4 ms·
Probably you will want liquified H2. So, we need volume manufacturing of aerogel, for the tanks. If we don't go to wholly new airframes, we will need to sling t
by ncmncm 5y ago
Probably you will want liquified H2. So, we need volume manufacturing of aerogel, for the tanks. If we don't go to wholly new airframes, we will need to sling the LH2 tanks in nacelles under the wings, like the engines, because the needed tankage volume won't fit inside normal wings. (With a new airframe with more internal space, the tanks could be inboard, but maybe you don't really want big tanks of LH2 inboard.)
The LH2 would be electrolyzed on demand at the airport, using power delivered by transmission lines from all over, banking LH2 when the sun is out or the wind is blowing, when it is cheapest.
Once these planes start flying, it will become impossible to compete with them, because the smaller mass of fuel needed translates to substantially more freight, both total capacity per flight, and per unit-cost of fuel. But there are still things to work out, so there will be an interim need to synthesize jet fuel from atmospheric CO2 and H2, which should soon get cheaper than extraction.
It would be helpful if somebody were to come up with a good use for all the waste oxygen everyone is going to be producing.
- tuatoru 5y ago> Probably you will want liquified H2. More likely to use solid adsorbed hydrogen. Room temperature, room pressure, less mass in the tanks. Adsorption has been experimented with for several decades at least. But modern computer power and modern processes for controlling material surface properties make it more likely than ever before. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adsorption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adsorption - not specific to hydrogen Random PDF of study: https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/10F54D8F0E3E0ACB12D0083DF1C91672/S0883769400053458a.pdf/hydrogen_adsorption_in_carbon_materials.pdf https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/c... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7CCq4oBgw4&t=464s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7CCq4oBgw4&t=464s - latest "breakthrough". One day, one of these will be real.
- ncmncm 5y agoLess mass than what? I promise you, adsorbed hydrogen along with whatever it is adsorbed onto will not weigh less than the same hydrogen, liquified. LH2 at atmospheric pressure does not need a heavy tank. If they can get it to adsorb to an aerogel, they might have something, but you still have to get the H2 back out.
- ddek 5y agoThe best solid adsorbed hydrogen is currently running about 5% the density of liquid hydrogen. Most solutions use either graphene or heavy metals too rare to meet mass demand. It's not a promising technology.
- ddek 5y agoAs you say, we've been working on solid adsorption for a long time now. Nothing has left the lab. The video presents an optimistic future, but we don't even have the basics yet. Firstly, there is a fundamental issue - H² doesn't really give you anything to work with. The vast majority of compounds have two protons, two neutrons (rare isotopes have more protons). [They're distributed in the most boring orbitals, just spheres with no real edge to gain leverage.](https://winter.group.shef.ac.uk/orbitron/atomic_orbitals/1s/index.html https://winter.group.shef.ac.uk/orbitron/atomic_orbitals/1s/...) This lack of leverage makes surface adsorption tricky. The molecule gives us nothing to grab. You won't carefully craft a surface that can hold H². I think right now there's a focus on activated carbon. That's become a bit of a synonym for 'graphene', with it's well known limitations. When I studied the subject, metal-organic complexes were the focus. These would be extremely customisable, but if they worked we'd probably have seen by now. They tended to use heavy metals. I wasn't optimistic at the time, I thought anything using materials past the 4th row of the periodic table was unrealistic. As the metals get heavier they get expensive and sometimes rare. If we want to solve a common problem, we need common components. If your solution has lanthanoid, it won't scale. I was right btw. The research group closed when funding was reallocated. Each experiment ran the research budget of another group. MoC's don't really get much love any more. Anyway, we should probably think about what makes a good hydrogen adsorption material. I think it's pretty simple, you want a material that: stores a high density of hydrogen, is reusable, quickly picks up hydrogen, and quickly releases hydrogen. The latter 2 categories is the 'kinetics'. Of the materials we know, all (literally all) that have 'good' kinetics are either single use or low density. Conversely, all that are both multi use and relatively high density have poor kinetics. Additionally, most of those with good kinetics have unrealistic conditions, like requiring 400˚C temperature to release the hydrogen.
- zoomablemind 5y agoFrom a realm of sustainability, it'd be cool to dream up a way for having bioships [1], so that the energy would be accumulated in the structure while still on the ground, then metabolised while in-flight. Well, SkyMoos [2] would also be nice to have around. [1]:https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioship https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bioship [2]:https://aliens.fandom.com/wiki/Skymoo https://aliens.fandom.com/wiki/Skymoo
- lowbloodsugar 5y agoFor those who, like me, got confused: Hydrogen requires more volume for the same energy as jet fuel, but even with that larger volume, it is lighter than the smaller volume of jet fuel.
- ncmncm 5y agoMuch lighter. The difference is quite a lot more than you might guess from the raw numbers, because the LH2 doesn't need to loft the weight of the jet fuel, but only its own, lesser weight. Since it doesn't need to loft that weight, that lifting capacity can be used for cargo instead, thus also increasing the top-line income for performing the flight. Finally, locally produced LH2 will be cheaper per joule delivered than jet fuel, moreso after its carbon is taxed, and the carbon burned in transporting it to the airport. It will take a while to get there, because it needs both new (or maybe retrofitted?) airframes, and new airport infrastructure, initially only at key international airports. Not injecting CO2 directly into the stratosphere will be a side benefit.