4 ms·
>> But we should still empathize with and consider the needs of those workers less privileged than ourselves Why? Or else what? They might look for better jobs
by noduerme 5y ago
>> But we should still empathize with and consider the needs of those workers less privileged than ourselves
Why? Or else what? They might look for better jobs?
- geon 5y agoOr else you are not a good person.
- idiocratic 5y agoNot everyone can have a better job. Sorry but your comment reveals how little empathy we, software engineers, can have at times.
- noduerme 5y ago>> Not everyone can have a better job I'd counter that your comment reveals disdain for people who you wrongly assume can't improve their skills or economic outlook. I could make a long list of people I know who taught themselves new skills and leveled up to new jobs - code or otherwise - without the need for "empathy" from someone who was certain they were less "privileged" and therefore should be pitied.
- apocolyps6 5y agoSo for the 97% of humanity that are worse off than american software engineers, you think they are just not trying hard enough?
- noduerme 5y agoYou might have way too high an idea of the place software engineers occupy in the economic and social hierarchy. We're trash compared to the money people. I just choose not to be angry about it, so I hope the guy serving me a burger chooses not to be angry about my job placement too; I'm more than happy to tutor him.
- eggsmediumrare 5y agoReasonable employment standards aren't "pity." Nor is empathy, actually.
- xkqd 5y agoI read that remark as, "in the grand scheme of things, we can't all have it good." - not as anything marked with disdain. As for my own opinion? I don't think there's a stone software engineers are cut from, but I don't think most people could be effective at working on technology without dramatic improvements in a few different key areas between analytical (data driven) thinking and layered abstractions. It's not that these things can't be learned - I certainly didn't learn these from my blue collar parents. It's that it takes significant investment of time that many adults can't dedicate.
- noduerme 5y agoI view us (coders) as plumbers or car mechanics; and I'm certainly not a good plumber, and only a very primitive mechanic. One will pay me $200/hr for my time fixing software and I'll pay them $200/hr back to fix my car or my plumbing. Anyone can learn a trade if they take the time to study and become proficient. I don't think it requires "privilege". Maybe twenty years ago you grew up too poor to have a computer in the house, but you certainly had a car or a toilet. And so some people learned to be proficient at fixing things, and other people ...? Not so much. But that's okay, because as you said, not everyone can be effective at working on technology. However, that doesn't mean that the world needs to bend over backwards for people who can't get proficient at something.
- onion2k 5y agoAny individual can get a better job. But not every individual. There aren't enough good jobs, and society would collapse if all the retail workers, bin men, teachers, nurses, etc suddenly became software engineers.
- noduerme 5y agoOkay, but you're disregarding both new hires and seniority. I know a garbage man who's a poet and makes $100k a year, with health care and a pension. Other people who have that job for a year or two might decide to move into a different field. There are more people being born all the time. They start somewhere and move on. I served when I was in my 20s. Now I'm served by people in their 20s. So?
- idiocratic 5y agoOthers already replied in useful ways that reflect my thoughts here. I know some people can and will make it, but it’s definitely not for everyone or even the majority of them, especially here in southern Europe. Think mums with kids doing 9 to 6, men in their 50s doing shitty jobs in shitty companies, young professionals living with their parents because they can’t afford to pay rent. Yes, they could go abroad and reinvent themselves, making a substantial improvement to their quality of life, etc. But in the meantime I like that our governments take steps to regulate overworking and crazy demands for those who don’t give a shit about their work beyond getting their salary and moving on with their life. I empathise and understand their context, even if I’m in a quite different situation. That’s empathy, not pitying others because they are less privileged than me. Maybe they are even happier than I am, who am I to judge?
- throwaway2331 5y agoDrug use, crime, violence, short-term thinking, ad nauseum. The majority of the population is working low-skilled, low-pay, low-satisfaction jobs. The people that do the shitty work (cleaning, cooking, serving, building, maintaining, etc.) are supporting the more privileged way of life. Circumstances aren't bad enough yet for all of them to go full Roman and stab the professional ("laptop") class while they're walking in the street or working in a cafe; but that doesn't mean all that negative emotional tension brought upon the working class is simply isolated, and has no reverberating impact on the greater world. However, were these circumstances left to deteriorate enough -- i.e. the negative emotions start overflowing and can no longer be subdued by drug use and other outlets, e.g. when one is starving -- then you're one internet meme away from getting your house molotov'ed and dragged out into the street. I for one don't mind making life a little bit easier for the working class. In this case it would likely be preventing managers from texting un-scheduled workers: "I need you to come in tomorrow to fill someone's shift" (a request that usually entails one's job being on the line).
- noduerme 5y agoI vote left because I consider it this type of value proposition: If people have no help and no way out of poverty, they'll revolt, and that'll be bad for me. But there is another, countervailing aspect. People think they have no alternative if they live in a society that provides no upward mobility. I happen to live in a country (the US) that provides the greatest degree of upward mobility in the world, which is why immigrants from every other country come here. But there are people here who, out of a form of sanctimony disguised as "empathy", want to insist to people in service jobs that they are permanently stuck there and should view themselves as members of a oppressed class, rather than emphasizing (let alone providing) the opportunities for people to reach their highest potential. We're not the UK, let alone Russia. I was a taxi driver. Numerous former bartenders I know own houses and work in tech. Friends who were barely employable ten years ago are now master carpenters, mechanics, or truck drivers with several trucks. And some are "professional", if you consider coding professional. I think it's more like plumbing without a license. My point is that pity and putting people in a box with hoity-toity empathy and little handouts is degrading and belittling, and saying they have to have those jobs forever is essentially a backhanded way for people to seem empathetic but actually guarantee that the existing hierarchy remains.
- eggsmediumrare 5y agoThis line of thinking falls apart if you think about it for more than 30 seconds. Unfortunately, people don't do that and end up creating legislation with this assumption... That people could just get better jobs (and the implication that they don't because they're lazy). It makes no sense, though. Who is going to clear tables and wash dishes? Who is going to pick fruit? I picked fruit as a teenager. It sucked. I hated every minute of it, but it has to happen. Your suggestion seems to be making it suck more than it has to in the name of what... motivation? Why not make it possible for every member of our society to live a decent life, even if they happen to not have the necessary faculties (not to mention money, support and time) to be an engineer?
- xkqd 5y ago> I picked fruit as a teenager. It sucked. I hated every minute of it, but it has to happen. And I dug holes by hand and loaded trucks with tractors. I've started to realize that when I share that fact with people, they either look down on you as an animal, or they realize you can do more than close Jira stories. I don't think the second group is common.
- wpietri 5y agoPersonally, working non-software jobs has been hugely helpful for me in my professional work. I've learned things from every "lesser" job. Many people who have only had professional jobs, especially those in the former group you mention, have no idea how limited their perspectives are.
- noduerme 5y agoNothing of the kind. I think everyone should have to pick fruit, wash cars, wait tables, drive taxis, stock shelves, work construction, answer phones, cook at a fast food restaurant, or join the military. Not go to college and eat on their parents dime. And they should do those things as a life lesson on their way to becoming a doctor, an engineer, an artist, a jurist, a philosopher or a writer. This is how life is actually discovered. People who are born rich never do anything of value. Bitching about picking fruit, while you're doing it, is fine. But then let's get on with it and stop viewing it as if it's a permanent form of oppression. FWIW I'd definitely hire someone who picked fruit and could write decent code versus someone who had a CS degree.
- Dudeman112 5y agoThe omnissiah hasn't quite reached us yet. You think you'll keep your quality of life if literally no one wants to lay bricks and stack shelves? Let people's lives be miserable enough and they'll stab you and eat you instead of working.