11 ms·
Justice Department sues Uber for overcharging people with disabilities
- KarlKemp 5y agoNow that's a lawsuit that is going to cost you in PR about ten times what any fine will likely amount to, a hundred times what you made with the policy, and exactly as much as you deserve for being a caricature of the scumbag corporation stereotype.
- oh_sigh 5y agoThis seems like a crime through lack of thought not a willful middle finger to the disabled to make a few percent more in late fees.
- Miner49er 5y agoUber has a long history of discriminating against people with disabilities. I'd be shocked if they didn't know that this was a problem.
- erehweb 5y agoPossibly. But if you're a big company, then not thinking about the impact of your product on the disabled is wilful ignorance, even if it doesn't make you that much more money.
- dastbe 5y agoarticle from nytimes with more context and uber's response: https://archive.md/AHBG4 https://archive.md/AHBG4 not to pick a side, but doesn't the crux of the lawsuit fail if uber is now waiving wait fees for people who have a disability? or are they also going after drivers who cancel/harass riders who have disabilities, similar to what happened with lyft?
- jedberg 5y agoA perfect example of equality vs equity. Uber treated everyone equally, but it wasn't equitable. I feel bad for the drivers. I have kids and I know it takes me longer to get in the car than just an adult. I wish there was a way to indicate in the app "traveling with kids" so the driver could get a bonus for picking me up, which I'd gladly pay for. But in this case, Uber should still pay the driver the waiting fee but not charge the rider. It should be on Uber to cover this cost of doing business.
- kyleee 5y agoGood point. Honestly I don't think that uber should allow drivers to use any vehicles not equipped for wheel chair transport. The discrimination and inequity, as you've noted, runs very deep with uber and indeed many other companies
- handrous 5y agoHow do normal taxi services handle this? I really have no idea. I assume better, since they'd have already dealt with these sorts of suits decades ago if they didn't.
- OldHand2018 5y agoI looked into buying a taxi medallion recently - they are historically very cheap and would dramatically increase in value if Uber and Lyft fail. Turns out that there are a lot of financial incentives available from city/state/federal governments for attaching the taxi medallion to a wheelchair-accessible vehicle.
- alistairSH 5y agoFor wheelchairs, in DC and the suburbs (VA and MD), the customer calls and asks for a wheelchair-accessible taxi. IIRC, taxi fleets are required to maintain a certain % of the fleet as wheelchair-accessible. Wait times for dispatch can be quite long. In DC, there's an initial fee (charged for the pickup and first 1/8 mile). Additional wait-time fees start accruing after 5 minutes. Mileage/time fees then get added by the meter as the ride progresses. This formula applies to all taxis - wheelchair or not.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gabriel_fishman 5y agoMy girlfriend has a visual impairment. When it's dark outside, it can take awhile for her to locate the Uber and get to it. A number of times she's been unable to locate the Uber and the driver has just left. I'll have to look and see if she's been charged wait fees. There was another incident which was caused by a very poor UI decision by Uber (or maybe just a bug). She scheduled a ride in advance from her work to a doctor's office. Then when she went to get a ride home (this time in real time, not scheduling in advance), the origin was set by default to the last place she scheduled a ride from - her workplace, NOT her current location at the doctor's office. She didn't realize that Uber wasn't doing its usual thing of setting the origin to your current location, so the driver showed up at her workplace. She ended up paying the driver cash to come to the doctor's office and pick her up from there.
- Someone1234 5y agoWhat they ask in relief: > The lawsuit seeks relief from the court, including ordering Uber to stop discriminating against individuals with disabilities. Additionally, the department asks the court to order Uber to modify its wait time fee policy to comply with the ADA; train its staff and drivers on the ADA; pay money damages to people subjected to the illegal wait time fees; and pay a civil penalty to vindicate the public’s interest in eliminating disability discrimination.
- recursive4 5y agoA few thoughts come to mind: - How should a person with disabilities indicate that they have a disability requiring extra time in a fraud proof manner? - Should all disabilities be treated equally? - Who decides how much time should be granter per? - Should this same policy apply to people with ephemeral injuries? - Should Uber compensate the driver for this extra time to ensure the driver is still incentivized to pick up people with disabilities? - Why, ethically, should this cost fall on Uber instead of the driver? Either way an inefficient market is being created here because the government is stepping in and saying that a transaction made between two rational actors is unfair even if those parties agree to the terms of the transaction (unless Uber is a monopoly). If the driver is not compensated fairly for their time, why is this sacrifice ethically permissible?
- kelnos 5y ago> - Should this same policy apply to people with ephemeral injuries? Are these sorts of things considered "disabilities" though, from the perspective of ADA and other disability-related laws? A bunch of years ago I broke my foot and was on crutches for 8 weeks. I don't recall it being that difficult to get to my Ubers in time (they may have been more lax with wait time back in 2014). It didn't occur to me to even think I should be entitled to extra time. > - Should all disabilities be treated equally? I would assume not? IIRC the key phrase in disability cases is "reasonable accommodation". I think it's reasonable to grant someone extra time if they have a mobility issue, but perhaps not if they have something like diabetes? - How should a person with disabilities indicate that they have a disability requiring extra time in a fraud proof manner? That might not matter? From what I understand, the ADA (and similar laws) are worded and interpreted to give the person claiming a disability the benefit of the doubt. I would guess that Uber is expected to eat the cost of fraud here, unless they can prove in specific instances fraud occurred. In general, though, the opposite case is much worse: denying an accommodation because you (erroneously) believe no accommodation is needed can get you in big trouble. > - Should Uber compensate the driver for this extra time to ensure the driver is still incentivized to pick up people with disabilities? Personally I would say yes, definitely. I know this isn't how Uber works from the driver perspective, but the "meter" should start running as soon as the driver gets to the pickup spot. Uber eats (or builds in) the cost of a reasonable "grace period" for riders, which is Uber's decision. Ignoring the disability question, if Uber drivers were truly independent contractors and had full autonomy, they could certainly decide to give riders zero time: either be at the pickup location already when the driver arrives, or you miss your ride. (Not saying this is a good policy, but in theory this could be something that's allowed; pre-Uber taxis in San Francisco would sometimes do this, and it sucked.) Not sure if Uber should specifically note "this person is disabled so you'll be getting a little more money as compensation for waiting longer"; probably not? Though I guess after they accept the ride and arrive at the pickup point, they'll see their required pickup wait time be 8 minutes instead of 4 (or whatever), so they'll at least know at that point. > - Why, ethically, should this cost fall on Uber instead of the driver? Because, despite Uber's insistence that drivers are independent contractors and are not employees, Uber still sets ride pricing and does not give drivers all that much flexibility in what fares they are willing to take (that is, they don't give drivers much information up-front about fare details, to avoid discrimination). Ultimately, though, the cost will more likely fall on riders (all riders, that is), not drivers; the rational response here from Uber will be to raise the cost of every ride slightly, in order to cover the added cost to transport people with disabilities.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoAfter Prop 22, I gave up on Uber. Uber never gets another penny from me. Not surprised that Uber shifts responsibility.
- foo92691 5y agoWait fees seem pretty reasonable. Maybe the solution is to have them subsidized by the government for qualified individuals.
- recursive4 5y agoThis is my personal opinion. If society decides that a sacrifice should be made in favor of a disabled Uber customer, society should incur that cost and compensate the Uber driver the market rate for their time. Wait fees, in this case, are not being used (in the abstract) to discriminate because there is an time cost inherent in this business model that somebody needs to inur.
- vkou 5y agoWhen a private business has to meet the legal demands set out by laws governing serving disabilities, it is up to the business in question to shoulder those costs, not society. Don't like it? Close down shop. Someone else's business will replace you, you won't be missed, and life will go on. It's outrageous to suggest that private businesses have to be bribed so that they follow the law.
- xboxnolifes 5y agoIt's not about "bribing". It's about using positive incentive-based economic policy instead of outright bans if certain regulations aren't met. Requiring companies to support certain things doesn't suddenly make them free. Either way, society eventually shoulders the costs. It just comes down to which members shoulder it more.
- RHSeeger 5y ago>> It's outrageous to suggest that private businesses have to be bribed so that they follow the law. > It's not about "bribing". It's about using positive incentive-based economic policy instead of outright bans if certain regulations aren't met. And, to be very clear, this is done constantly. If you leave your home to go anywhere but a nature walk, I guarantee you you pass within close range of at least entity that is getting/generating some sort of rebate or similar for following a regular. Energy rebates alone are everywhere you look.
- alberth 5y agoDumb question: so who gets the money from this lawsuit? Does the government keep it or does the government distribute it to all who were impacted?
- dawsmik 5y agoOn the DOJ website, they were asking for reimbursement of past disabled people who had to pay a fee to be paid.
- slownews45 5y agoLooking at this uber charged folks with disabilities on the same basis as those without, not differently. So the discrimination claim is that they should have not charged folks with disabilities the waiting fee.
- cududa 5y agoIn 2017 had a broken knee, hand, and ribs. Lived on the fourth floor of a building with no elevator. Only left to go to physical therapy, and took me a half hour to scoot down the stairs to the sidewalk. When Uber drivers saw me in my braces and crutches they'd drive off - and it makes you feel like shit when you already can barely move, then something like that happens. Lyft drivers, as I learned, were trained to help disabled people get into the car and were just so obscenely kinds about the whole ordeal. Getting back up the stairs was about an hour long process. Early on had at least 5 Lyft drivers turn off their pickups and help me get back to my apartment. When you're in a state of limited mobility and vulnerability like that, that kind of kindness is unimaginably appreciated. But it's a culture thing, even if the drivers are just "gig" workers - whatever Lyft was doing brought about folks that'd help you get laid down and comfortable in the back seat, and sometimes, without request, insist they help you up the stairs even if it took them nearly an hour. I was cash strapped at the time and gave the most generous tips I could, but most folks refused it. It's just wild that whatever top-level edicts were at Uber versus Lyft, the level of compassion displayed varied so much.