5 ms·
OK, on reflection this is excessively snarky. The background for my comment: I've been peripherally involved with SEO for a couple of years now, and although I
by patio11 15y ago
OK, on reflection this is excessively snarky.
The background for my comment: I've been peripherally involved with SEO for a couple of years now, and although I cherish my white-as-the-driven-snow reputation I know some folks socially who, well, don't. It's an open secret that a huge amount of the internet advertising market is a hive of scum and villainy. We often refer to it as PPC, which in this context means "porn, pills, casino", although there are other industries which have varying levels of sketchiness associated with them -- Make Money Online, government grant scams, ringtones and other rebilling fraud, etc etc etc.
Google has, since the inception of AdWords, made billions of dollars off of these. No joke.
Now, the government is often slow on the uptake, but they're not unaware of this. So here's a conversation which has virtually certainly taken place before:
Government: I see you're advertising X.
Google: We are?
Government: See here.
Google: Oh we are.
Government: You can't advertise X.
Google: We'll get right on that.
12 months pass
Government: You're still advertising X. Did you "get on it?"
Google: Oh yeah, we put some new heuristics in place.
Government: What does a heuristic mean?
Google: The computers guess whether that text means X and if it does, we don't advertise it.
Government: The heuristics seem to be missing quite a bit of X.
Google: Yeah, that happens.
Government: What do you mean "that happens"?
Google: No heuristic is 100% perfect.
Government: OK then, you need to have a human review these to make sure they aren't X or Y or Z.
Google: We don't do that.
Government: ... excuse me?
Google: We prefer scalable methods to manage our advertising programs. After all, there are only about ten thousand of us and we only make tens of billions of dollars with 35% margins.
Government: ... what?
Google: So you see, we won't manually review ads.
Government: This account, how much money has it spent on your ads while not being manually reviewed?
Google: SQL query About a hundred thousand dollars.
Government: Your compliance is not optional. Do you know who we are?
Google: Do you know who we are?
Government: You might think that was a cunning retort but, well, not really.
Edit for P.S.
Speaking of which, take a look at Aaron Wall's screenshot of an AdSense interface which allows you to opt out of having various seedy industries on your website.
http://www.seobook.com/how-make-easy-money-google http://www.seobook.com/how-make-easy-money-google
- tptacek 15y agoThat screenshot is upsetting.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- throwaway4587 15y agoExcept Google employees do manually review ads. Ads that might break the guidelines, such as pharmacy ads, are flagged by the system when they are submitted. Flagged ads are then reviewed manually to see if they comply with policy.
- sbov 15y agoWhich are (were?) probably flagged... through an imperfect heuristic?
- throwaway4587 15y agoCertainly ... and the condemning / damaging thing is the scale of the imperfection. But it's also worth pointing out that many of Google's AdWords policies have long been written to be at the edge of a nexus of the law and public pressure of a market. Pornography, for example. Or "drugs and drug paraphernalia", where bongs and water pipes are prohibited, but vaporisers are allowed if they are advertised as "an aromatherapy device".[1] Which is to say: the pharmacy policy, like others, was likely constructed by Google to get away with as much as possible without damaging the brand or the bottom line. And it hasn't worked. [1] http://adwords.google.com/support/aw/bin/static.py?hl=en-GB&topic=1626336&guide=1316546&page=guide.cs&answer=176024 http://adwords.google.com/support/aw/bin/static.py?hl=en-GB&...
- napierzaza 15y agoSo 500 million dollars worth of ads slipped through? I think you're right, they probably manually went through the ads and approved these sketchy online pharmacies. Does it make Google more or less complicit? The fact is that they don't really have much of a defence when they made 500 million dollars on it. If it was 50$ I think we could all agree some things slip by.
- throwaway4587 15y agoAgreed ... I wasn't suggesting that Google was not at fault, just pointing out that the system for approving ads is not completely automated.
- ntoshev 15y agoHumans are often worse than algorithms. But human mistakes (e.g. in medical practice) are socially acceptable, machine mistakes are not.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- crizCraig 15y agoTaking a look at the keywords with highest cost per day on Google Adwords: http://www.spyfu.com/TopList.aspx?listId=29 http://www.spyfu.com/TopList.aspx?listId=29 "schools nursing" is #1 Third ad to nursingschools.classesusa.com http://www.mywot.com/en/scorecard/classesusa.com http://www.mywot.com/en/scorecard/classesusa.com Pretty scammy. All in all the list doesn't look very upstanding. It would be interesting to see some sort of long tail analysis that cross referenced services like web of trust with data like that from SpyFu.