4 ms·
Look up the Rule of Capture. Under that, the operative law for mineral rights in much of the US, there is no owner of a "wild and migratory" resource beneath l
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Look up the Rule of Capture. Under that, the operative law for mineral rights in much of the US, there is no owner of a "wild and migratory" resource beneath land. There's an incredibly poorly-reasoned (and scientifically counterfactual) 1904 Texas Supreme Court ruling to thank for that.
There are other resource law doctrines, but they tend to treat an unconfined in situ resource similarly in many (though not all) cases.
In practice, what's lead to conservatorship over oil has been either cartels (Standard Oil, the As Is agreement, the Seven Sisters, National Producers, OPEC), state management (the Texas Rangers, Texas Railroad Commission (Because Texas), the US Department of Interior, Norway, or again, state producers (often as state-owned enterprises (SOEs) or partnerships), again: Saudi Arabia, Mexico, Brazil, USSR/Russia, and others.
Daniel Yergin's book The Prize has an amazing history of much of this, in particular chapter 13 covering the East Texas oil boom of the late 1920s / 1930s, which lead to production controls in the US. Absent government control and seizure by force of arms of wellhead production, price per barrel fell to $0.02, under the free market.
What happens as the resource grows scarcer is ... not well understood, and depends on surrounding circumstances. The island nation of Nauru gives one version, where an extractive economy for a resource for which there were in fact other alternatives around the world existed. In the 1970s it had the highest per-capita income on Earth. It no longer does.
An NYT story from its heyday: https://www.nytimes.com/1982/03/07/magazine/world-s-richest-little-isle.html https://www.nytimes.com/1982/03/07/magazine/world-s-richest-...
The story with oil is different in that there is no global alternative that matches its characteristics. The alternatives that do exist were being used previously, and proved insufficient for humanity's appetites. We've grown more gluttonous on what's proved to be a highly limited pantry rather than a cornucopian farmland. After Nauru's phosphate deposits were exhausted, the island's economy collapsed, but the world's did not. With oil and coal deposits declining (barring global warming impacts, which are seem to be matching pace), the $1,000 or so of GDP the US achieves from each barrel of oil consumed will be gain against an ever-rising price of that crucial input. At $30/bbl, the multiplier was 33x costs. At $100/bbl, it is only 3.3x costs. Other nations' productivity per barrel varies from a low of around $400 or so for India to a high of over $3,000 for Switzerland (last I checked, a few years back). That threshold marks a point at which productive economic activity will be very sharply curtailed.
Oil isn't merely a material input, but a motive source that literally makes the world go 'round. It has parlous few alternatives.
- WalterBright 5y agoOil is a hydrocarbon, a family of chemicals consisting of C and H in various configurations. With modern chemistry (I'm not a chemist) I expect it can be fully synthesized with the application of energy to C and H. It's just cheaper to pump it out of the ground. The only element that is non-recoverable is Helium.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYou've changed your argument, just so we're both aware of the fact. The initial argument was that oil is under-priced relative to its full cost of formation. You're now arguing that we can synthesize oil given sufficient energy. The principle value of fossil fuels has been somewhat less their chemical properties than the stored energy that they represent. This is rather like saying one can satiate one's hunger by eating one's arm. The problem isn't filling the belly, the problem is growing and operating the arm. If we do find a viable means of creating synthetic hydrocarbon-based fuels (I've suggested this myself fairly frequently: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adredmorbius%20synthetic%20hydrocarbon&sort=byPopularity&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...), what we'll find is that a properly-functioning market will price those according to their true opportunity costs. Those will reflect the energy and capital inputs. If I understand the research correctly, stored energy will net about 50% of the input. Returned energy from thermal mechanical or generating applications will be about 15--25% of the original input. The cost is a great deal of lost energy, the gain is storage, portability, and availability when needed. The reason oil is "cheaper" to pump out of the ground is, as I began this thread noting, because economics ignores the full costs. And, as I've said previously, under free-market conditions, prices fall to the marginal cost of extraction only (equivalent to the bus fare to the bank), which in 1930s east Texas hit a low of $0.02/bbl. (At the time, $1/bbl was considered a reasonable price.) Note that at the time, the geology and chemistry of formation were poorly understood. The age of the Earth itself had only been firmly established as being in the billions of years, rather than the 6,000 of biblical estimation or perhaps a few hundreds of millions by geological and physics estimates (Lord Kelvin concluding the latter, in the absence of knowledge of radioactivity which could explain the sustained inner heat of the Earth and the Sun's own power source). You might care to avoid bringing the discussion back to previously addressed and dismissed points.