3 ms·
So you care about a thousand-year problem but forget about the 50-year problem (climate change).
by fsflover 5y ago
So you care about a thousand-year problem but forget about the 50-year problem (climate change).
- bryanlarsen 5y ago50 year problem? Climate change is an 8 year problem. That's the main reason that nuclear is infeasible, we can't do it in 8 years. We should have started building 100s of nuclear reactors 20 years ago. Doing it now is too late. Wind & solar + batteries can be built much quicker.
- an9n 5y agoWhat are you going to make the batteries from - lithium? That comes with its own host of terrible impacts that people seem to be keen to brush under the carpet.
- daneel_w 5y agoThe majority of lithium is extracted through passive evaporation of brine, not from ore mining. The impact is far less horrible than mining copper, gold, silver, platinum and so on. I'd wager that you have conveniently forgotten about these metals in your environmental argument.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoLithium, yes. I am very comfortable trading the existential threat of climate change, the local environmental damage caused by fossil fuel particulates, and the massive damage done by fossil fuel extraction for the damage caused by lithium extraction. The quantities of lithium required are a couple of orders of magnitude less than the quantities of oil we extract annually. There are a good half dozen viable methods of extracting lithium. Some are substantially cleaner than others, which are the ones we should use.
- p_l 5y agoAnd still won't work in 8 year timescale because of their intermittence and that batteries are a bit like fusion.
- fsflover 5y agoSo you suggest to do nothing? Don't start with renewables, they aren't providing enough power and stability in the next 8 years.
- ben_w 5y agoIf the literally exponential growth in PV from 1992-today lasts another 8 years, it will have a nameplate capacity of 12 TW. Growth of storage is more of an open question, but not inconceivable, and even a partial improvement gives more time to do the rest. (And the timescale sounds more like the timescale for actually taking this seriously than the timescale for fully solving it, though I definitely hope that isn’t just me listening to what I want to be true).
- caeril 5y agoOur very first production civilian reactors went from no design and bare land to production in about 4.5 years. Modern engineering, siting, and construction is tied up with regulatory approval processes, safety protocols, diversity and inclusion quotas, and NIMBYism that occupy the vast majority of timelines. A prior civilization would have looked at a literal existential threat and been willing to risk a few desert turtles, a few extra construction workers' lives, and ignored some Karens to get the job done. But we don't have that kind of civilization anymore. Regulation and safety protocols are great for societies not sitting at the edge of the Seneca Cliff, but they're pretty terrible when the ELE meteorite is en route.