3 ms·
And just like building bigger highways induces demand so will building more shelters in SF. “Build it and they will come” Not sure why we’d aim to building ho
by refurb 5y ago
And just like building bigger highways induces demand so will building more shelters in SF.
“Build it and they will come”
Not sure why we’d aim to building housing for homeless in the most expensive city in the US
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> And just like building bigger highways induces demand so will building more shelters in SF. "Induced demand" is a fallacy. The demand isn't induced, it was there the whole time and being suppressed by high prices (or, in case of highways, congestion). If there is very high demand, the amount of supply needed to satisfy it is equally high, but that is by no means the same as being infinite and impossible to do. There are also ways to satisfy the demand for "highways" other than building more highways. Like building more housing closer to where jobs are so people don't have to drive such long distances. Often these alternatives are better, but sometimes they're not. Sometimes your problem is actually that your highway doesn't have enough lanes. This isn't a question you can answer in the general case without looking at the specifics. > Not sure why we’d aim to building housing for homeless in the most expensive city in the US Because that's where a lot of the homeless are because they can't afford the price of housing there. There are literally people in San Francisco who are homeless despite having a full-time job. Also, it's not "housing for the homeless," it's just housing. Build enough and the price comes down. Then people can afford it instead of being homeless. There is obviously also a benefit to be had for the person who isn't homeless but is spending 60% of their income on an apartment the size of a parking space.
- refurb 5y agoInduced demand is not a fallacy. And we’re not building housing here we’re building shelters.
- epistasis 5y agoInduced demand for housing is a fallacy. There's only a very very small range of living space that people want. Induced demand for highways definitely is not a fallacy. People can go from needing zero highway miles a day, up to 60-90 highway miles a day, depending on where they live. This sort of range is an order of magnitude higher than what could potentially be induced by having access to, say, cheaper construction methods. In fact, for housing, the opposite seems to occur. When there are more people in an area, people tend to take up less individual space. It's only when people live far away from anything that they seems to expand to 1000+ square feet/person.
- refurb 5y agoYou’ve got cause and effect backwards. More people in an area take up less space because it’s more expensive and vice versa when living far away. And of course you can induce demand with housing. If suddenly you could find $1,000/month 1 bed apartments in SF how many people you think would move there?
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Induced demand is not a fallacy. It is a fallacy. The demand is there either way. It's just a regular supply and demand curve, where there is more demand at a lower price (and "price" includes the time cost of sitting in traffic congestion). The heart of the fallacy is the assumption that the demand is infinite and it's impossible to ever satisfy it. It's not. It's just non-linear. > And we’re not building housing here we’re building shelters. Shelters are housing. But also, why aren't we building housing? Build a lot more housing and fewer people will be homeless or need "shelters" because housing will cost less.