11 ms·
Work begins on architects’ cracked Denver residential tower
- sjdksbldb 5y agoThe HN title makes no sense. It should be either "Work begins on MAD Architects’ cracked Denver residential tower" or "Work begins on cracked Denver residential tower"
- blakesterz 5y agoThis is not the story I thought it would be based on that title! "The “crack” in the façade, which covers 10 storeys, is a reference to Colorado’s dramatic mountain scenery." So it's designed to look like it has this crazy crack in it. I wonder what that'll look like in real life, the renders are... interesting. I figured this was another building that's in danger of falling like San Francisco’s slowly cracking up Millennium Tower.
- wonderwonder 5y agoReading the headline and seeing the image for the first time, I legitimately thought the building was cracked and broken in real life and doomed. Looks pretty neat once I realized what it really was.
- JPKab 5y agoI live outside of Denver, and I find this concept to be extremely exciting at an architectural level. That being said, it will be interesting to see how well the greenery in the "crack" will hold up to the extremely dry climate, as well as the extreme temperature swings in the area. I'm assuming they will use native species, which are amazingly hardy. Ponderosa pines and other tree species (Colorado Blue Spruce, etc) are known world-wide in the bonsai community for their extreme hardiness. I can drive 5 minutes west from my house and find excellent yamadori without walking more than 5 minutes from where I parked my car. Based on my experience with the extreme winds we get, especially on exposed, elevated building facades, I don't think anything other than native species will survive. I'm really looking forward to seeing this, although it's not clear I'll be able to get into the building, lol.
- bobthepanda 5y agoIt'd be really interesting to see how they will support all of this. The big reason green roofs are not very common is because dirt, particularly wet dirt, gets really heavy, as do any sizeable plants.
- starwind 5y agoTrees don't easily grow in the Denver climate so yeah I wonder how well the trees will do, too. I live like 15 minutes south of downtown and none of the trees around me look particularly healthy. If I drive east towards Brighton or Elizabeth I'll see like 1 random tree growing out of a creek but otherwise it's all shrubs
- jdkee 5y agoI wonder if this building will have issues with water damage 25 years from now.
- objclxt 5y agoI am reminded of the BEST stores, many of which were designed to look like they were falling apart or unfinished: https://www.archdaily.com/778003/the-intersection-of-art-and-architecture-the-best-products-showrooms-by-site-sculpture-in-the-environment https://www.archdaily.com/778003/the-intersection-of-art-and...
- Larrikin 5y agoDisappointed that there were atleast two in Richmond and I never saw the interesting one. There was a Best right down the street and it was my favorite store as a kid to explore, but it was in a generic strip mall. Spent a lot of time there playing the Sega Genesis display.
- mzs 5y agoneat: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Best_Products#More_History_needed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Best_Products#More_Histor... > … An order was written up and turned into one of the service desks and sent to the warehouse in a plastic tube "shot" through a pneumatic line. The tube was opened by an order picker who read the catalog numbers on the order slip which told the picker where the merchandise was located in the warehouse. It was picked, the slip was attached to the product, it was sent down a roller belt where a carbon copy of the order slip was given to a cashier who paiged the shopper to the register. The transaction was completed and the customer took the receipt to the pick up area and received their product when they were ready to leave the store. Seems like alot of work, but the entire process was done in less than five minutes time. …
- owyn 5y agoB&H photo has something like this too. When you want to buy something, they bring it up from the warehouse. [1] https://www.core77.com/posts/81735/BnHs-Innovative-Overhead-Conveyor-Belt-System-for-Retail-and-a-Brief-Company-History https://www.core77.com/posts/81735/BnHs-Innovative-Overhead-...
- jacquesm 5y agoWe had stores like that in NL, the 'Kijkshop' concept, they went bust a while ago. Limited selection of marginal quality goods. But no shoplifting and no broken stuff on display.
- hannasanarion 5y agoThe finished building will look nothing like the renders. The "crack" that's shown in all the renders as filled with lush greenery faces north. It will be in permanent shade. If they actually do plant all those trees, they'll be dead within months.
- booi 5y agoIt looks like to the south of the building is the river. They probably optimized that side for residential units to increase profits. That being said, they could always use massive lights to keep the trees alive...
- hannasanarion 5y agoNah, the river is on the other side of the traintracks further to the north. To the south is the Cole and Five Points neighborhoods, which are in early stages of redevelopment
- conductr 5y agoThis can be said for nearly every architectural rendering. They aren’t used by architects to build/design, they are used by sales to sell.
- WillPostForFood 5y agoThere are plenty of tree and plant choices that don't need direct sunlight. Denver is a sunny city, with the right choices it will be green and thrive.
- dasil003 5y agoAll good, they'll just put one of these across the street: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/20_Fenchurch_Street https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/20_Fenchurch_Street
- ericbarrett 5y agoIf you hike in temperate, mountainous areas, you'll find the greenest areas are on the north slopes (in the northern hemisphere—in other words, the shady side). Maybe not with the plants in the renders, but making it green shouldn't be a problem.
- sigstoat 5y agothey're going to have to pump in stupendous amounts of water to keep that much plant life green, 6 to 16 stories up off the ground, in colorado. hopefully they can at least use the building's own greywater or something.
- trgn 5y agoThis kind of architecture is absolutely cringe-y. The architects basically out themselves as detached sociopaths, and the patrons out themselves as gullible idiots. A building like this is a shtick. "Cool" for about 5 minutes. It will not age gracefully. The people behind this project confuse architecture with sculpture.
- colordrops 5y agoI'm curious, what are examples of architecture you admire?
- hannasanarion 5y agoI like architecture that isn't covered in dead trees a few months after completion because the idiot billionaire funder doesn't understand that there's no sun on the north side of a building in the northern hemisphere.
- WJW 5y agoPlenty of trees grow on the north side of hills though. Not every tree needs full sunlight.
- trgn 5y agoArchitecture which does not fetishize the engineering aesthetic, which is mindful of its impact on the public realm, and which does not consider the building-proper as an artistic expression in and of itself. Basically, anything before modernism, before WW1 is generally good. Or really, anything before cars. The rise of car culture and the decline of architecture are directly correlated. I personally had a hard time articulating why I found contemporary architecture so revolting, it was just a feeling. Then I found videos by Leon Krier (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFiYL8AvvnY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFiYL8AvvnY), or Nathan Lewis's blog series on the topic (https://newworldeconomics.com/category/traditional-city-post-heroic-materialism/ https://newworldeconomics.com/category/traditional-city-post...), and everything suddenly just clicked.
- pharke 5y agoI'm curious as to why more high rise buildings don't incorporate "park floors" or large balconies. The walls are non-structural after all so you could push them further into the building and have an open air space. You could add extra headroom by making those floor taller as well. Is it simply a cost issue? Everyone is just trying to maximize "livable area" at the expense of not making the structure itself more livable?
- R0b0t1 5y agoYes, just a cost issue. The park floors is a really good idea, especially for very high density city developments. I had some ideas in similar thrust to yours, I think it's worth following up on. One of the cooler things you could do is space the floor plates so that you give people berths in a building. They then install walls and possibly a subfloor and run utilities. If they want to leave the space open they can, if they want to cut it up into rooms they can.
- hannasanarion 5y agoCost, and also practicality. Most of the "green building" plans that you see come from artists with no knowledge of construction or engineering working in 3D programs where everything is weightless, and all building materials are free and have infinite strength. Trees are heavy. Assuming a fairly mature tree with a 10-inch diameter trunk and around 20 feet of height, the wood alone weighs around 800 pounds, and that's before you consider the soil that the tree sits in (100 lbs per cubic foot, so at least a ton for the whole planter) or the water that it needs (100 gallons per week ~800 pounds)
- R0b0t1 5y agoFloor plate loading is 50-250lbs/sqft over the entire area, with hotspots far greater. If what you really wanted was trees you could put them in there. I think he may have meant more just an open green area.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- athenot 5y agoThe trees and greenery make for a beautiful render, but I'm reminded of this article from 2013, "Can we please stop drawing trees on top of skyscrapers?" https://www.archdaily.com/346374/can-we-please-stop-drawing-trees-on-top-of-skyscrapers https://www.archdaily.com/346374/can-we-please-stop-drawing-...
- ashtonbaker 5y agoI'm also reminded of https://www.currentaffairs.org/2017/10/why-you-hate-contemporary-architecture https://www.currentaffairs.org/2017/10/why-you-hate-contempo...
- yummypaint 5y agoNone of the depicted trees appear to be native to the region either. Tropical looking vegetation will look very out of place in Denver, and will be resource and time intensive to maintain, assuming it can actually survive exposed. This building looks like it was designed for Singapore, and doesn't do anything to aesthetically connect to the region.
- fimdomeio 5y agoAlso article and podcast episode on 99% invisible: Renderings vs. Reality: The Improbable Rise of Tree-Covered Skyscrapers https://99percentinvisible.org/article/renderings-vs-reality-rise-tree-covered-skyscrapers/ https://99percentinvisible.org/article/renderings-vs-reality...
- Pxtl 5y agoGo visit Singapore. Tree-covered skyscrapers are reality there. Probably has something to do with being a rainy tropical island, of course.
- Aromasin 5y agoI must admit, I do like the design, but why don't we get buildings where the crack style extends to the whole structure? I can think of 1000's of artist renders of what the architecture of the future will look like (eg. https://www.yankodesign.com/images/design_news/2020/04/259791/06_TesseractScraper_evoloskyscraper_yankodesign.jpg https://www.yankodesign.com/images/design_news/2020/04/25979...), but I can't think of one building when I've seen it put into practice. I've seen much less feasible designs engineering wise made into reality. Why are these "utopic" buildings left to fiction?
- Arainach 5y agoBecause they're dramatically more expensive than standard rectangular prisms for comparatively little benefit and significantly less usable/sellable square feet per acre.
- Aromasin 5y agoGranted, but there are also countries in the UAE that throw billions at these sorts of projects as little more than a side hobby it seems. I'm not asking why aren't all buildings like that, I know full well. I'm curious why there are NO buildings like tis.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoit’s the Frank Lloyd Wright curse: his houses are beautiful but maintenance nightmares - the first time you build a new design, it’s going to leak. as soon as you get creative, you’ll get seams that settle and crack in unpredictable ways. cubes are not the strongest form (rhombic dodecahedrons are better) but it’s not the weakest form either, you start playing with acute and obtuse angles you might come up with something fragile. best to stick with right angles. I turn my nose up at rectangular buildings as much as the next guy (my house, at least, is an octagon) but we’ve become very skilled at building rectangles that don’t leak / collapse.
- dymax78 5y agoReminds me more of an avant garde design by BIG than MAD.
- testplzignore 5y agoMy first thought upon seeing the rendering: a giant jagged gash in a building reminds me of September 11th. Not the kind of thing I would want to see every day...
- lathyrus_long 5y agoHere's an article on the technical challenges of a different treed building, Italy's Bosco Verticale: https://global.ctbuh.org/resources/papers/download/2099-a-new-urban-forest-rises-in-milan.pdf https://global.ctbuh.org/resources/papers/download/2099-a-ne... The weight of the soil and water isn't negligible, but it's not that bad. Most plants will grow happily in a tiny fraction of their root volume in nature, as long as precise irrigation delivers water (or fertilizer solution) just as it's needed. The practical root volume is probably chosen mostly based on the longest expected fault in the irrigation system. The tiny root system also provides a very weak attachment to the building. Bosco Verticale strapped each tree to a vertical steel cable, plus various additional restraints.
- dirtyid 5y agoConcept is fine, but I can't imagine this surviving Denver winters.
- caseyohara 5y agoDenver winters are not exactly harsh, there's still plenty of sunshine in the winter months. Flora grows back in the spring, every other park survives the winter.
- rwmj 5y agoIn other news, the UK government rejected the London "Tulip" skyscraper: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-59253160 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-59253160 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-46259419 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-46259419
- leoedin 5y agoI find it hilarious how public figures criticising the tower talk around the fact it looks like a giant penis. I also can't believe it was seriously proposed. I mean, look at it!
- quantified 5y agoIs it the tulip’s fault? At least it wasn’t the Mushroom Tower.
- vgel 5y agoI read this, thought "It can't be that bad", clicked it, and burst out laughing...
- Waterluvian 5y agoI feel like this can look gorgeous and thought provoking if people manage to keep the greenery looking as-intended. I wonder if they do worst case renderings too or if they just focus entirely on their art project.
- tromp 5y agoReminds me of the Viñoly office tower in Amsterdam, although that has a straight crack spiraling around the building: https://www.brandveiligmetstaal.nl/upload/Image/projecten/project13-1.jpg https://www.brandveiligmetstaal.nl/upload/Image/projecten/pr...
- markdown 5y ago"The nature-inspired design by MAD Architects was influenced by C̶o̶l̶o̶r̶a̶d̶o̶’̶s̶ ̶l̶e̶g̶e̶n̶d̶a̶r̶y̶ ̶l̶a̶n̶d̶f̶o̶r̶m̶s̶ ̶ Singapore."
- ldbooth 5y agoAm I the only one who thinks: just make the whole facade trees/greenery?
- jonstewart 5y agoI was expecting this to be a disaster/engineering story. A classic in that genre is the 1995 story in the New Yorker about the Citicorp building: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1995/05/29/the-fifty-nine-story-crisis https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1995/05/29/the-fifty-nine...
- Animats 5y agoThe 1990s had Frank Gehry. This is the next generation.
- gonesilent 5y agoI don't think it'll be very green green Denver's winters.
- rytis 5y agoI wish there'd be more architects avoiding using full-glass facade. This design looks interesting, but (at least to me) somewhat disturbing. Yes, they make the "artistic" statement, but we're not talking about a picture in a gallery, this is going to be visible by a lot of people and for a long time. The urban environment is affecting people, so I think they should be more careful with these experiments... https://geneticsofdesign.com/2019/07/27/how-bostons-glassy-seaport-fails/ https://geneticsofdesign.com/2019/07/27/how-bostons-glassy-s... In the surrounding sea of glass (including three large spaces on the same building) the crack looks really out of place, and draws the attention too much, It's also not regular, which fights against our desire for uniformity. Just feels very out of place, at least to me. Interesting nonetheless, but I wouldn't want to look at it every day for years... :)
- account-5 5y agoLooks good, but always when I see stuff like this I just think functionally it's just for show. I'm function over form every time. What's it going to look it in 10/20 years. I feel the "inspired by nature" bit is non-sense. There's better ways of "surrounding yourself by nature" that is more functional and not as gimmicky.
- cafard 5y agoMAD Architects? Am I the only one who thinks of potrzebie?