3 ms·
In the context it was written, it was pretty good advice. Maybe a bit too far on some points, but it was a solid step in a good direction. This caused the book
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
In the context it was written, it was pretty good advice. Maybe a bit too far on some points, but it was a solid step in a good direction. This caused the book to be praised. But we tend to elevate praised books well beyond what's reasonable, dogmatically follow their advice even when they cause problems, and recommend them even though they're responses to a discussion that nobody has been having for 15 years. Same with Gang of Four and a bunch of other books.