3 ms·
Can some explain this guy's Sin in short words for me please? Suggesting the application of metrics to hiring in scientific employment? Suggesting that this met
by h2odragon 5y ago
Can some explain this guy's Sin in short words for me please? Suggesting the application of metrics to hiring in scientific employment? Suggesting that this metric be used instead of another? Could he have discussed the subject in a different way and avoided being shunned by his discipline?
- twofornone 5y agoThe sin is meritocracy. Any system which does not achieve equality of outcome is broken in the eyes of the woke. And they spread their views by bullying people who mostly don't fight back, like this astronomer. It's important to note that he wasn't shunned by his discipline, only a loud untouchable minority. Some animals are more equal than others, after all.
- torstenvl 5y agoCan someone explain why sibling comment is flagged into oblivion? Is there any sound evidence that meritocracy and "equity" are compatible? If not, I don't see why sibling comment's position is false, and I don't see how it breaks site guidelines either.
- dang 5y agoIf you're talking about https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29217720 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29217720, it is clearly an ideological battle comment (almost a prototype actually) and therefore obviously against the site guidelines. We want curious conversation here. Not only do ideological battle and curiosity not overlap, the former destroys the latter, like a tank battle in a city park. If people can't post in the intended curious spirit, they shouldn't post at all; and if they do anyway, flags are the appropriate outcome—no? I'm not sure why this would be unclear.
- torstenvl 5y agoThe article is about a scientist who was pressured into retracting a paper over ideological reasons rather than scientific reasons. It would be understandable if HN were opposed to posts and comments that "do ideological battle," but that doesn't appear to be the case. If HN's editorial policy is that "ideological battle" may be waged with impunity by one side but may not be called out by the other, that's deeply troubling. How can there be curious conversation if an honest and frank discussion is disallowed? There's a huge social upheaval occurring, with a large number of people trying to change the status quo to focus on equity in outcome over equality in opportunity. I respectfully disagree with the idea that selectively stifling speech on just one side of that discussion will somehow make discussion more curious and open, instead of less.
- dang 5y agoEveryone whose favorite side gets moderated thinks that the moderators are secretly favoring the other side*. The thing is, the other side thinks we're favoring yours; I could give you dozens if not hundreds of examples. Here's an old list: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26148870 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26148870 – there are many more than that, and plenty of cases of people attacking us personally for siding with your side, which they perceive as dominating the site. These perceptions are all false; they're determined not by what the moderators are actually doing, or how the site actually is, but by your/their own passions. I think this is literally the most predictable phenomenon that shows up on HN—it's so reliable that one can confidently predict people's politics simply by their assessment of moderator (and/or community) bias. > How can there be curious conversation if an honest and frank discussion is disallowed? An honest and frank discussion is not disallowed. What's disallowed is ideological rhetoric that seeks to defeat the other side instead of relate to it. That's deeply destructive of curiosity. If we were to allow it, it would actually drive everyone who isn't consumed by such passions away from HN, and that would be the death of HN. If you want to smite enemies, there are lots of other places to do it. * https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22always%20feels%22%20mods%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- torstenvl 5y agoNot sure what you think "my side" is, but I appreciate the response. I know you have better things to do. Sorry for the meta-discussion.
- Digory 5y agoAs presented here, his theory is that the careers of younger scientists depend on the qualitative judgments of older scientists. The field is convinced the judgments of older scientists are systemically, oppressively wrong on matters of sex and race. So the only acceptable judgment is criticism of the qualitative judgments of older scientists. He can only be un-shunned by criticizing scientists like himself.
- semol 5y agoI can't speak for the critics because I am not in that particular field and would not have called for its retraction. But having read it, I do think the paper exemplifies a deeply flawed schema for how science works today and how scientists should be judged. In my opinion it shouldn't have been published, at least because it's superficial and doesn't contribute much in practice beyond citations or h index, to the extent those might be used. Should it have been retracted? I don't know and don't really care, to the extent I think there's lots of stuff published in the academic literature that's questionable. The paper makes these assumptions, at least implicitly: (1) that scientific value should be evaluated in terms of contemporaneous reputation of some sort, and (2) that scientific products reflect something in the individual, as opposed to groups, political factors, and so forth. Both of these assumptions are deeply flawed, or in the least, might be seen as controversial. I can't speak to astronomy in particular, but in biomedicine academics has become a sort of FOMO rather than focus on correctness, rigor, or insight. In my areas, large citation counts almost always reflect an idea or evidence being on the mind of lots of people, with a small number just having been first to get it on paper for whatever reason. It's kind of like trivial patents or something, where something has a lot of value but is pretty obvious to anyone knowledgable working in the field. Then on top of that you have the group-work phenomenon where things really reflect the group, and not the individual, but because of promotion, the nature of crowds, etc. certain individuals are always trying to soak up attention like a black hole. Take large observatory projects, or probe missions. Does sending a probe to a planet reflect 1 PI? 2 co-PIs? The team? There's lots of things like this but even more incremental. It also ignores the role of political factors, which are huge. Imagine a computer science department where all of the non-hardware faculty are bullied out of the department by those doing hardware, physics-type research because of a belief on the part of the latter that anything non-hardware based isn't "real science." Junior faculty are threatened, not given tenure, senior faculty have their salaries frozen and are slandered, people leave in droves until they get what they want. Do we judge someone in that type of environment the same as someone who is surrounded by supportive colleagues? Academics is broken, and this paper sort of proceeds as it's not. It's not really about diversity, except to the extent that diversity issues can often be a canary with regard to deeper problems with abuse, dysfunction, and corruption. The short version is this: the paper is circular. Foxes guarding the henhouse, etc.