7 ms·
Toyota spreads anti-EV propaganda in Japan
- browningstreet 5y agoToyota is releasing their newest electric car as the "bZ4X", while Subaru is releasing the same car as the "Solterra". One of them seems to want to sell the car more than the other.
- pornel 5y agoTo add: "bZ4X" is ill-suited to be spelled in native Japanese alphabets, and 4 is an unlucky number. It's like Ford releasing a car named DӔTӉ.
- BizarroLand 5y agoI would gladly buy the Ford DӔTӉ.
- karmicthreat 5y agoToyota just seems like it doesn’t want to admit it backed the wrong tech.
- Hypx_ 5y agoPeople need to question whether Tesla bet on the wrong technology. No one is even asking that question; instead they are just assuming it is correct. Assumption often leads to disasters later on.
- BizarroLand 5y agoThe thing is that culturally you have to consider the point of Face. If Mr. Toyoda is going to look bad by these decisions and also look bad by giving in, then there is no point in him giving in. Instead he will either double down or greyrock any opportunities to change direction. Instead, Mr. Toyoda should be encouraged to keep the propaganda up for a year or two while they plan their all out Toyota EV invasion, blast Tesla out of Japanese airspace, and take market dominance in the country for EV vehicles. He would look like a brilliant hero, Toyota would make billions, and the world becomes a better place, and it would have all been facilitated by a little dab of misdirection on his part.
- a-dub 5y agothis is an issue that will need attention worldwide. there's a huge cottage industry of small businesses built up around motor vehicle service. lubrication, muffler shops, transmission shops, mechanics, emissions certification shops and others i don't even know. i think there needs to be a plan in place for what all those people are going to do with new vehicle technology that only requires a tenth of the service. if governments mandate transitions to technologies that take away the life's work and livelihoods of people and simply ignore the fact that it's happening, those who lose everything will take political action to get it back. we've already seen some of this and it has not been pretty.
- phicoh 5y agoThere is a huge number of technical people needed for the energy transition. If everybody starts driving EVs, who installs the chargers? Who upgrades the grid? Who installs new heating systems in homes (and upgrades the electrical installation in the homes)? If anything, we are way short on people.
- a-dub 5y agoright. but is anyone thinking about how the transition may go? how decentralized is the fossil fuel vehicle industry and how might its replacement look? are there policy levers that can ensure the new ev economy is as inclusive as the fossil fuel one was? are there policy levers for taking care of those who simply won't have a place in the new economy and have too much invested in the old one? it seems this all gets way too little attention.
- rurp 5y agoSkilled jobs aren't that fluid though. Many of the new EV jobs will require very different skills from the jobs they are displacing. I wouldn't assume that laying off a bunch of auto mechanics will fill a bunch of electrical engineer jobs any more than I would expect it to fix a nursing shortage. There are things the govt can do to help that transition though, such as free job training and economic support for laid off workers. I understood the OP's point to be that the govt has a responsibilty to pursue these types of policies, and I totally agree.
- coldtea 5y agoWhat makes it "anti-EV propaganda" as opposed to "reality"? Who decides whether "anti-EV" is propaganda, whereas "anti-gas" merely information? "electrek.com"? First of all, the pamphlets shown have no anti-EV statements whatsoever. In fact, as the article shows, they don't mention EV at all. What they accuse them is propaganda by omission! The company dared not tout EV in its own pamphlet, but focus exclusively on their traditional models. Well, they also didn't bet strong on the EV market, so can they promote what they actually focus on? Or is that forbidden? Secondly, that hybrids are globally a more realistic solution in the next 10-20 years is true. Some people bought their $50K+ Teslas (or some small EV for city use) and are under the delusion that in, say, 10 years or so (if not immediately), all gas stations could stop serving gas, and just have EV charging units. The world is neither just Tokyo nor just California or Stockholm, nor is the capacity and infrastructure there (from batteries and materials required for them, to the power grid). And in the future, between inflation, infrastructure neglect, covid repercursions to the economy, climate change costs, trade war costs, and so on, infrastructure might even get worse, not better. (I'd bet those "all new cars must be EVs by 2030" edicts, will be revisited and expanded a couple of times). Thirdly, that workers in many traditional car trades and manufacturing will go out of a job by such a switch is a fact, and something to be taken into account (of course there's always the Ayn Ran "solution": "fuck them"). If anything, it's the article that has a strong pro-EV-or-bust vibe (well, given the website), and it makes sense that the "complaint" came from a "concerned citizen", which could be anything from an EV-obsessed enthusiast to astroturfing.
- agonmon 5y agoPhysics and statistical arguments about the medical harms of pollution. But if that is too much to dig into, consider the incentives in play, and who has more to gain from spreading disinformation.
- coldtea 5y ago>But if that is too much to dig into Is that similar to the difficulty digging into whether an all-new-EV car fleet is practical, from an electric needs/power grid capacity and stability/charging infrastructure spread/battery making capacity/battery materials capacity/standpoint? Or to the physics and statistical arguments regarding their total relative environmental impact with externalities taken into account? >consider the incentives in play, and who has more to gain from spreading disinformation. EV companies that have the chance to sell the entirety of new cars, with state mandated priority to their technology, and ample subsidies and tax-cuts?
- webmobdev 5y agoWhile the article has a valid point, it misses the bigger picture (even though it highlights it): > "The main reason is simple. Jobs. Japanese manufacturers buy parts from small family-owned businesses across Japan. Toyota has only about 70,000 employees in Japan but are indirectly responsible for the income of far more Japanese and foreign workers in Japan. It is well-known in the Japanese car industry that their record profit business model is based on the sweat and tears of hundreds of small underpaid parts manufacturers in the country." The current internal combustion engine dominated automobile industry, and its ancillaries, are quite embedded in the current economy of Japan. (This is also very much true in India too, that has a similar successful automobile industry). Any economist / politician would be a fool to promote EV without first considering the impact of job losses and shutdown of these ancillary units on the economy (and both will happen because Electric Vehicles use much less parts). I too think that moving to Hybrids first, is a more practical approach in such a scenario, especially for countries like India and Japan. While the benefits of EV are sound and needed, we still can't predict the long-term impact of completely moving to them - is there enough resources (e.g. lithium) to create enough batteries to meet the demand (batteries will need replacement)? Power generation is dirty, unless it is from renewable source like Solar or Wind (Nuclear and Hydel too, to a certain extent, despite the ecological consequences) - will we able to generate this extra power in a sustainable manner? Moving to Hybrids first can give us real data on all these, and help better plan the future for a full EV migration.
- phicoh 5y agoI wonder how this will work if they can sell the hybrid cars only in Japan. A hybrid is a good idea as long as the ICE plus associated mechanics is cheaper than the bigger battery pack you need for a BEV. However, as soon as the battery pack is cheaper (and in many cases BEVs are already cheaper to run), your are out of the competition if you only offer hybrid in a market that desires BEVs.
- pornel 5y agoThese jobs will be lost anyway. It's only a matter of time, and then the question is are they going to be lost to Toyota's EVs, or foreign EVs? EVs are already cheaper per mile, and often have better TCO for new cars. When battery cost drops further, it will be a bad deal to pay extra for vehicles that carry an extra high-maintenance expensive-to-run engine. Especially that Japan likes Kei cars, which don't have space to waste.
- hnov 5y agoCalls the opposing viewpoint "anti-EV propaganda", then states that "Even on dirty grids, EVs are cleaner" which links to an article titled "Even electric cars powered by the dirtiest electricity emit fewer emissions than diesel cars, says new study".
- josephcsible 5y agoWhat's your point? Are you implying that either that statement or article are false?
- hnov 5y agoNo, it's just sleight of hand. They take a study that states "EVs produce fewer _greenhouse emissions_ per mile than _diesels_ even on Poland's fossil fuel electrical grid" and turn that into "Even on dirty grids, EVs are cleaner". 1. Burning coal emits NOx, SO2 and other toxic and radioactive shit, which is not what the studies were about. For example an American city like LA emits a ton of CO2 but I wouldn't call it polluted compared to someplace like Shanghai where PM2.5 in the air poses a danger to your health some days. Greenhouse gas emissions and pollution are related but different. 2. Japan doesn't really use diesel for passenger vehicles and diesel tends to be pretty dirty in terms of NOx, especially diesels before dieselgate. So the premise that on a dirty grid an EV is cleaner than an ICE car may or may not be true. Note that the study doesn't seem to be touching on hybrids at all which will obviously close to (non-hybrid) diesels in terms of CO2 while offering even lower toxic emissions.
- pornel 5y agoIf the transition to EVs is going to go like transition to smartphones, Toyota is setting itself up to be the Nokia. I've driven several latest EVs, and they're getting really good. I think we're at the "iPhone 3G" stage in the EV tech.
- Youden 5y agoSeems like hypocrisy considering Electrek routinely ignores FCEVs (hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicles), which are Toyota's apparent future preference. Among other things, the image at the top of the article clearly shows "FCEV" alongside "HEV" and "PHEV" and Toyota sponsored a small YouTube series by Physics Girl. The indication is that Toyota sees FCEVs as a big part of the future of EVs. Yet in this article Electrek says "M. Toyoda’s (Chairman of Toyota) [...] has taken a very public anti-EV position worldwide", "the companies and government are scrambling to slow the adoption of EVs in the country and abroad". Clearly Toyota is investing substantially in (FC)EVs, yet Electrek claims a hostile stance. Electrek even goes so far as claiming that BEVs are "the only real EVs that don’t use fossil fuels". I'm not sure if the intent there is that FCEVs are less "real" than BEVs or if they're somehow injecting fossil fuels into the process somewhere. This isn't an isolated incident. Just a couple of weeks ago, Electrek called the bZ4X Toyota's "first all-electric car" [0], ignoring the RAV4 and more recently the Mirai. I don't mean this as an ad-hominem attack, nothing I'm saying necessarily negates other points in the article but it feels like Electrek is attacking Toyota for the very same sin it commits itself. Electrek should take a look in the mirror and consider reporting more fairly concerning FCEVs in the future. They don't have to like them but they shouldn't deny that they exist. [0]: https://electrek.co/2021/10/29/toyota-unveils-first-all-electric-car-bz4x-an-electric-suv-packed-cool-features/ https://electrek.co/2021/10/29/toyota-unveils-first-all-elec...
- phicoh 5y agoMaybe there is the thing that hardly any hydrogen is created from non-fossil sources. Given the challenge of bringing enough green electricity online, producing enough green hydrogen for industry, it is extremely unclear how we can afford to waste a lot of green electricity in producing green hydrogen for cars. Of course, by the time customers find out about the price difference they will dump their FCEV cars. So at the moment, hydrogen is produced from methane. And indirectly produces as much CO2 as ICE cars. Due to their enormous efficiency, BEV cars can indirectly produce less CO2 even is electricy is generated from fossile fuels. And with enough nuclear, wind or solar, CO2 can be a lot less.
- Hypx_ 5y ago
- dzhiurgis 5y agoFact 1: in short term, PHEV's are better for environment Fact 2: PHEV drivers don't plug-in negating above BEV's are still only like 2-3% of total annual car sales. A lot can change in next 10 years.
- josephcsible 5y ago> PHEV drivers don't plug-in Yep. One major factor is that a lot of companies, including ones that claim to care about the environment, will reimburse employees on business travel for gasoline but not electricity for their vehicles.
- san-fran 5y agoAs one solo data point, the privately-owned company I work for handles business travel reimbursement based on mileage rather than personal money spent on fuel. The fuel economy of vehicles available to me has factored into at least one instance when planning a business trip. It would depend on the business policies of course, but can EVSE stations generate digital receipts for costs incurred to charge?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- erik_seaberg 5y agoThis article glosses over having chargers, but anyone pushing BEVs over hybrids needs to have an answer for that problem. How many Japanese have private garages?
- MrRiddle 5y agoI still don’t understand how they plan to solve that problem in majority of the world. I only have public parking around, and even refueling at the gas station in the neighborhood can take 15 minutes due to queues, at least it lasts me for 1000km. There is a charging network, which at the moment works fine, but imagine if everyone had EVs. Charging stations would need to have 50-100 spots.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoElectricity is ubiquitous. For those with private garages our outdoor parking, they will use their own charger. Sidewalk charger pedestals, as well as chargers that integrate with street lighting, are available. Fast DC charging at public parking is rapidly expanding. Workplaces are offering charging as a perk. Most will charge at home or at work. For the most remote locations, chargers exist that charge batteries off of solar to provide charge to EVs. Consider how gas stations are fairly ubiquitous, and that EV chargers are even easier to install anywhere power is available. Outlets and level 2 chargers (~10kw) are a 1-2 day job, Fast DC chargers (Superchargers and similar) a week or two.
- theshrike79 5y agoThe solution is a complete paradigm shift on how you "refuel". With an EV you don't go to a "refuel station" every time your charge is around 5% and charge it all the way to full like you do with ICE vehicles. The solution is that you charge everywhere. Reliable and ubiquitous destination charging. Going to the supermarket? Charge. Going to the mall? Charge. Parking at the office? Charge. Parking at home? Charge. Park at the curb? Charge from the streetlight. Arrive at the hotel for your trip? Charge overnight. None of these need to charge your car from 0-100 in 5 minutes. It just needs to give you more charge than it took you to get there and the net result is positive. It doesn't need to be a 350kW mega-charger with water-cooled wires to prevent overheating. A 11-22kW AC charger is more than enough and costs a grand a pop to install. The only time you actually need fast DC charging is when you're doing road trips that are longer than your EV range is. And even in these cases your car navi should take care of it for you. (Most don't do this properly, some do, but it's mostly software). All the other times you're charging a bit every time you stop somewhere. For example the supermarket I shop at weekly is about 20km round trip, they have a 22kW charger and my car can pull around 7kW from that. After a half-hour of shopping, I've got more charge in my car than I had when I left home. If I go to the local McDonalds drive-through, I can use their 350kW DC charger and usually need to unplug before my burger is done and brought to my car.
- fomine3 5y agoI don't say Toyota is anti-EV obviously, but they advertise too much for FCV car in Japan. FC is great but FCV is already lose for most (family) car use cases.
- theshrike79 5y agoThe issue with EVs in Japan is that their grid is 100V single-phase and split to 50Hz and 60Hz for half of the country. That's not something you can charge an EV from. The fact that a good 80% of their electricity is produced via imported natural gas and coal isn't helping either.
- rasz 5y agoNah, their grid runs at 167-500 KV (kilovolts) with local 6-22-66KV substations. Every shop can have 3phase 200-210V just like in US.
- theshrike79 5y agoShops yes, but normal apartments? Can I get 3-phase 200V to a Tokyo apartment for EV charging?
- rasz 5y agoMost apartment buildings are wired for 3 phase (elevators etc).