As presented here, his theory is that the careers of younger scientists depend on the qualitative judgments of older scientists. The field is convinced the jud

As presented here, his theory is that the careers of younger scientists depend on the qualitative judgments of older scientists. The field is convinced the judgments of older scientists are systemically, oppressively wrong on matters of sex and race. So the only acceptable judgment is criticism of the qualitative judgments of older scientists. He can only be un-shunned by criticizing scientists like himself.