4 ms·
Basically all of these things are teething problems. The early adopters have problems, the problems get solved, then they're solved for everybody. What's going
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
Basically all of these things are teething problems. The early adopters have problems, the problems get solved, then they're solved for everybody.
What's going to be interesting is how attorney client privilege interacts with the third party doctrine and proprietary systems increasingly moving your documents to The Cloud, often without telling you or making it obvious that it's happening.
That could drive early adoption by law firms that don't want to be the first to get burned by that.
- tubby12345 5y ago>The early adopters have problems > LibreOffice Initial release: 25 January 2011; 10 years ago don't think it's getting solved mated
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoDifferent populations have different problems. When was the first time it was adopted by a major law firm? Example: The OP cares about "redlines" because lawyers use that all the time and most others don't.
- RNCTX 5y agoI worked for one of the online legal databases for several years. They had a Windows desktop app in addition to the website for accessing content. I managed to get the desktop app working in Linux after messing with Wine and permissions (it had some cache files written to a relative directory and what not) and after telling management about it they figured the potential market for such a thing would be small enough that they could just send any support requests about it directly to me for setup help, and likewise tell the sales reps to forward inquiries to me if Linux came up on a sale or demo install. In the decade I worked there I got exactly one call from a Linux admin at a law firm asking for the docs on using the desktop app.
- npongratz 5y agoIt gets even worse. LibreOffice forked from OpenOffice [0]: > OpenOffice.org Initial release May 2002; 19 years ago Which itself originated as StarOffice [1]: > StarOffice Initial release 1985; 36 years ago [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Openoffice.org https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Openoffice.org [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StarOffice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StarOffice
- tiahura 5y ago“What's going to be interesting is how attorney client privilege interacts with the third party doctrine” Not really. If I take a file to Kinkos to get copied, it’s still privileged. Contrary to the thinking of many technophiles, for almost every “How is the law going to deal with X technology?” there are useful analogies that were figured out decades ago.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Not really. If I take a file to Kinkos to get copied, it’s still privileged. What happens if you take a file to Kinkos to get copied and don't notice that the service agreement allows them to keep a copy of it and sell the contents to third parties or use it for advertising?
- tiahura 5y agoStill privileged. Jurisdictions vary, but generally the question is wether the broader dissemination was intentional.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThen the other side gets to argue that everybody knows or should have known that The Cloud works like that, and accuse you of doing it intentionally because you wanted the cost savings or convenience of the product with those terms. Also, "jurisdictions vary" can be quite a relevant caveat for all the people in the jurisdictions that vary.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pdabbadabba 5y agoMaybe so. But your client will still be pissed that, from their perspective, your carelessness put them at risk. In my practice, it would be a disaster for this question to even arise.
- tjalfi 5y ago> Basically all of these things are teething problems. The early adopters have problems, the problems get solved, then they're solved for everybody It's not just teething problems. Using OpenOffice and Linux means that you're opting out of the substantial ecosystem of legal-specific Word add-ins - document templates for court filings, semantic analysis for contracts, metadata scrubbing, etc. Most of these tools are only available for Windows although some of them support Macs. A small practice can get away with using Linux but a large firm would be foolish to do so.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThose are the teething problems. Somebody has to convert the templates or make it so LibreOffice supports them. The early adopters have to deal with that, but then it's done. A lot of that also isn't as hard as you would think. Semantic analysis is looking at text. That isn't likely to be Word-specific and the author could plausibly add support for plain text files in an afternoon, if it isn't already present.