3 ms·
But the argument is always the same. The largest amount of labor used to be farm labor. Used to be 95% of the population. No innovation today comes even remote
by panick21_ 5y ago
But the argument is always the same. The largest amount of labor used to be farm labor. Used to be 95% of the population.
No innovation today comes even remotely close disrupting that large a % of the population.
One of the most labor intensive things humans did for 1000s of years was making of cloth, an absurd amount of work. That was as well disrupted.
The pace of labor disruption today is WAY slower and the dynamic economy is WAY faster at producing new uses of labor. Hence why we have not actual seen this supposed collapse in the amount of required labor despite an endless parade of supposedly smart people predicting it for 200 years straight.
- agumonkey 5y agoI still don't agree about the similarity today. Every step in the past created a new layer (if I get your point), by virtue of being new, couldn't be solved so humans were involved to do it. But what's new to be done now ? Technology is wrapping around all layers of the pyramid, from mechanical to factories to information to "intelligence" (to an extent). I honestly fail to see what it won't be able to handle. Especially considering how lame most jobs are today[0] I don't think it will hold long. [0] I've ranted about it so many times but it reaches absurd levels .. people are not doing much, and the few that is asked of them is ridiculous. Plus it's often done through coercion by mediocre management that nobody respect (causing immense political friction, paranoia and misery.. most of my colleagues delay work and watch tik tok .. after talking to them the main reason is that nothing is working right nobody care, thus nobody wants to work anymore).
- panick21_ 5y agoAt every point the smartest people asked 'But what's new to be done now ?'. Turns out even the smartest people don't know the future. At a certain point its realizing that your own limitation if imagination is what preventing you from predicting the future. Again, at every point over the last 200 years smart people were sitting around asking this same question, finding the same answers and then promptly be totally wrong. How many times does it need to happen before you believe a historical pattern rather then your own limited predictive capability. Fact is, if anything, labor is the limiting factor for a lot of things we would want to do. > Especially considering how lame most jobs are today Jobs today are generally less lame then the past. This is another Marxist myth, alienation doesn't hold up.