4 ms·
>Pay me or delete. You don’t own my content cause you didn’t pay me. Pay me or delete. Period. You weren't hired by YCombinator as a writer, nor was any contra
by krapp 5y ago
>Pay me or delete. You don’t own my content cause you didn’t pay me. Pay me or delete. Period.
You weren't hired by YCombinator as a writer, nor was any contract for employment or payment negotiated as a term for your use of this forum. If you believe you're entitled to monetary compensation for your comments, then feel free to get a lawyer.
You can't, and won't, because even if you could make a case that you own your comments, no one is under any obligation to pay for something you literally gave away.
Mind you, I'm sympathetic to your cause - I'd like the option to at least delete my older comments, I'd very much prefer to be able to delete or at least suspend my account like on Reddit and/or mass delete my comments. Somehow other forums get away with that but for whatever reason Hacker News is sacrosanct and doesn't have to play be the rules of common decency that the rest of the web does.
But your argument here is plainly irrational and probably legally untenable. HN is not going to pay you, and they're not deleting your comments. Just accept that and move on with life.
- fritzw 5y ago> You weren't hired by YCombinator as a writer, nor was any contract TOS could be construed as a contract. In fact, it is. It’s been tested. It’s not ‘given’ if it’s under terms of service. There was in fact, a contract. You are wrong. Pay or delete
- krapp 5y ago>TOS could be construed as a contract. In fact, it is. It’s been tested. If it is, it's not a contract which obligates YCombinator to pay you anything. That sort of thing has to specifically be in the contract... you don't just get paid because "it's a contract," that isn't how contracts work. >It’s not ‘given’ if it’s under terms of service. There was in fact, a contract. Yes it is. Again, the existence of a contract, alone, doesn't automatically obligate payment. Most platforms have terms of service under which you explicitly relinquish all rights to anything you post to the platform, to use in any way they wish, without compensation, forever in perpetuity throughtout the universe. Hacker News' terms of service are here: https://www.ycombinator.com/legal/ https://www.ycombinator.com/legal/ nowhere is an obligation to pay for content mentioned. >You are wrong. Pay or delete You and your alts have fun in arbitration then, let us know how it goes.
- headShrinker 5y ago> you don't just get paid because "it's a contract," that isn't how contracts work That's exactly how a contract works. Contract specifies transaction. How do you not know this. transaction, entails something for something. A Transaction is never something for nothing. This is basic. You should know this. HN is flagging and blocking my posts. alts are necessary. > fun in arbitration Typical corporate speak. If only hacker news would be able to see you, had you not shadow banned me.
- fritzw 5y ago> You and your alts have fun in arbitration then, let us know how it goes Nice corporate speak. Wouldn’t need alts if you didn’t shadow ban