4 ms·
FCEV cars (not trucks) are prototypes pretty much. There are way too many problems to solve before they become an actual solution to anything. A station that c
by theshrike79 5y ago
FCEV cars (not trucks) are prototypes pretty much. There are way too many problems to solve before they become an actual solution to anything.
A station that can fuel 2 FCEVs every 15-20 minutes costs around $2 million.
The cost of driving with hydrogen is completely bonkers compared to any other power source currently in use (natural gas, electricity, gasoline, diesel).
For long-haul trucks, ships etc. hydrogen might be a good solution.
Currently the best thing we can use hydrogen for is as a battery for renewables. Use excess energy to generate hydrogen and store it on-site. When production dips, convert the hydrogen to electricity on-site and feed it back to the grid.
- Youden 5y agoI think the viability of FCEVs is certainly up for discussion, my point is mostly that Elektrek accuses Toyota of dismissing BEVs, which are Electrek's preference while itself dismissing FCEVs, which are Toyota's preference. But on the specific points you raise, I agree that FCEVs are at a very early stage. You can buy them and they function but refueling stations are rare and unreliable, so they're not yet very practical. Regarding the costs of a fueling station, the hope is that as the technology is more mature, the costs will decrease substantially. The equipment isn't anywhere close to being mass produced the way it is for gas stations and BEV charging stations. But FCEVs are a young technology and if (and I know it's a big if) we can work around their issues, I can see them being a very compelling alternative or compliment to BEVs. For example stick a hydrogen tank in the back of a BEV and you can use the batteries for your daily commute and hydrogen for longer journeys.
- Hypx_ 5y agoMost of the those problems are fully solved. In fact the the biggest event in green energy is pushing back from the anti-hydrogen nonsense and just start investing. A good example of this is Fortescue industry and JCB. They've pretty much stopped caring about the criticisms and have begun investing billions of dollars.
- theshrike79 5y ago> Regarding the costs of a fueling station, the hope is that as the technology is more mature, the costs will decrease substantially. The equipment isn't anywhere close to being mass produced the way it is for gas stations and BEV charging stations. A good chunk of the costs involved in getting a H2 station running is regulation and licensing. You can't just store 500kg of pressurised hydrogen on any parking lot. You need permits and licenses and all that fun stuff. You also need to maintain it, actually bring the H2 to the station from somewhere etc. An EV charging station is pretty much a fancy extension cord, you need a HV certified electrician, a backhoe and some cables along with the charger units. You don't need permits from anyone except maybe from the power company. Cost for a 22kW AC charger is maybe 1k per unit, HVDC units are 20-50k a pop, depending on the amount of power. Wal-mart, for example, could have 40 350kW HVDC chargers (complete overkill btw) on their parking lot for the price of one H2 station, that can serve 2 cars every 5-20 minutes. Or they could electrify their whole parking lot with 22kW destination chargers and still have money left over. Hydrogen will have its day, but there are WAY too many hurdles for it to cross before it becomes something regular people can have in their cars. Hydrogen trucks for long haul trips, yes. Hydrogen powered cargo ships, yes. Hydrogen for renewable energy storage, yes. If we want H2 to become a valid choice for normal family cars, someone needs to put up billions to get a proper refueling network up and running and keep it running. Which needs a reliable, cheap, source of hydrogen and a fleet of trucks. Maybe a Hydrogen-Musk will appear some day? =)
- Hypx_ 5y agoYou're stuck in the world of ten years ago. Absolutely none of that is true. Refueling is the same as a gasoline car. A fuel cell car also costs about the same as a SUV to own and run. It fully makes sense to begin the transition to hydrogen cars now.
- theshrike79 5y agoSo there's no need to re-pressurise the station after every few cars anymore? At least a year ago this caused queues in Californian H2 stations, people had to queue for 30-40 minutes waiting for their turn. Hydrogen price in Germany, with government support, is around 9.5€/kg. Toyota Mirai's consumption is about 1kg/100km, making the cost to drive 100km 9.5€. You can drive the same distance with an EV for a third or half of the price, depending on where you charge. (0.20€/kWh for public charging, consumption around 15-20kW/100km = 3-4€/100km) The Mirai, without the insane Californian rebates and subsidies, is around 80k€ in Europe. You can get a fully loaded (FSD and everything) Tesla Model 3 LR for 10k€ less.
- Hypx_ 5y agoNo. How hard is it to have faster pressurization and/or extra tanks? For any of the newer stations this is solved. Gasoline is approaching 7€ per gallon in Germany. Cost per mile is cheaper with a hydrogen car. Public charging is more like 0.40€/kWh in Germany too. Cost per mile is is not that different between EVs and hydrogen cars. The Mirai starts at 50,000€ before subsidies in Europe. It is nearly as cheap as the cheapest Model 3. Depending on the subsidies you get it could be even cheaper. Future hydrogen will be cheaper and so will be fuel cell costs. People's mentality on this subject is entirely out of date.
- theshrike79 5y ago> How hard is it to have faster pressurization and/or extra tanks? For any of the newer stations this is solved. Is this a fact or speculation? I haven't heard of faster pressurisation systems. You can't just pressurise highly flammable gases "faster" all willy-nilly, stuff tends to heat up and boiling point lowers when pressure goes up. Even at 0.40€/kWh it's still about 6 euros / 100km. Still 1/3 lower than H2. And with the car prices being similar or lower, there isn't really any point for H2. Gasoline is reaching parity with subsidised H2 though, let's see how that goes in Germany since exactly zero German manufacturers are doing FCEV cars.