4 ms·
I was expecting a data driven argument but the bits of data shared actually contradict the author. These companies mentioned are collectively worth $500B, after
by paxys 5y ago
I was expecting a data driven argument but the bits of data shared actually contradict the author. These companies mentioned are collectively worth $500B, after taking $100B in venture capital. They are starting to get profitable. Demand for their services is increasing.
This article is thousands of words of the exact same talking points we have been hearing for a decade. What's the "after all" part?
- jjulius 5y ago>They are starting to get profitable. No. They posted an adjusted Q3 profit of $8M, with an actual Q3 loss of $2.4B.
- cactus2093 5y agoThe $2.4B loss is a write-down of their ownership in Didi which has nothing to do with the basic economics of Uber's operations.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 5y agoWasn't part of the basic operations to pay for capturing all the markets?
- edanm 5y agoPresumably no, because that was a one-off fee.
- ashtonkem 5y ago"We're worth 5X what the investors put in despite losing all that money so far" strikes me as an argument for it being a bubble, not against.
- newfonewhodis 5y ago> They are starting to get profitable I don't know what you are basing this on but it's definitely not based on data. $UBER EPS over the last few quarters: -1.28 0.61 -0.06 -0.54 -0.62 $DASH EPS -0.30 -0.34 -2.67 The only way they are getting profitable is on an "adjusted basis", in other words when they exclude most of their expenses. That's not a business, that's a game.
- mmazing 5y agoI still contend that many of these types of "startups" are merely elaborate ponzi schemes. Actually, I think a lot of businesses are just that.
- Ekaros 5y agoThey are not even ponzi schemes. They are blackholes, which if they are lucky are IPOed/sold to greater fools...
- mmazing 5y agoRight, but, the owners end up pocketing a substantial portion of investor money. Look at WeWork. If you need 10 rounds of funding to keep running, your profit model is "obtain investor money". (Probably controversial, but IMO 3 rounds of funding is pretty sus.)
- edanm 5y ago> Actually, I think a lot of businesses are just that. Can you explain what you mean by that? People often say this and I never really understand what they mean. Most businesses which aren't unicorns just sell stuff for money. What's a ponzi scheme about it? I also think calling these startups ponzi schemes is disingenuous. They are not lying about anything - they're offering a very clear, risky bet to people, which some people are taking up. That's their choice. (If they are lying or committing fraud, then obviously that's a different story).
- mmazing 5y agoI've known several entrepreneurs in my life that simply lived off investor money and never really got anything out the door. They would come up with a new idea, get money, and then botch the execution, over and over. I've been a part of companies where the owners cashed out millions of dollars after round 3 of funding where the business never really sustained itself, yet continued to receive funding. In the end, both examples didn't really mind if the business failed, because they already got their massive paycheck from it. To me, that's some sort of legal ponzi scheme.