4 ms·
It was the other way around. During the time of the New Deal, the military industrial complex was yet to exist. There was no OSHA. They hired anybody off the st
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
It was the other way around. During the time of the New Deal, the military industrial complex was yet to exist. There was no OSHA. They hired anybody off the street to build the Hoover Dam, a bunch of them died, but the dam got built.
This was followed almost immediately by WWII, which was more of the same.
But then all the people making a living from this didn't want the money train to stop when the war ended so they hired lobbyists and the military industrial complex was born. Which made government ineffective, wasteful, and disdainful of the very people it was meant to serve. Enter Reagan.
To get back to the old thing you would have to first dissolve the military industrial complex. And then somehow prevent it from reforming.
The government already spends a higher percentage of GDP than they did during the 1930s, and real GDP per capita is also significantly higher so this is more even in real dollars per capita than it was during the New Deal. The problem is that parasites are sucking it all out and it doesn't go where you want it to go because of the corruption.
- N1H1L 5y agoPretty wrong. Dupont was the military-industrial complex, way before New Deal. The military industrial complex is not some new thing. Alfred Nobel did not become rich selling candies to children.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- shipman05 5y agoAre you arguing that Reagan reined in the military industrial complex? While you may be able to plausibly argue that he reduced government waste in some areas (emphasis on MAY), there is zero room for an argument that he somehow cut the fat on military spending. Under his administration, military spending (deficit spending, mind you, none of this was paid for) increased: "Reagan significantly increased public expenditures, primarily the Department of Defense, which rose (in constant 2000 dollars) from $267.1 billion in 1980 (4.9% of GDP and 22.7% of public expenditure) to $393.1 billion in 1988 (5.8% of GDP and 27.3% of public expenditure); most of those years military spending was about 6% of GDP, exceeding this number in 4 different years. All these numbers had not been seen since the end of U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War in 1973." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaganomics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaganomics
- arrosenberg 5y agoI don't really understand what you are getting at, your points seem sort of disjointed. The comment I was responding to asked "Why can't this work in the US", and I don't think anything you've said refutes my point that Ronald Reagan's presidency is responsible for the shift in attitudes against public participation and enthusiasm for public works and administration. There is no doubt that the New Deal platform was becoming somewhat wasteful toward the end of its' era, but it was still serving the broader public. Post-Reagan the government has been far less involved in directing the economy toward the benefit of the majority, and the conservative movement he fostered has worked tireless to ensure people don't trust the government to do anything.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe problem was that by the time of Reagan, corruption had already taken root and was diverting the money from useful public purposes to the pockets of anybody with a good lobbyist. Contemporary example: Instead of having the government build new housing developments and then sell them into the market, any it does build are designated as "affordable housing" with restricted access to limit their impact on the market price of housing, i.e. to keep them from actually making housing more affordable. Meanwhile there are rental subsidies that don't increase the housing stock and thereby primarily benefit landlords. How do you fix this when the problem is powerful lobbyists capable of unseating politicians who try? Reagan never solved this. Government spending didn't really go down. The theory ("starve the beast") was that if they lowered taxes, the tax reduction would be sticky (because people like that) and then the budget crunch would cause politicians to have to trim the pork. But the cuts never happened. The lobbyists were too strong. So now we just run bigger deficits. Nobody has ever solved the problem. If you give the modern US government a dollar, it goes to building tanks the army doesn't want or inflating the cost of healthcare, because those industries have strong lobbyists. To get it to go to building dams or meaningfully increasing the housing stock or anything like that, you not only have to fight Lockheed Martin for the dollar, you also have to fight the coal lobby who don't want more hydro, or the National Association of Realtors who don't want lower housing costs. If you can't answer how to solve that, you can't get publicly beneficial government projects. And what we get instead is very expensive trash.
- clairity 5y agoas an aside, the seeds of the military-industrial complex started with WWI (from observing japan and germany), not WWII, though it didn’t really get going until the impending second war impelled it into overdrive via the reconstituted war production board. and it didn’t really become part of the popular vernacular until 1961 via eisenhower’s speech about it. by then it was already an entrenched part of our gdp, to our collective detriment (it uncovered for other industries the government teat from which to suck money).