3 ms·
> Seems most industries will evolve into a state where you have 2-4 competitors that suppress all competition by building up regulatory hurdles and by their abi
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Seems most industries will evolve into a state where you have 2-4 competitors that suppress all competition by building up regulatory hurdles and by their ability to buy small companies.
This isn't a natural law, it's the point at which antitrust stops letting them buy each other. If it wasn't for that they would merge to monopoly. And that few competitors is enough for them to implicitly or explicitly collude instead of actually competing.
But it only works if barriers to entry are high. Otherwise investors would see profit in going into competition with the cartel. Which is why they lobby for regulatory barriers to prevent that from happening.
> I would be in favor of massively progressive taxation of large companies. I just don’t see the value of them beyond a certain size but I see a lot of danger accumulating so much power in their hands.
What causes this is really the opposite, and what you're suggesting would make it worse.
Corporate expansion is a tax deduction to corporations because corporate income tax is a tax on profit and building new factories etc. to expand vertical integration is a cost. So they'd have more incentive to reinvest all their revenues instead of paying the tax. That's how you get Amazon.
The real problem there is that we double tax corporations. So Ian invests in Apple and his share of Apple's profits are $1000. If Apple pays the money to Ian so he can go invest it in a company that makes electric cars, he has to pay tax on it right away, and then he has less to invest. If he leaves the money inside of Apple and Apple expands into making electric cars, he doesn't have to pay the tax until he sells his shares and gets to earn returns on the money in the meantime.
So then investors have a preference for share price appreciation over dividends, which is equivalent to preferring conglomeration over returning profits to the investor to invest in independent companies. Then we get more and ever-expanding huge conglomerates and less independent companies that do one thing and do it well.
The solution is to make dividends a tax deduction to the corporation. Then corporations with money they don't know what to do with will do that for the tax deduction.
- specialist 5y agoI'm fine with returning to the system of high corporate income taxes, disbursing surplus to investors via dividends, high corporate R&D budgets, pensions, living wages, typical executive to janitor compensation ratio somewhere around 40:1, sustained productivity booms, and whatever other beneficial outcomes we got from the the last keynesian regime. I'm ambivalent about capital gains taxes on individual investors. The rate should probably adapt dynamically, like pick a target number for the gini coefficient (or whatever) and ratchet the tax rate as necessary. I'm completely untroubled by so-called double taxation. Squint and it looks like a VAT. It makes perfect sense to me that most every transaction should be taxed. That's kinda the point.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> The rate should probably adapt dynamically, like pick a target number for the gini coefficient (or whatever) and ratchet the tax rate as necessary. High tax rates on the super rich are kind of this political pablum, where everybody buys into the idea of it because the thinking is Zuckerberg is going to pay all the taxes and then you won't have to, but it doesn't really solve anything. Zuckerberg is never going to spend that much money on consumption. Not even 10% of it. Not even 1% of it. How could you even do that? You only need so much food, so many houses and jets. The problem is that his wealth gives him control over "Meta" and therefore everyone. But that's the same problem even if he's only the CEO. It has little to do with what percentage of the company he owns; somebody's got to be the CEO. The actual problem is that the company's too big. You can't fix that with individual income tax rates. And if you try, the amount of resources that will get poured into tax avoidance will just eat you alive. I mean it already does. Billionaires already shield most of their wealth from taxation whatsoever, so what does it matter the rate? Fix the thing that causes billionaires to exist, namely market concentration that causes the founder of the winning company to be a billionaire instead of there being a thousand competing companies whose founders are all millionaires. > I'm completely untroubled by so-called double taxation. Squint and it looks like a VAT. This is completely the opposite of VAT. The whole point of VAT is that it isn't double taxation -- if a business buys wholesale for $80 and sells retail for $100, they only have to collect VAT on the $20 difference and not the whole $100, because the wholesale seller already collected it on the $80. To do otherwise creates a massive incentive for vertical integration because if the wholesaler buys the retailer outright they wouldn't have to pay it twice. And so it is with corporate dividends.
- specialist 5y agoI have no opinion on the capital gains tax rate (for individuals). Just that it's dynamically adjusted as needed to meet a defined policy goal. Like reducing inequity. The never ending tug of war drives me nuts. I get that rhetoric about taxes is more about campaigns than policy. And I don't know that capital gains rax rate is even the most important parameter. So while I'm totally fine with repeated radical cachectomies, I'm also fine with simply rolling back GWB & Trump tax breaks, or Warren's 2% wealth tax. Whatever works. I can't recall previously disagreeing with anything you've written. So I'm pretty sure I misunderstood your point about double taxation.