was a solution that's both fair and, you know, won't cause mass extinction. Maybe that's just not possible.
- rp1 5y agoI guess my point was that a "finders fee" is fair. If you push the boundary of human progress, you're allowed to exploit your discovery a bit.
- rocknor 5y agoFor people wondering what the numbers on cumulative emissions look like: https://www.gapminder.org/tools/#$model$markers$line$data$filter$dimensions$country$country$/$in@=usa&=chn&=gbr&=ind&=can&=rus&=jpn;;;;;;&encoding$y$data$concept=cumulative_co2_emissions_tonnes&space@=country&=time;;&scale$type=linear&domain:null&zoomed:null;;&frame$value=2017;;;;;&chart-type=linechart&url=v1 https://www.gapminder.org/tools/#$model$markers$line$data$fi...
- TedShiller 5y agoIt’s easy to compel those countries: just stop importing from them
- srvmshr 5y agoThere will be a major supply chain crisis if you stop importing from China, India, Pakistan, Bangladesh & Indonesia. It amazes me how even a bar of quality soap comes imported from China nowadays.
- vnchr 5y agoThey can’t do that. They signed the Paris Accords.
- srvmshr 5y agoI hope this answer was a sarcasm or that I misread it. A poor man looking for his next meal will not know anything about Paris accords. He will not certainly elect a leader who will starve them to death over sticking to environment commitments by people living in a high castle. When it comes to developing countries like India, China and Bangladesh - it is a question of subsistence, not comforts. They need rapid growth and cheap energy to come out of poverty and ensure basic quality of life to everyone. Part of the reason, why they can't commit to eliminating coal this fast - without obvious helping-hands from richer countries.
- naruvimama 5y agoAmong the G20 India is the only country to exceed it's commitments. Having already exceed it's renewable energy targets and setting new ambitious targets.
- InTheArena 5y agoAt some point - it's simple. Just pass on a carbon tax on any good, regardless of which country it is created on. Taxed in the country of destination. If India and China decide - last minute - to hold international agreements back - rather then water down agreements just agree it without them, and let them continue to repeat to the rest of the world how "unrespected" they are. To anyone who thinks that this is due just to "fairness" and India's and China's due - go to India. Fly from Bangelore to Hydrabad - a distance of 714 kilometers. It is pea-soup pollution the entire way. Pollution so think it seems like you could dish it up in a bowl. And it's that way at 30,000 ft, in a plane, flying between the two points.
- celloductor 5y agowell it's not simple, because that would mean more taxes for the rich developed countries. their whole agenda is to deflect blame and costs to developing countries.
- nroets 5y agoYes, pass a tax. Not just on goods but also services: Flights, heating, taxi rides, bus tickets, food delivery etc. Before the US consumer can claim any kind of leadership, it they must make some real sacrifices.
- narayanbs 5y ago> Pollution so think it seems like you could dish it up in a bowl. And it's that way at 30,000 ft, in a plane, flying between the two points. What a load of bullc$ap. Even greta thunberg wouldn't make up things like this.
- srvmshr 5y agoPart of the reason developing countries are forced to deal with such pollution is because developed countries have offloaded the manufacturing on markets with cheaper capital investments. London had its peasoupers as recently as late 40s, when it was still in the business of making goods. I find making fun of have-nots from a highcastle of righteousness somewhat disappointing, when its bricks were baked in the homes of these poor gentry.
- 5y ago
- aww_dang 5y agoI find it an interesting contrast of contradictory themes. On one hand there are progressive voices demanding climate action and sustainable development. What is sustainable development in real terms and where does it differ from just plain development? I think you'll find that the real difference is the cost of whatever is being promoted as "development" is much higher or more scarce under the so called, "sustainable" model. Paying climate reparations to the regressive government institutions which hinder development, probably isn't a good strategy if development is the goal. Of course, it is always worth considering if anyone actually cares about development, sustainable or otherwise. Perhaps it is all a song and dance for ulterior motives. Then further down the line, we might ask how this compares to other themes which have been tabooed in the modern age. Take the entire premise of western institutions dictating energy policy to less developed countries. How does that contrast to the theme of colonialism we've been taught to hate so well? What about carbon credits, how does 'global' institution appoint itself as arbiter of carbon consumption and demand payment worldwide? Again, how is this different from the colonialism we've been taught to hate so well? Finally, consider the demonized Christian proselytizers. They are disdained by the secular West and hated by the religious East. These people make the mistake of putting children in school, building homes and bringing aid directly to people in poverty. If only they had chosen to believe in a cult of climate apocalypse and sent funds to government bureaucrats instead...
- dirtyid 5y agoWealthy countries can start by justifying not delivering on the 100B in climate finance first.
- celloductor 5y agoit's just a few weeks of leaders making soft promises to save the environment so they can tick off a box and not have to deal with it the next few years. i think everyone is over the charade.
- darepublic 5y agoPhase out vs phase down is kind of irrelevant. Hides how vague the phrase "phase out" is in the first place.
- amriksohata 5y agoJustification: India was one of the richest countries in the world before the industrial revolution. After years of invasion and loot it was left as one of the poorest. Western countries have built their economies on coal for over 100 years and got rich and still use per head more than India. EU/UK/US carbon output per person is still much higher. Now when India is growing others are telling it needs to change. Well you thrust it upon them, now we can fix this if you fund Indias change and invest to change, otherwise it can't. More info: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-asia-india-59049691 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-asia-india-59049691
- naruvimama 5y agoEven affluent Indians drink boiled/filtered water drawn from wells. It was a surprise to me that in many European countries one could drink straight from the tap. A even bigger shocker was to know that the same water is used for flushing toilets. Treating water to make it drinkable is extremely energy intensive. Making small tweaks to our current setup without a discernable lowering of quality of life is just not comparable to making access to drinking water more expensive.