4 ms·
There is an important thing missing: In order to prove that someone is dead, you must do electroencephalography. This will detect the brain electric charges. No
by csomar 15y ago
There is an important thing missing: In order to prove that someone is dead, you must do electroencephalography. This will detect the brain electric charges. Normally, since the patient isn't dead, there will be brain pulses, which will prove he is alive.
- carbocation 15y agoIn which country is it required that a physician perform an EEG prior to declaring death?
- csomar 15y agoI don't know. I'm a medical student in Tunisia. Here, in order to claim that a patient is dead you need to show its' EEG graph. Well, what's happening is something else.
- mikaelgramont 15y agoAn EEG is probably necessary for official reasons, before a "certificate of death" can be issued. But there is a point where the emergency rescuers have to give up, and it probably takes hours before the EEG can be done.
- sp332 15y agoMaybe when the person is already on life support, and you're trying to make a decision about whether the person is "dead" even if most of their organs are alive.
- typicalrunt 15y agoThen what about the wave of death [1] that happens to people? The body can still release pent up energy well after brain death, but it doesn't necessarily mean the person can be brought back to life. [1] http://news.discovery.com/human/near-death-brain.html http://news.discovery.com/human/near-death-brain.html
- csomar 15y agoThe wave described in this article is actually atypical brain activity. This confirm that the brain is unstable and the person may be facing his last minutes. This actually make the EEG more precise.
- Hoff 15y agoThere are differences among the laws and norms of local and national jurisdictions, and among pre-hospital and hospital providers. Depending on local laws, US emergency services field providers usually don't officially declare legal death, though there are protocols for either not commencing or for ceasing resuscitation efforts. These don't involve electroencephalography. Factors input in this decision and these protocols vary, but can include evidence of insufficient structures for maintaining life (eg: decapitation), absence of vitals, rigor, lividity (blood pooling), absent electrocardiogram, rescuer exhaustion, and (for cases involving cardiac) failure of defibrillation and advanced cardiac life support where applicable. These factors are usually used in combinations; you need more than one of these, and no vitals. Contraventions can include hypothermia, which may have been a factor in the cited case, and cold-water drowning. Many of these cases can and do involve a consultation with the patient's physician, or with the emergency physician Emergency transport of patients that are presumed dead is not without risks to members of the community and to the EMS crew; these can include vehicular collisions with emergency vehicles, as well as simply not the crew unavailable for another call. Funding also applies, as survival to discharge is (in various studies) not expected in cases where pre-hospital advanced cardiac life support (ACLS) has been administered, and has failed. (If ACLS didn't work in the field, it's equally unlikely to work after a five or fifteen or half-hour transport to an emergency facility.) I'm not aware of any US emergency services field providers that are using electroencephalography for this nor any field equipment for this, nor even any discussions of its applicability in the field. On the other hand, capnography has been a subject of various discussions for some years now among emergency physicians and hospitals and field providers, including its use for assessing correct placement of breathing tubes, and waveforms for differentiating various respiratory dysfunctions.
- goatforce5 15y agoI've had paramedics tell me they'll go beyond what the protocols say to try to resuscitate people because they won't the extra paperwork involved in dealing with a death. A paramedic I know failed to revive an elderly woman who'd collapsed at home. The rescue attempts were watched by the woman's (panicked) daughter, who was a nurse. The daughter later threatened to sue, saying he was negligent for not performing a procedure that she thought was necessary. Paramedic was called before some lawyers, at which point they found out he'd actually done a lot more than protocol had required in those circumstances, and the case was dropped. Nice way to say thanks for trying to save your mom.