4 ms·
On the topic of synth chips, does anyone have any good resource talking about why those big retro synths still exist? There’s got to be a good reason I simply
by Waterluvian 5y ago
On the topic of synth chips, does anyone have any good resource talking about why those big retro synths still exist?
There’s got to be a good reason I simply don’t understand for why a computer cannot replicate everything those massive pieces of furniture do.
The one thing I concluded is that their interface, with hundreds of knobs and potentiometers must be very nice to interact with. But can they not just house a computer inside?
I guess my curiosity and ignorance boils down to: why can’t computers generate all the kinds of signals that these big synths do?
Edit: a bulk thank you for all these helpful responses.
- jb1991 5y agoThere is quite a big difference between a digital sound and an analog sound, and even among digital sounds, there is a big difference between a software program making sounds and a digital hardware circuit that is architected specifically for making particular types of sounds.
- Waterluvian 5y agoThanks! What might I search for to understand this detectable and quantifiable difference (vs. Monster cable style subjective feelings about sound)?
- 323 5y agoIt's mostly that hardware makers invested more time and money into the algorithms to make them more pleasantly sounding. Many software synths are one-man projects which has to do it all (DSP, UI, ...) Hardware makers also have proprietary institutional knowledge, since you can have a couple persons who researched synthesis methods for 10 years. They also work with users to tweak the sound and interface to perfection.
- rotexo 5y agoI don’t have any resources for you, but I will say that there are a lot of synth emulations out there (for instance, google “dx7 vst”). Developers might be more or less obsessive about emulating the particular quirks of different hardware synths, but I can’t say how significant those details are. I guess it comes down to the listener’s ears. Some people like having vintage synths because they are collectors, and some like the workflow surrounding them (ie, the big front panel of knobs and faders you allude to, or the simplicity of plugging in audio and/or control voltage and/or midi cables).
- martyvis 5y agoI listened to this "shootout" video only two days ago. The different ones tested here all have their quirks. (I've been playing with Dexed as it has all the original features and is free). https://youtu.be/vMvGk_fcIo8 https://youtu.be/vMvGk_fcIo8
- 323 5y agoOne factor is analysis paralysis. On a computer you can have 100 different software synths, which can be daunting. Having 2-3 quality hardware synths can force you to get things done and not get lost in minutiae. Of course, there are also modern producers which are very effective with software only.
- spookthesunset 5y agoThat is one of the biggest hurdles I have whenever I attempt to play around with fancy synths… lots and lots of options. Very easy to get completely lost in the weeds.
- lewispollard 5y agoFor digital synths, yeah they can be fully emulated afaik. With the actual hardware unit, you get the knobs and keys, sure, but it's basically an embedded device, the OS and synth functions are tightly integrated. Which means nothing competing for the scheduler, latency practically 0. Plus they come with all the standard inputs and outputs needed for performance over a PA. By comparison a laptop is a bit of a liability. Who knows when some system service is gonna activate and add latency, or cause a freeze, or stall the audio driver, or something. Plus you then have to lug around all these adaptors and cables and external devices, for the I/O that you need that isn't built into a laptop. If you're a performance artist anyway, it's not as big a deal in the studio. For analog synths, well they can also be emulated quite accurately, but the way they produce sound is just fundamentally different to digital synthesis. They're directly manipulating the voltage of current to get oscillation, and then manipulate that signal to drive the speaker and produce sound. This process can be emulated but it doesn't produce the same output in a physical sense. It's questionable whether a typical audience would notice the difference I guess, but there's something quite raw and visceral about using an analog synth.
- post-it 5y agoI'm not a sound engineer or anything, but I've noticed that dedicated audio equipment is really fast - there's always zero perceptible latency, even in a complex system that uses a bunch of different boards connected together. It's hard to make very low-latency software because of all the layers of abstraction between applications and the OS and various hardware buffers.
- jacquesm 5y agoAnd software buffers! Those are usually much worse than the hardware ones.
- aspenmayer 5y agoFor a look at what it takes for a clean room reimplementation of this same synth: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJ97iXQrqzw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJ97iXQrqzw
- DennisP 5y agoIn principle they can, in practice the limitations on processing power have caused the sounds they produce to lack the richness of analog. They're getting better though. The thing about analog is that you get a lot of random variation in the waveforms. A naive computer implementation will lack that variation. A better one will purposely add particular random variations. The really good ones, like Diva (which runs on a regular computer), will run SPICE-style simulations of the actual analog circuitry, but running that at full fidelity is still pretty processor-intensive. There are lots digital hardware synths that emulate analog. There are also hybrids, like Novation's Summit and Peak. These start with digital sound generation, but using FPGA to run at a much higher sample rate (24 MHz instead of the typical 48 to 96 kHz). Then they convert to an analog signal that runs through analog filters, then they convert back to digital for effects (reverb and such). The advantage of starting with digital here is that it can start with different waveforms than the ones easily generated by analog circuits. Further muddying the waters, modern analog synths have components with a lot more precision than in the old days, so they also lack some of the random variation of the old stuff. That's great for staying in tune, but now synths like the OB6, which is pure analog, have added "vintage" features which artificially add the variations again.
- mrob 5y agoModern software simulations are very accurate for conventional VCO-to-VCA-to-VCF type sounds, but struggle with audio frequency modulation of control voltages. Aaron Lanterman includes an example of this in his excellent lecture series on analog synthesis: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZz8PJCfK1c&t=452s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZz8PJCfK1c&t=452s
- DennisP 5y agoThat looks like a really interesting course.
- lvl100 5y agoIf you look at DAW and plug-in offerings they have a lot of these in digital format. But you’re right about having actual physical controls is very different. And I do think there will be a completely custom audio interface/keyboard/synth in the next couple of years (this is a side project of mine).
- detaro 5y agoFew points: a) people like having the original thing, even if it can be replicated. (I think this generalizes fairly far across musical instruments, old ones are always coveted by some, and into many different topics) b) Limitations of the circuitry etc that affect the sound can be surprisingly hard to precisely simulate. For cult machines that's probably something someone has done, but it's a lot of work. c) as you said, physical interfaces are important, as are the restrictions of what an instrument can't do the guide where people go with it d) people will fight tooth and nail about b) and if a specific simulation is good or not - and often you can assume that the range of how the originals sound is actually also quite large (especially now, with the components having aged a few decades), so you'll always find someone who is sure the software doesn't sound exactly like the one specific device they compare it to.
- al2o3cr 5y agoBut can they not just house a computer inside? A lot of modern modules _do_ just have a computer inside - for an open-source example, many of the Mutable Instruments modules use AVR or STM32 controllers: https://github.com/pichenettes/eurorack https://github.com/pichenettes/eurorack
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoAnalog has a lot of detail that digital doesn't. Real circuits are imperfect in all kinds of interesting ways. It's not just randomness, it's specific kinds of non-ideal operation - distortion, non-linearity, noise distributions, and other fine details. It's trivially easy to make idealised digital models of VCO-VCF-VCA but they sound sterile and boring. The more imperfections you model the richer and more interesting the sound get, but the more processing power you need. Good models - especially good models of analog filters - are incredibly difficult to design. And even the best aren't as smooth as the real thing, because - for example - with a filter you may have to recalculate a load of coefficients for every sample. A lot of digital models get in the ballpark now, but very few do better than that. And there's a fair amount of secrecy among DSP coders. There's no mystery about the basics, but the manufacturers like to keep the best models to themselves. So the big computer music tools - like Csound and Supercollider - have third or fourth rate models that are a good few generations behind the latest code. So it's still hard to get comparable sounds of pure digital synthesis. The new M1 chips are fast enough for better models, but you'd need about 5X to 50X the processing power - and more research - for no-compromise digital replacements of vintage analog hardware.