6 ms·
You Are the Object of a Secret Extraction Operation
- nickthemagicman 5y agoThere's actually a clever hack to get around facebooks information gathering. Deleting Facebook.
- Cymrukicks 5y agoNo, not even close. Facebook doesn't need you to have an account to gather information on you. It's an ad network tracking what you browse everywhere on the web via cookies. It also know who you are via your accounts with other sites and agreement to share. So if your email address is connected to your friends contacts it know you connections before you even have an account.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThey also get data from apps compiled with the FB libs. No account needed.
- jcynix 5y agoThat's why I use NetGuard (Android app) as a personal firewall on mobile and block facebook on home router etc.
- nickthemagicman 5y agowhat are FB libraries?
- rurban 5y agoI dont have the FaceBook app on my fresh Android phone. There's still the com.facebook.katakana service running, which I explicitly blocked via NetGuard. But they are still the tracking pixels and cookies remaining, via all the webpages with their Like button integration, and Google/Mozilla conspired to block browser extensions to disable those.
- goalieca 5y agoFacebook won’t make coin without a delivery method for the ads. Stop using their products and they will suffer greatly.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoOk sure, but thats secondary info. All that they can get for sure is that you know someone. That's way more limited compared to all of your thoughts likes dislikes beliefs location family members pets, etc that people share when logged in. My point is that we complain about Facebook stealing our data but then log in to Facebook and freely give it to them. Instead of waiting for the govt or some big regulatory entity to slap Facebook we can do it ourselves and just delete Facebook. Why do you think people don't just do that?
- a0-prw 5y agoBecause FB provides them with (what they perceive to be) value. I deleted FB, Insta and Twitter, and lost nothing. My life got better.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoSAME. Those sites provided me with negative value.
- Chris2048 5y agoFB explicitly asks connections about other connections. This means other people might be giving your info to FB even if you don't.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoFacebook knows that you met someone or know someone? That's all they know for sure. it's something but not much.
- Chris2048 5y ago"Did Jane smith go to <some school/university>?" "Did Jane attend <event>?" "Do you work with Jane an FooCorp?" etc etc etc
- ajuc 5y agoThey know much more. What you liked or disliked, which ads you clicked on, which ads you closed immediately, which you waited till they finished. When you added people as friends. Which network were you in at the time. What browser/system/device were you using. How fast was your internet. How much battery you had. How often are you using their site, how it changes through the day and through the year, have you changed your timezone. Each of these is insignificant and noisy, but when aggregated it allows 99.9% predictions on stuff like "who are you voting for", "how much do you earn", "are you expecting a child", "are you buying a house/car/trip/anything significant soon", "how's your health", "are you sleeping well", "where do you live", "are you on a trip", etc. People get ads about health issues before they realize they have these issues, because the Algorithm knows better. When you have enough noisy uncertain data it doesn't matter that it's uncertain and noisy.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoI think that may be a bit sensational.
- trhway 5y ago>the ultimate harm: the growing power of tech giants willing to use their control over critical information infrastructure to compete with democratically elected lawmakers for societal dominance. i thought that the "democratically elected lawmakers" are there to carry on the will of the people, not to dominate. And if instead you accept the system of societal dominance in principle, then does it really that matter who is going to dominate? I mean following the Churchill it becomes "now we're just negotiating".
- nabdv 5y agoWell there is no human institution on earth that runs without a domination and obedience based hierarchy. The internet has caused a bit of confusion because it initially didnt resemeble a hierarchy but hierarchical structures tend to emerge in complex systems or such systems tend to just collapse.
- trhway 5y agoInternet is the first tool in history which allows to run complex systems without hierarchy - the hierarchy is a necessary optimization resulting from the physical limitations of information and control flows, and the internet removes those limitations. >hierarchical structures tend to emerge in complex systems one can say that many observed complex systems emerge as the way to facilitate/implement/support the hierarchy.
- ashtonkem 5y agoThat is absolutely not true, regardless of what the hiers of Hobbes would like you to believe. Co-ops, mutual aid societies, some of the Kibbutzen, and various anarchistic communes have operated in non-hierarchical ways You can debate the effectiveness of these arrangements; it’s clearly true that hierarchical orgs are the norm, and they have a tendency to expand via force. But to say that there is “no human institution on earth” that doesn’t use hierarchies and dominance is just not true.
- jtms 5y agoIt’s a matter of scale. The examples you provide are microscopic.
- perihelions 5y ago>"Early in the pandemic, for example, Apple and Google refused to adapt their operating systems to host contact tracing apps developed by public health authorities and supported by elected officials." Their linked source actually says the two companies "refused to open their technology to governments pushing for centralized data storage, a strategy they considered vulnerable to state snooping." https://www.politico.eu/article/google-apple-coronavirus-app-privacy-uk-france-germany/ https://www.politico.eu/article/google-apple-coronavirus-app...
- poofsoda 5y agoAgreed TFA is misleading. Apple and Google refused to allow governments to track individuals through exposure notification apps and forced client-side, privacy-preserving notifications. I’d imagine HN would have supported the Apple/Google approach where everything’s local and anonymous rather than what many governments initially proposed where identity and/or location was logged by the apps. (I also agree that privacy-preserving exposure notifications are better than invasive tracking ones, especially in the US where the citizenry expects a right to privacy) Source: ran the team that developed one of the first US state exposure notification apps based on EN Express, the protocol to which the linked source is referring.
- me_me_me 5y agoThat is a rich comment coming from Google when Page was boasting google can predict how you are going to vote before you will know it.
- atoav 5y ago>"Early in the pandemic, for example, Apple and Google refused to adapt their operating systems to host contact tracing apps developed by public health authorities and supported by elected officials." I am one of the last people to defend Google and/or Apple, but in this case they just didn't weaken their existing guidelines for states to snoop the data of their citizens. A hypothetical contact tracing app that would have met the guidelines would have had no problems at all.
- lukebuehler 5y agoGreat article, but the author puts too much hope in regulation. While I believe that new laws will help, the solution must ultimately come from new technologies, platforms, and protocols. The kind of information extraction that these companies engage in is enabled by the way we built the internet, we could have chosen different paths and still can.
- haspoken 5y agohttps://archive.md/r014U https://archive.md/r014U