2 ms·
You can’t rate 0 stars so the entire range is shifted by 1 star. This makes any star rating system fatally flawed to begin with. Humans will see 3 stars and no
by Waterluvian 5y ago
You can’t rate 0 stars so the entire range is shifted by 1 star. This makes any star rating system fatally flawed to begin with.
Humans will see 3 stars and not perceive that as 50%.
- feoren 5y agoIs that really a fatal flaw? It's humans reading the ratings, and humans doing the ratings, so our human-factors might balance out a bit. I don't think people come in expecting the rating system to be perfectly linear because we have a mental model of how other humans rate things -- 1 star and 5 stars are very common, even when there's obviously ways the thing could be worse/better. So even though 3 stars sounds like more than 50%, most people would consider 3.0 stars a very poor rating.
- Waterluvian 5y agoI think you make a good point. But I don’t think it completely defeats the bias. Especially given that the star system that existed before the Web had 0 and half stars. It seems like it’s purely a result of widget design deficiency: how do you turn a null into a 0 with a star widget? (You could add an extra button but naturally designers will poo poo that)
- Macha 5y agoPercentage systems aren't immune to this, various pieces of games media were often accused of a 70-100% rating scale. Anything below 70 was perceived as a terrible game, and they didn't want to harm their relationship with publishers. So 70 became the "You might like it if there are some specifics that appeal to you" and 80 was a pretty average game.