4 ms·
> Why, ethically, should this cost fall on Uber instead of the driver? Either way an inefficient market is being created here because the government is stepping
by whimsicalism 5y ago
> Why, ethically, should this cost fall on Uber instead of the driver? Either way an inefficient market is being created here because the government is stepping in and saying that a transaction made between two rational actors is unfair even if those parties agree to the terms of the transaction (unless Uber is a monopoly).
You are relying on "ethical" principles that I would say are alien to the vast majority of people.
There is no reason why Pareto efficiency should be ethically prioritized if the alternative is welfare enhancing in the aggregate.
- recursive4 5y agoRespectfully, I don't think we can say axiomatically that welfare is enhanced in the aggregate by Uber stakeholders ({drivers|employees|shareholders}) sacrificing in favor of the disabled because the Nth degree ethical consequences are unknowable.
- whimsicalism 5y agoMy claim is that there is nothing about Pareto efficiency that is ethically preferable to a situation in which more people are better off. Arguing that this policy would render some consensual exchanges illicit is irrelevant, because I don't think the most ethical outcome is axiomatically realized by solely consensual exchange without any coercion.
- toolz 5y agoCan you describe to me a situation in which reaching pareto efficiency would, in your opinion, not be the optimal state for the welfare of the aggregate? I'm trying to imagine a situation where resources are optimally distributed where that would be suboptimal for the welfare of everyone. edit: I'm new to the concept of pareto efficiency, so hopefully this reads more as a sincere question rather than a challenge to your opinion
- whimsicalism 5y agoSure. Imagine a situation with two people and a state-like actor. One person has all of the food in the entire world minus one loaf of bread. The other person has one loaf of bread. After they eat that loaf, they will probably die of starvation in the next 30 days. This is a Pareto efficient distribution. If the state-like actor intervened and re-distributed some of the food to the other person (with coercion), I would argue that aggregate welfare would be improved.
- toolz 5y agoThat makes sense, I guess there's subjectivity involved as to what that would look like as I imagine the death of one of those people would be an unwanted consequence to the person with all the food and as such the first person would be better off giving food to the starving person. Your point makes sense to me now though, so thanks
- whimsicalism 5y ago> unwanted consequence to the person with all the food and as such the first person would be better off giving food to the starving person. Doesn't really play out that way in actual real life (people still starve every day and both you and i probably have the resources to stop at least one of those starvation deaths), so didn't think of including this altruism in my toy model
- jjk166 5y agoThat's not a pareto efficient distribution. The efficient option would be for the person with bread to sell bread to the person without bread in exchange for future labor. Pareto efficiency is defined to be an economic state where resources cannot be reallocated to make one individual better off without making at least one individual worse off. If a redistribution can make things better, it is not an efficient state.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> The efficient option would be for the person with bread to sell bread to the person without bread in exchange for future labor. Okay, with work, let's say they are given the bare minimum to survive and they will get their work done (no rational reason to offer a higher wage). It would still be welfare enhancing to re-distribute. > If a redistribution can make things better, it is not an efficient state. This is just straight-up false, no other comment. Not what Pareto efficiency. The redistribution makes the person taken from worse off.