4 ms·
A thousand times this! Scientists and mathematicians should be embracing cold hard reality instead of wallowing in self-aggrandising mysticism. That's the poin
by jiggawatts 5y ago
A thousand times this!
Scientists and mathematicians should be embracing cold hard reality instead of wallowing in self-aggrandising mysticism. That's the point of science! Empiricism and rationality is are its distinguishing features. These elevate it above the near-worthless philosophies that it replaced.
The worst offender by far in the mainstream sciences is Quantum Mechanics, which is absolutely infested with woo and self-contradictory nonsense. Its overuse of complex numbers is just the beginning.
Mysterious action at a distance isn't mysterious and isn't action at a distance at all.
The electromagnetic field is made up of continuous waves filling space, there are no point-like photon particles. That was just a mathematical abstraction -- a convenient shorthand term for describing interactions with matter, and shouldn't be taken literally.
Electrons aren't little hard balls, which is why they don't rotate, and this is why spin isn't some huge mystery.
Etc...
- wyager 5y agoAt some point you’re stuck with a bunch of equations that work and the only way to make progress is to try to interpret the equations. > Electrons aren't little hard balls, which is why they don't rotate, and this is why spin isn't some huge mystery. This doesn’t clarify spin at all. Spin is actually incredibly weird and anyone who writes it off probably doesn’t understand what’s interesting about spin quantization, spin/angular momentum noncommutativity, fermions obeying SU(2) instead of SO(3) rotation characteristics, etc.
- ncmncm 5y agoYet, the only instruments we can build pick up particles, and nothing but particles. Maxwell's electromagnetics, and his field waves, are a useful approximation. But as close as we have been able to measure, the Schroedinger equation is an exact description: of waves that resolve to probability of the detection of a particle. There are things to complain about in our description of the universe with particles: magic numbers that can only be measured, not deduced. But incorrectness isn't one of them. "Spin" is just a name.
- jiggawatts 5y ago> the only instruments we can build pick up particles In general, this is not true. As in, there are experiments we can build that demonstrate that the wave nature of light is the true description. Where people get confused is that practically all instruments are made of matter. Atoms, or at least a plasma or even individual particles, but matter nonetheless. If "particle behaviours" is a property of matter, and you have only experiments made of matter, then this tells you nothing about the behaviour of light, which is not matter. This is like basic experimental science 101. Beginner stuff. Isolate the thing you are testing, and test it, and only it. This is hard to do, but not entirely impossible. Try harder to be a scientist and stop reiterating woo that you picked up from textbooks that copied it verbatim from people that died nearly 100 years ago. (The same people that thought that a human looking at an experiment was somehow an essential aspect, leading to a century of stupid people arguing about whether a brain is necessary for physics to occur!)