4 ms·
I highly doubt that reducing the number of channels is a simple efficiency hack, if it was simple to just reduce the density then animals would have had lower d
by Jensson 5y ago
I highly doubt that reducing the number of channels is a simple efficiency hack, if it was simple to just reduce the density then animals would have had lower density just like humans. The question to ask is why humans would benefit from having fewer channels while animals doesn't.
My naïve hunch tells me that this could be related to rationality in some way, that weakening the ion pump signals could make it easier for cells to learn and make alternate computations, creating humans strong rationality that is capable of overriding our natural urges. An animal without significant ability to learn rationally like humans wouldn't have a reason to weaken the signals, so to them they just optimize for signal strength and energy use.
- emmelaich 5y ago> ... then animals would have had lower density just like humans. My just so story would be that those with the higher benefit out-competed (i.e. killed) those primates with somewhat lesser efficiency.
- Aicy 5y agoThe article mentioned thst reducing thr number of channels decreases the energy use, but surely this is for some kind of tradeoff? Would he nice to hear what this might be since the article did not mention or speculate it
- Garlef 5y ago> My naïve hunch tells me that this could be related to rationality in some way, that weakening the ion pump signals could make it easier for cells to learn and make alternate computations, creating humans strong rationality that is capable of overriding our natural urges. That's quite a conclusion you're jumping to... "rationality" is a word denoting a very complex concept obtaining its meaning only through a specific historic background including a lot of assumptions that are not as universal as you might think. I would always be very careful when trying to bridge between 1) A physical phenomenon. 2) Concepts derived through a complex cultural discourse. These are two very separate worlds.
- netcan 5y agoQuite, but I don't think GP is jumping to a conclusion. More like proposing an interesting hypothesis.
- Garlef 5y agoTo say it less politely: To me it seems more like stoner talk. "Quantum entanglement, ... blablabla, ... collective subconscious, ... blablabla, ... everything is connected, man!"
- astrange 5y agoIt seems like early modernism, where they discovered something called radiation existed, and immediately decided it must have superpowered positive effects (curing all diseases) rather than being bad or useless.
- Jensson 5y agoI don't think you understand how science works. The aim isn't to be correct, the aim is to find potential areas of progress. Is my hypothesis here most likely incorrect? Yes, of course it is, but that doesn't matter since if it is correct it would be huge and therefore it is worth exploring. But thanks for your comment, now I understand better how luddites thinks. So in the future when I make comments like above I'll say "this hypothesis is unlikely to be true but...", so that even luddites can understand it.
- mdp2021 5y ago> I don't think you understand how science works I have some understanding of how science works. The purpose remains to find plausible explanations to phenomena, explanations that show some solidity. The same value - linked to grounds - remains valid for statements in general. This is why we refine them, in the internal "lab", where they are tried under duress of criticism. Which is scientific process.
- 5y ago
- swayvil 5y agoI was thinking somewhat similarly. The reduction in channels could mirror a difference in attention-investment. More attention invested in the "thought realm" and less in the "physical realm". Thus our unique facility with thought.
- Ginden 5y agoMany animals aren't under strong pressure to increase efficiency of their brains, because these brain are small and majority of metabolism is put into very basal structures like brainstem. Birds for example were under such evolutionary pressure and look where it got them - Corvidae have 15g brain and they are much smarter than 22g squirell or 30g cat. Moreover, such choices have tradeoffs, improving efficiency often requires more precise regulation that can be nondesirable for small species.
- podgaj 5y agoI do not understand this obsession people have with ranking the "smartness" of animals. Each animals has the intelligence it needs to survive in the niche it lives in. Each is as smart as it needs to be. You say a Corvidae is smarter than a squirrel, but why do you think that matters? Each species survives just fine. Would it benefit the squirrel species survival if they were "smarter"? Or would there just be more of them and then overpopulation and pollution and...oh, I see I am talking about humanity now. ;) You know, the human experiment is far from over, but everyone seems to have our evolutionary survival mapped out like some sci-fi movie that ends up having us colonize the universe.
- Ginden 5y ago> Each is as smart as it needs to be. Petter Watts formulated it in different manner - "all animals are under stringent selection pressure to be as stupid as they can get away with". > Would it benefit the squirrel species survival if they were "smarter"? Probably yes, but this benefit doesn't necessarily outweight greater metabolic cost of sustaining brain. But I was talking about efficiency. Birds achieve much higher intelligence from the same volume of brain than mammals.
- podgaj 5y ago> "all animals are under stringent selection pressure to be as stupid as they can get away with". Thanks for that quote. So maybe that is what humanity is doing by offloading our intelligence to machines, making ourselves stupid? >Birds achieve much higher intelligence from the same volume of brain than mammals. I just have a hard time supposing what "intelligence" means since human intelligence might be much different than bird intelligence. Not higher or lower, but different for different needs.
- jnwatson 5y agoI think the more likely situation was that, given that humans spend so much of their energy in their brains, early humans had high selection pressure to make this process more efficient. We spend roughly 10% of our entire energy budget on those ion channels. Keeping neurons at -70mV takes a lot of work.