3 ms·
> You can still dislike videos to further personalize and tune your recommendations. If I come across a low-quality rip of Dark Side of the Moon and dislike it
by dotancohen 5y ago
> You can still dislike videos to further personalize and tune your recommendations.
If I come across a low-quality rip of Dark Side of the Moon and dislike it, will Youtube recommend to me less Pink Floyd or less low quality rips? What if I dislike that horrible Barenboim performance of Beethoven's Ninth? Will I get less Beethoven or less horrible performances? What about reports of Israel killing Gazan children, when the video footage clearly shows children killed when a Hamas projectile they were "guarding" prematurely detonated? Do I get less news or less lies? What about that idiot who knows a lot about cars and car history (Donut maybe) but screams and acts like he graduated from Animal House? Do I get less informative car videos or less puerile screaming and sentences composed of 15 cuts, sometimes right in the middle of a compound word?
I think that basing recommendations on a single dimension is flawed in its own right.
- dotancohen 5y agoI just went to Youtube's homepage for the first time in ages, to see what it would recommend for me. I saw maybe a dozen suggested videos just to check it out. And I would say that all but two had either a misleading title or a misleading thumbnail. These are things directly related to my interests: self defense, computer security, lockpicking, spaceflight, physics, automobiles. But other than the young man talking about SpaceX (Marcus House) and the Lock Picking Lawyer, every single video had either a title that misrepresented or completely lied about the content, or a very attractive thumbnail that was barely tangentially associated with the content.
- josteink 5y agoWelcome to monetised platforms with a “infinite” global reach. People are going to game it. They are going to cheat. Especially when the platform itself allows it. But hey! “Small creators!”, right?