4 ms·
It’s often stated that in theory each branch of government is equal, in practice the idea of the constitution splitting power into three exactly equivalent port
by Retric 5y ago
It’s often stated that in theory each branch of government is equal, in practice the idea of the constitution splitting power into three exactly equivalent portions is kind of silly.
As you point out it’s somewhat arbitrary how much weight to assign to each individual branch of government. But, the judicial branch sure tells the legislative branch no far more often than the reverse (edit: than the legislature tells to judicial branch no.). Hypothetically the ability to modify the constitution is a real power the legislature holds across the state and federal levels, in practice a divided legislature has issues passing via simple majority.
Which adds another layer to these assessments. Does the each branch actually have the powers it should hypothetically have or only those it can actually exercise in practice?
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> But, the judicial branch sure tells the legislative branch no far more often than the reverse The court does not really interact with the legislature directly, to say Yes or No. The court interprets a body of laws, and won’t have an opinion on the validity of a law except insofar as it is in conflict with another law (such as the Constitution, or state laws in conflict with federal ones, or maybe just one law that’s inconsistent with itself). Moreover, a the key function of the Supreme Court of the United States specifically is to resolve conflicts in interpretation in law in the lower circuit courts (as is relevant to actual ongoing disputes). If the law is clearly invalid, a lower court can decide that. So yeah, if the law is obviously valid or uncontroversial, or even if it’s obviously invalid, chances are there’s just not any case brought before the Supreme Court. That’s just the default. They don’t affirm the validity of laws that often because most valid laws aren’t really challenged there.
- xpe 5y ago> It’s often stated that in theory each branch of government is equal Not by myself (above), but yes, sometimes others say this > in practice the idea of the constitution splitting power into three exactly equivalent portions is kind of silly. I wouldn't use the word 'silly'. I would say that any such design goal of a constitution would be (a) tricky to implement and (b) probably impossible to convince the public that it was 'equivalent' because doing so would require value judgments (norms).
- xpe 5y ago> But, the judicial branch sure tells the legislative branch no far more often than the reverse (edit: than the legislature tells to judicial branch no.). This is only one of many ways to try to quantify the balance of powers between the branches. To make a comprehensive assessment, we'd need to be much more systematic.