3 ms·
People have been talking about the "rickety foundation" of China for decades. I'm sure when they have an economic downturn sometime in the next two decades, tho
by whimsicalism 5y ago
People have been talking about the "rickety foundation" of China for decades. I'm sure when they have an economic downturn sometime in the next two decades, those people will all come out to crow about how they had been right all along.
To me, they seem to be building on top of a more modern infrastructure base and do not have the super-prevalent NIMBY problems that exist in the West.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> People have been talking about the "rickety foundation" of China for decades Economically, sure. (Those always struck me as sour grapes or a fundamental misunderstanding of how debt works in a centrally-planned economy.) Politically, however, the CCP had intraparty competition that avoided the sort of rot that felled the Soviets. It also kept the Party thinking long term. Hong Kong and Taiwan are good examples of Xi's impatience. Absent intervention, Hong Kong would have uncontroversially folded into China in 2047. The combination of China's military and economic prowess, then, could have encouraged peaceful unification with Taiwan. But Xi was impatient. He wanted it in his lifetime. So he rushed Hong Kong and screwed up not only Taiwan, but relations with all his neighbors, from the Philippines to India. Dictators like to style themselves as monarchs. But monarchy has a continuity that dictatorships don't. That makes them more impatient and more unstable, particularly at the transfer of power.
- boringg 5y agoAgreed - the fundamental political structure is flawed. However we don't know how long it will take for that structure to break or change. Currently Xi is making some moves (with the historical resolution) to retain power indefinitely. There are also economic problems in China that Evergrande has brought to the attention - the wild speculation in real estate that is concerning for the party to maintain control. As well with the tech crackdown recently. In broad brushes it points to some problems over there (manageable probably - but risks for control of the party).
- rgbrenner 5y agoIn 8 years, China is not going to rot to the degree you're referring to. So Xi made a mistake and maybe cost China Taiwan... but in no way does China's future depend on Taiwan. He has to make a lot more mistakes or be in power much longer. Right now, his tenure could be compared to a bad US president... we survive that sort of damage fine (it's not good, but the country isnt going to fail).
- majormajor 5y ago> To me, they seem to be building on top of a more modern infrastructure base and do not have the super-prevalent NIMBY problems that exist in the West. How new the roads and houses are doesn't seem like the most relevant factor for future economic growth. The US built modern infra for the time, then it stagnated. Japan built modern infra for the time, then it stagnated. The US and Japan otherwise took very divergent economic growth paths. China could go either way, but the increasing central control is hardly without risk for future economic development. Miss a few big bets and you have less of a backup plan than a less-organized economy.