5 ms·
It's actually an interesting question how nefarious or harmful this actually is. We obviously know why Apple is doing it and why the apps in question don't lik
by Brian_K_White 5y ago
It's actually an interesting question how nefarious or harmful this actually is.
We obviously know why Apple is doing it and why the apps in question don't like it.
But a couple things occurred to me:
You could view this like Amazon giving away your book or android app in a promotion. As I understand it, they still pay the author as if it were a sale, so the author seemingly has nothong to complain about. Even that still seems wrong to me but that's the argument Amazon uses. That is essentially, no, litterally, Amazon advertizing your product for their own purposes.
Another argument Apple and Apple devotees and general "invisible hand" worshippers may try to use is: Any sales generated by the ads would not have existed without the ad, and so it's not taking anything from the app developer.
I don't really buy either theory, but it does take some thinking to describe a mechanism by which they cause harm and should be considered invalid.
They hold enough water to convince a lot of people who want to be convinced, and the arguments against just sound kind of weak and whiny.
- Aulig 5y ago>Any sales generated by the ads would not have existed without the ad, and so it's not taking anything from the app developer. This argument is not very convincing in my opinion, as it looks like Apple is purchasing ads for brand keywords. If the ad wasn't there, the customer would go to the brands website, which would be ranked #1 without the ad.
- quitit 5y agoThe example shows the brand name being ranked 1st. For this to be a poor result for the brand it would require cannibalisation rates to be high enough to push the 15/30% fee higher than their margin - that’s not realistic because the app store price would never be at a loss to begin with (with many alreadying increasing the app store fee to match the 15/30% cut.) In all likelihood the end result is a net profit for the developer at the expense of their competitors. Also neglected for consideration: the developer doesn’t pay for these ads - and the scarcity isn’t high enough to meaningfully affect bid pricing over regular competition.
- notahacker 5y agoIt doesn't need cannibalisation rates to be high enough to push the fee higher than their margin to be worse off, it just needs (delta between direct and App Store margin) * cannibalisation to be greater than the opportunity cost of users who would have given up trying to subscribe to HBO if they hadn't seen Apple's search result [assuming click costs/volume differences roughly even out]. I don't think it's exactly difficult for people to find a link to HBO Max from those results if the one that says "Download the HBO App" isn't there Sure, they still make profit from the Apple signup, but less than they would have done if people were signing up from their website. Needless to say if the App Store price is increased 1:1 to match so the developer definitely doesn't lose, it's a terrible deal for the consumer instead (if you're Googling, it's not even like Apple can claim the App Store is adding value with simplicity of discovery...)
- tmoravec 5y agoWithout the Apple's ad, wouldn't there be some _other_ ad instead? Presumably a competitor's, or the brand's own, paying the Google tax?
- GeneralTspoon 5y agoYes, but if their own ad converts the user to a paying customer, they don't pay 30% of their revenue to Apple.
- RileyJames 5y agoYes, but an ad to a competing product would become very expensive, as it wouldn’t convert and it’s cost (cpc) would increase as it is deemed less relevant. Or the the developer would run their own ad. But those are very different propositions to a middle man running a ‘genuine’ ad which simply takes a cut.
- echelon 5y agoThis shows just how much a monopoly Apple has over brand <—> customer interaction. They say that their app store not allowing side loading is for user safety. In actuality, it forces the brand/company/startup into a place where they're completely shackled. They pay 30% taxes, have no customer relationship, and have to step through every hoop to satisfy apple. The handicap their browser so you can't get new runtimes or deploy software via alternate means. Good luck launching your media startup on iPhone without an app. Now this. They're clearly trying to gobble up any interest in other apps and force them into the payment shackles. This is a fucking monopoly! Please stop this, department of justice! Apple has undue power in computing! Every company has to go through them to reach 50% of consumers, and apple is extorting us! Apple says you're welcome to go to consumers another way, and then they do this. Look at their actions.
- RNCTX 5y ago"nothing will fundamentally change" -- the person currently in charge of the DOJ, when running for office, speaking to donors.
- offtotheraces 5y agoI run a big portfolio of mobile apps, and the discussion around this is misguided. It's not about Apple taking 30% of the revenue generated from these ads. It's about Apple driving up the user acquisition costs for these companies so much so that it become entirely uneconomical for them to buy ads that direct users to their own websites, and instead the campaigns that target users to download the app - which results in 30%-to-Apple IAP subscriptions - become much more attractive again. So Apple is trying to make the cost of running these ads so prohibitive to the companies that they stop trying to drive web subscriptions and instead go back to driving app subscriptions only, where Apple gets 30% of everything. As you can see it's even more sinister than it first appears - it's not a short term land grab, it's a long term strategy to prevent developers from legitimately acquiring users outside of Apple’s walled garden. (Looking at the economics make this even more clear. Let's say Tinder has a $100 subscriber LTV (lifetime value). If the user purchases the subscription in the app, Apple takes $30 of that, so if Tinder wants to run a marketing campaign on Google, Facebook, etc that drives an app install, they can't pay more than $70, otherwise their spend has a negative margin. On the other hand, if tinder can use these ads to get people to subscribe on the Tinder website, they have a ~$97 LTV ($100 minus 3% payment processing fee via stripe/adyen/etc). So now they can run a campaign on Google where they can spend up to $97 to acquire a user, much more than the $70 before. And because Google and Facebook inventory availability scales non-linearly with your maximum bid, a 38% increase in acquisition cost allowable could mean a 100% increase in available inventory, and potentially higher quality inventory at that. But if Apple - with their unlimited cash pile and not caring about negative margins - comes in and soaks up all this inventory by bidding the same $97 for every user, all of a sudden the cost for Tinder to acquire these users goes way up and becomes negative margin. At that point, the rationale thing for tinder to do is stop running these campaigns. This means they stop getting web subscriptions, stop diversifying their business away from Apple, and Apple maintains its iron grip on Tinder. Remember, in this case Apple is paying $97 to acquire a user who will generate $30 for them (30% of the $100 LTV), so they're massively in the hole on this spend. But they don't care because their goal isn't to profitably acquire users; their goal is to make the costs for Tinder to create a more diversified business so high that Tinder stops trying to. That's some f-ed up sh*t.
- renewiltord 5y ago
- makeitdouble 5y agoOn the Amazon part, the harm is caused by your book losing value during the Amazon give away and a while after. For instance any other seller of your book is affected, so you potentially lose distribution channels. Customers also get attracted to Amazon, but your book is only seen as a bait, and when it goes back at the regular price it will be less desirable (some will have negative feelings of having missed the sale, some will keep seeing your book as something only worth giving away). If your book has a short shelf life and you didn’t expect much of it, or if it’s a stepping stone into a series and you could have given it away anyway, Amazon footing the bill is a boon. Otherwise it probably shortens the life of your book.
- schwede 5y agoTo me it’s an issue if Apple refuses to stop if a particular business asks them to. That seems like an easy measuring stick.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoNot sure they can. The dev agreement permanently signs away their refusal.
- lupire 5y agoApple would ban you from app store and therefore all of iOS if you did in the app store what they are doing on Google (advertise to sell subscription via a different channel). Its predatory monopolistic behavior.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoYesterday there was some discussion of "Project Bernanke", so-called "quantitative easing" for DoubleClick's AdX. One could see similarities. Here, Apple is helping certain "preferred" iOS app developers win against other iOS app developers. Apple stands to profit, the preferred developers stand to profit, but not other developers (and possibly users who will never discover their apps). There, Google was helping Google Ads users, i.e., "preferred" DoubleClick AdX auction participants, to win against other participants in AdX auctions. Google profits (and brags about it in its internal presentations), Google Ad users may profit, but not the users of Google Ad alternatives. Big Tech wants to facilitate "winner-take-all" scenarios. Healthy competition and parity amongst competitors (for user attention) reduces the profitability of the "tech" company business model. Big Tech would rather that user attention only be focused on what is most popular, creating more desirability to advertise to that single audience. A "Top 20" mobile app list, or top of page 1 of SERPs. Concentration of web traffic, 80/20, network effects, and so on. Winner-take-all. The most ideal conditions for selling apps or ad services. The issue is not that they are doing this, it is in how are they doing it. They run and control the so-called "platforms" for advertising and sales and use that privileged position to manipulate outcomes that favour themselves. (And stifle competitors.)
- dudus 5y agoExactly and the crux is how can you prove the download would happen regardless of the ad put out by apple . This is an attribution problem on the ad space and nobody has solved it yet. Google has been trying to push complex attribution rules but they are not in a position to do it because they are insentized to attribute the sales to their own ads.
- stefan_ 5y ago"A reseller offering both trade mark goods and competing products is not precluded from using the trade mark in advertising, provided that the reseller safeguards the legitimate interests of the trade mark owner. The German Federal Court has found that if a trade mark is used misleadingly in advertisements originating from a Google search resulting in the exploitation of a trade mark in a way that guides the public to third-party products, such use may provide a ground for the trade mark owner to oppose the use of the trade mark." This was specifically re: Amazon using a trademark in AdWords to redirect sales to Amazon, where they then of course also sell competitor products. This might be moot of course if you granted Apple rights to your trademark in whatever agreements, but then these agreements are also frequently found inapplicable so ymmv.