3 ms·
The subsidies reflect the belief/position/ideology that the train brings a net benefit to all of society, and so should be paid for by everyone, not just those
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
The subsidies reflect the belief/position/ideology that the train brings a net benefit to all of society, and so should be paid for by everyone, not just those who ride. This is intended to be in contrast to flying, which brings more costs than benefits.
You can certainly argue that these beliefs are incorrect if you feel like it, and it's not as if there isn't a case to be made. But it's not just a simple matter of "we tax this, and subsidize that".
- rsj_hn 5y agoThe parent post I was responding to was saying that the reason trains cost more is that that aviation was being subsidized at the expense of trains. That's just wildly incorrect. They supported that position by taking one out of context fact. I remedied that by providing the overall context. I was not making a judgement as to whether trains should be subsidized or not. That's a whole separate discussion. But since you bring it up, I'd say that in general, transportation of all kinds provides such massive positive externalities that it should probably be subsidized. Then we can debate how much more trains should be subsidized over airplanes, but both create massive net positive externalities, IMO.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI think it's really hard to argue that for planes. In saying that I don't mean that I think it's clearly not true. I mean that the case for net positive externalities for air travel is dependent on things like (a) the geographic scope you consider (b) the temporal scope you include (c) value judgements about time-efficient travel and much more. One could legitimately take quite opposite positions on all these aspects (and more), and would end up reaching very different conclusions. Something like this applies to trains also, but much less so because their inherent geographic scope, environmental impact, sociological impact and effects on reducing travel time are much less than flying.
- rsj_hn 5y agoSo you are correct that externalities is something that is really ill-defined, which is why all claims to impose externality-based taxes should meet a high bar of rigor. In most cases, that's just impossible and the taxes end up being applied for political or emotional reasons rather than objectively taking all costs and benefits into account. But when it comes to a few areas, we know that there are massive positive externalities in anything involving transportation or communication. Anything that makes the world smaller generally has big positive effects. Even if you never buy a foreign good, the fact that a good was brought in will lower the price and raise the quality of the domestic good you do buy. That generates employment and income. Anything that lowers the price of bringing in that good will have a huge positive effect on the economy. With planes, the fact that they make transportation easy and affordable generates massive revenue for tourism, trade, employment. European Airports alone generate about 675 Billion in GDP -- 4% of the EU's GDP when both passenger and freight is taken into account[1]. And that's just airports. An older FAA study concludes that civil aviation generates 5.4% of US GDP[2] and that's a fairly conservative study not even trying to measure too many spillovers. Then there is a third effect, which is the superiority of point to point designs. Miami Beach was developed in the 30s and 40s because some developers saw its potential as a great beach destination. But it was only with plane flight that the rest of the nation had a chance to enjoy it. Or Las Vegas, another center that sprang out of nowhere. The fact that I can fly from pretty much anywhere in the country to Miami for $100 massively increases the tourism trade to Miami Beach. To do that with rail, you'd have to overcome n^2 problem. That alone would require laying down ~50,000 miles of track, requiring God knows how many tons of steel, trainyards, and workers. And it would take days to travel there with connections, stopovers, etc. Those are all frictions. And once you laid it all down, suppose you didn't want to go to Miami, but to Corpus Christi. Thus air travel allows places to spring up in response to market demand, whereas in the old days, cities along the track became the important centers -- e.g. development was infrastructure constrained rather than allowing the infrastructure to meet the needs of development flexibly and quickly. That increased flexibility and convenience, together with the reduced frictions of point to point travel provides trillions of dollars in positive externalities. [1] https://medium.com/geophy-hq/airports-as-a-positive-externality-82325130d41f https://medium.com/geophy-hq/airports-as-a-positive-external... [2] https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/media/2014-economic-impact-report.pdf https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/media/2014-econ...
- thehappypm 5y agoI don’t get how trains help everyone. By their very nature, they draw lines blessing certain areas with infrastructure, blessing certain cities, while bypassing others. It must be hard for smaller cities in Europe to get much traction when the big cities all have fancy rail. In the US? Even small, super remote places (Aspen, Steamboat, Bar Harbor, Bozeman, Spokane, Jackson Home) have airports and that makes them equally connected to the country as anywhere else.
- jltsiren 5y agoEurope is more densely populated than the US. Small cities are rarely far from major cities, and they are usually connected by regional rail. Small remote cities don't really exist in areas where rail traffic makes sense.
- thehappypm 5y agoThat’s a very Western / Central European bias. In fact it probably is a big reason why there’s such a major east/west split that persists today, the rich countries keep building themselves more and more of this type of luxury infra.