20 ms·
Tuvalu looking at legal ways to be a state if it is submerged
- ape4 5y agoWon't someone think of the top-level domain!
- visarga 5y agoRaise a 5m wall.
- sharmin123 5y agoIs It Possible to Hire Hackers Online?: https://www.hackerslist.co/is-it-possible-to-hire-hackers-online/ https://www.hackerslist.co/is-it-possible-to-hire-hackers-on...
- rectang 5y agoIf the worst case scenario happens and Tuvalu is submerged, how will the state manage to survive even without territory? Is that in the best interest of its citizens? Can any of the nation's collective wealth be preserved, either in the form of an enduring landless state as proposed, or by in some way transferring that wealth as the citizens emigrate somewhere else? Or is this proposal the futile death throes of a state about to be obliterated by a human-made disaster?
- SoapSeller 5y agoThey always have the option of building a platform(Sealand[0] like) and claim the territory. Probably there still few advantages to be recognized as nation. Being Tax shelter and selling domains(.tv is somewhat popular) comes to mind. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principality_of_Sealand https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principality_of_Sealand
- bin_bash 5y agoSealand isn't a great example considering nobody recognizes it as a country. Tuvalu might get away with it since they would've been a "real" country in the past.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoI assume he just meant a platform resembling that although it should be apparent that would come nowhere close to the size, beauty, or natural wealth of the current islands.
- javert 5y agoMore important than official recognition by other countries, is simply being allowed to exist. Incredibly, Sealand has achieved that.
- dane-pgp 5y agoThat brings to mind some interesting ideas. One of the "business models" for Sealand was to be a "data haven", i.e. offer online hosting of data in a jurisdiction which didn't allow searches or seizures of data or servers. Could Tuvalu provide a similar service, possibly from within the territory of a nation which grants them a legally autonomous region? Similarly, I wonder what would happen if Tuvalu decided its laws should not recognise copyright as a concept any more. The government could run an official "legal" file-sharing site and other countries would have to decide whether to prevent their own citizens from accessing it. I imagine these other countries would lose a lot of sympathy for the people of Tuvalu if such a site were created, though.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThese nations will need to make arrangements to migrate to welcoming host nations, that will allow for local governance similar to how tribal lands work in the US. Wealth could be preserved by seeking restitution from nations according to lifetime emissions (which has led to sea level rise), and creating a trust to manage and distribute the returns from those funds invested to citizens where ever they are. Once submerged, it’s unlikely the land has any value beyond tourism for diving yachties transiting the pacific.
- lastofthemojito 5y agoIt reminds me of the concept of government in exile, similar to how there's been a Tibetan "government" in India since China took Tibet. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_in_exile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_in_exile
- bin_bash 5y agocall me cynical, but would any country be willing to give up its land like that? Tribal lands only exist to give back a small fraction of stolen lands back. Would any country give land to another country just for goodwill?
- ocschwar 5y agoThe most likely resolution would be a land purchase in (for example) Fiji along with a grant of autonomous power on that land, in exchange for a fishing lease in Tuvaluan waters. Fiji gets a share of Tuvaluan fishing grounds, and the Tuvaluans get a place to live AND some protection for their territorial waters by a nation that is still landed.
- selimthegrim 5y agoWhy would Fiji treat them any differently than the Indians?
- ocschwar 5y ago
- lcpriest 5y agoNew Zealand has previously given citizenship to island nation citizens, it is likely that that will continue if things worsen.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoBetween wealthy doomsday preppers and Pacific climate refugees, New Zealand is dealing with the immigrant trends of 2050 today!
- ocschwar 5y agoWell, a nation with a thriving Polynesian culture is probably the best place to collect atoll refugees.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoAnd a liberal democracy that prizes multiculturalism, I absolutely agree they are a good fit. You get all that human capital and goodwill too, it's good business.
- FredPret 5y agoProbably going to help make their damn rugby team even stronger too!
- BitwiseFool 5y agoPerhaps, perhaps not. In Hawaii there is actually a lot of tension between the Kanaka Maoli (Native Hawaiians), the Marshallese, and Micronesians. I am not keen as to exactly why this is, but I think it underscores the importance of providing more resources for both the Pacific Islanders already living receiving limited assistance, and the new arrivals. I think the government shouldn't just assume they'll get along because of shared cultural heritage.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ocschwar 5y agoTuvalu exists as a state because the international community decided to let them. They export coconuts and fishing licenses for hard currency, and there is no way they could muster the money and hardware to defend their patch of the ocean. So if the same institutions that decided to enable the foundation of the republic of Tuvalu decide to protect Tuvualuan territorial waters as a way to give the Tuvaluan diaspora some source of currency with which to start over where they go, then that is what will be,.
- vehbisarikaya 5y agoThey also export .tv domains (e.g., twitch.tv)
- ocschwar 5y agoAnd before that they financed a significant part of their government's budget selling postage stamps to kids like me. Recognized sovereignty can be a source of money in all sorts of ways.
- number6 5y agoSo they can exist forth on the metaverse.
- hasmanean 5y agoThat is a very grim assessment. But yeah they might become the worlds first virtualized state for stateless people.
- number6 5y agoI can already see the Press Release: Meta preserves the Culture and unique Landmarks of Tuvalu on the Metaverse. The State of Tuvalu lives on through the efforts of Meta and is the first fully virtual State.
- 5y ago
- pkphilip 5y agoThey can become a nation where citizens live on boats (if they are ok with that) or on dwellings that exist over water.. or they can increase the height of their island by bringing soil from elsewhere.. or they can make their own islands.
- ocschwar 5y agoThe engineering challenge involved in making that a safe way to live go beyond anything the Tuvaluans can hope to finance.
- b112 5y agoI wonder, because even it they are submerged, it could be 1 foot submerged.... So, trade could bring wood, materials, solar, desalinaton. If done slowly, over years, as parts submerge, it wouldn't be a massive outlay at once. I agree.. not cheap, but individual citizens have to buy building materials currently, their new houses would just be on stilts.
- oblio 5y agoThey just need to persuade the latest crazy, pardon me, eccentric billionaire.
- cblconfederate 5y agoI dont think the UN can recognize that as a state with territory, territorial waters, EEZ etc.
- pkphilip 5y agoWhy not? many countries make their own islands, adjust their coast lands and do other sorts of geoengineering. Building tall platforms isn't that controversial either.
- cblconfederate 5y agoThe UNCLOS allows them to make artificial islands in their EEZ, but to have an EEZ they must be a country first.
- Svip 5y agoThe Sovereign Military Order of Malta has had observer status at the UN since the early 1990s despite having no territory.[0] They issue their own passports and enters intro treaties like a regular state. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_Military_Order_of_Malta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_Military_Order_of_Ma...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- OneTimePetes 5y agoThey even had a tremendous airforce..
- deanCommie 5y agoSo does the Red Cross and the International Olympic Committee [1]. And if you scroll up you see so do many "banks". UN Observer status is most often used to discuss the status of states like Palestines but it has less of an implication of being a sovereign "state" than people think. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_General_Assembly_observers#Other_entities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_General_Assembl...
- L3viathan 5y agoThe order of Malta is on a different level though: It's a sovereign entity in international law[1], the IOC, banks, etc. aren't The only somewhat comparable thing afaik is the Holy See, but that at least has sovereignty over some land (the vatican). [1] although this status is sometimes questioned
- jasomill 5y agoJust to be clear to passers-by, all banks in this list are intergovernmental development organizations, not commercial banks.
- shagmin 5y agoI'm not really optimistic for Tuvalu, I'm guessing their culture may out last any legal standing. But I've learned in history the idea of the modern state with its political borders and such is kind of a novelty. For some people, it's just pointless lines drawn by Europeans from long ago (e.g. Pashtuns on the Afghan/Pakistan border) and others it's something like an inconvenience (e.g. rich people who live anywhere they want, corporations putting their profit far from their headquarters, etc.,) - wish stories like Tuvalu would further the discussion on the role of the nation-state in the modern world, because it looks like we're probably going to have a lot of refugee crises in the decades to come. In a way the world is getting smaller all the time and we even have more people going to space than ever, its own thing beyond geopolitical borders.
- nharada 5y agoSo have we moved from "climate change isn't real" to "it's real but we aren't gonna do anything"? Nobody making long term plans is questioning the science of it, they're just trying to figure out how to be the last ones to starve.
- awestroke 5y agoWhat's the alternative?
- rectang 5y agoRendering climate-science deniers irrelevant and allowing them no influence on the debate is a step forward.
- advice_thrwawy9 5y agoIf we were really going to prevent catastrophic climate change the realistic time to act would have be probably 50-70 years ago. I've become fairly patient with climate deniers over the years since it is both a difficult to imagine idea and contains serious amounts of existential dread, making it very hard to reason about. Because of the latter I don't know anyone, climate scientists and myself included, that aren't in some way climate change deniers. The only possible pathway to dramatically reduced carbon intensity in our economy is the potential of physical resource limitations, not intentional human action. If you study the way energy impacts our civilization (highly recommend Smil's "Energy and Civilization"), it's fairly obvious, if not hard to swallow, that we cannot reduce carbon emissions radically enough in a short enough time span without also destroying the global economy. Destroying the economy today to mitigate the worse case scenarios is risk that even right now no sane person earnestly wants to take. That destruction, on the timeline somewhere in the next 100 years, is inevitable anyway, but nobody really wants to suffer now when the more extreme suffering we're putting off might be in 20 or even 60 years. This is really the heart of the problem: the immediate cost of addressing climate change has always seemed too high given the perceived uncertainty of outcomes. In 1950 it would have been fantastically easier to put a cap on carbon emissions than today, but the real threat of climate change was more than a lifetime away, and seemed ludicrous to even most educated people. But today, meeting the emissions goals required would make the pandemic seem like black Friday as far as economic activity goes. And at the same time, while we know the impact of climate change will be bad, we still don't really know how much we'll each live through and how bad it will be immediately. Maybe we'll see the AMOC shutdown in our lifetimes and Europe will suffer massive crop failure and starvation... and maybe it will just get unlivably hot at the equator, and people from the American Southwest will have to move to the Northeast. As many have pointed out, the pandemic is basically a toy problem version of climate change. In order to really prevent the pandemic we would have had to globally shut down the economy for a few months, much like China did. The problem is if we did that and prevented the pandemic, our world today would remain an imagined counterfactual that would not be perceived as worth the harm by the majority. We completely failed to address pandemic, and we will completely fail to address climate change. We'll find out what that means.
- bobthechef 5y agoWhy not build a system of dikes around the island? What about poldering? Is that feasible here? The island is only 26 square kilometers.
- rbanffy 5y agoI don't think it's feasible with local resources. Breakwaters would help with coastal erosion, but, if done wrong, would cause enormous damage to coastal ecosystems.
- ocschwar 5y agoThe hard part is keeping people living safely on the island.
- roywiggins 5y agoThe land area of Fulafuti is 2.4 square kilometers, but the total area of the atoll is 275 square kilometers: it's a ring of islands surrounding a lagoon. The lagoon is 120 feet deep. The atoll is basically the tip-top of a vast underwater mountain that drops away precipitously: there's nothing to build a dike on. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Funafuti https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Funafuti https://tuvalu-data.sprep.org/system/files/Rapport_de_leve_CPS.pdf https://tuvalu-data.sprep.org/system/files/Rapport_de_leve_C...
- Y_Y 5y agoThen let's make the old land the dike and build everything in the lagoon. Maybe we can mine the Pacific Trash Island for building material.
- roywiggins 5y agoThe density of the pacific garbage patch is not high, it's not an island so much as a denser soup of trash than other areas. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_garbage_patch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_garbage_patch
- trasz 5y agoThere is a precedent: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_Military_Order_of_Malta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_Military_Order_of_Ma...
- beervirus 5y agoPure theater. > Kofe said he delivered the video address, scheduled to be aired at COP26 on Tuesday, in a place that used to be dry land, adding that Tuvalu was seeing a lot of coastal erosion. Coastal erosion, not climate change, not rising sea levels.
- Hamuko 5y ago>Coastal erosion is the loss or displacement of land, or the long-term removal of sediment and rocks along the coastline due to the action of waves, currents, tides, wind-driven water, waterborne ice, or other impacts of storms. >According to the IPCC, sea level rise caused by climate change will increase coastal erosion worldwide, significantly changing the coasts and low-lying coastal areas. Interesting.
- HamburgerEmoji 5y agoCheck any of the NOAA charts and chances are excellent that you'll see the seas rising at, say, 2mm/year, and that there has been no acceleration in the rate for over a hundred years. https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/sltrends_us.html https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/sltrends_us.html
- mbostleman 5y agoYes, one of the causes of coastal erosion can be the effects of climate change. But what is the likelihood that the cause, or even partial cause, of this particular coastal erosion is climate change? I could be wrong, but I doubt that that causation is readily provable in this case. Hence some people that value a strong, empirical case for things like this will tend to take it more as theater than science. I personally think that stunts like this hurt rather than help the cause. But that's just my two cents.
- beervirus 5y agoWhen the sea levels rise a significant amount, sure. How much additional coastal erosion does IPCC think we’re getting now, with sea levels up like 4 inches? My point is that there’s no reason to think that the land Tuvalu has lost has anything to do with climate change. Pretending otherwise is pure theater.
- FredPret 5y agoBuild an underwater server farm and become an offshore (undershore?) banking centre
- bogwog 5y agoOr an underwater city and become the number one tourist destination in the world for the next few years (until everyone else is forced to do the same)
- Y_Y 5y agoSounds like a very expensive aquarium with no exit.
- rbanffy 5y agoBuild a platform on the highest point of the island and call it Sealand II
- asasidh 5y agoThey should look at the metaverse. I am told that is the future.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments, please don't take HN on generic tangents, and especially not generic flamewar tangents. All that leads to predictable and lower-quality discussion. We'd like the vector to point the opposite way here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- asasidh 5y agoWhen disagreeing, please reply to the argument.
- dang 5y agoModeration comments are about the site rules. They're off-topic, but that's (alas) a necessary evil in order to prevent the system from ending up in well-known failure modes. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20%22out%20of%20band%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=tedious%20write%20read%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... If you'd please stick to the rules from now on, we'd appreciate it, and I'd personally appreciate because it would mean fewer tedious moderation comments.
- mherdeg 5y agoI think this is the premise of 1995 Sci-Fi channel classic CARVER'S GATE -- in a grim future where the planet's ecosystem is ruined and its remaining inhabitants struggle to survive, anybody who can afford spends all their time inside their VR helmets living out escapist fantasies. The motivating issue in that film is that a bunch of people play video games, a scientist invents a tool that allows the Doom monsters to come back to earth, and a QA engineer has to hunt them down before they destroy the remaining shreds of humanity. That part is of course unrealistic but otherwise the Metaverse narrative plausibly matches this Michael Parée classic.
- luckydata 5y agoI understand why they are trying to do that but the effort is ridiculous and shows the inadequacy of last centuries' institutions to deal with the current challenges. Reactive in nature as humanity is, nothing will be done until well past due and many will suffer because of it.
- alksjdalkj 5y agoKen Liu has a relevant short story [1] - set in a future Earth where climate change and rising sea levels have forced people to live on floating settlements. It's also included in his collection The Hidden Girl and Other Stories. [1] https://www.lightspeedmagazine.com/fiction/dispatches-from-the-cradle-the-hermit-forty-eight-hours-in-the-sea-of-massachusetts/ https://www.lightspeedmagazine.com/fiction/dispatches-from-t...
- optimalsolver 5y ago"Is a man not entitled to the sweat of his brow"? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cipd-wuHHc0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cipd-wuHHc0
- logfromblammo 5y agoThe time is now to dredge and dump, and build fixed oceanic platforms at their territorial extremes, while the construction crews can still breathe air and weld cheaply. The only motivation any other country has to preserve the EEZ of Tuvalu is to prevent Chinese fishermen from overfishing that part of the ocean into a dead zone, or Chinese excavators drilling all the oil/minerals out of the seabed. So they should play up that aspect, and then they may attract the necessary investment to make a big enough pile of sand at the right coordinates.
- DicIfTEx 5y agoOthers are citing various examples of states without territory, such as the Sovereign Military Order of Malta or various governments-in-exile throughout history, so I thought I'd throw Estonia into the ring, which has its government backed up in Luxembourg in case the Russians invade: https://e-estonia.com/solutions/e-governance/data-embassy/ https://e-estonia.com/solutions/e-governance/data-embassy/
- 310260 5y agoThat is really interesting. Especially the part where they mention their data centers have immunity just like their diplomatic embassies.
- 323 5y agoTuvalu is just 26 sq km. How many bulk carriers filled with dirt you need to raise that by a few meters?
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI'm certain it would be more than Tuvalu could afford, unless they were granted the money by the UN, which seems unlikely. I also can't help but think the dirt would eventually be washed away regardless. The kind of land reclamation places like the Netherlands do isn't applicable on Pacific Low Islands.
- 323 5y agoChina has experience growing islands in the ocean. They are also the biggest polluter right now and they can afford the cost. If Tuvalu allows them to build a naval base in return maybe the US will get involved just to prevent that.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoMy understanding is that the Spratly Islands base China has built is not something that can actually sustain a population trying to live traditionally. They've destroyed the reefs and encircled the dredged area with a sea wall that prevents normal sand beaches from existing. While the terraformed island would be above water, you wouldn't have the kind of ecosystem that is viable or productive.
- int0x2e 5y agoThat could work for Tuvalu, but I hope you realize that if everyone just used that solution to address the sea-level rise due to global warming, you'd end up greatly accelerating both global warming and sea level rise...
- soperj 5y agomajority of coral atolls have actually been growing in the last 50 years, not shrinking.
- hammock 5y agoThe image of the government official standing in the water "on what used to be dry land" is quite dramatic.[1] Unfortunately that land is not underwater due to climate change-driven sea level rise, but due to soil erosion. They do mention this fact, however the focus of the article inexplicably remains on rising sea levels. A factchecker might call that "missing context" (or worse). [1]https://www.reuters.com/resizer/8doSEMId31ayO3rBn1MaCzPgW50=/960x0/filters:quality(80)/cloudfront-us-east-2.images.arcpublishing.com/reuters/XRLGUTBN6NIQ3L5OOFE2FQ32IU.jpg https://www.reuters.com/resizer/8doSEMId31ayO3rBn1MaCzPgW50=...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smnrchrds 5y ago> Unfortunately that land is not underwater due to climate change-driven sea level rise Did anyone think it to be the case? That the sea levels have risen a meter already and we just haven't tuned in to the news recently enough to learn about it?
- postsantum 5y agoPeople are suffering, people are dying ™ You would be suprised if you knew how many people think oceans will be boiling in 50 years
- eganist 5y ago> The image of the government official standing in the water "on what used to be dry land" is quite dramatic.[1] > Unfortunately that land is not underwater due to climate change-driven sea level rise, but due to soil erosion. They do mention this fact, however the focus of the article inexplicably remains on rising sea levels. > A factchecker might call that "missing context" (or worse). Summarizing is a thing journalists do to make things more accessible to lay readers, but that didn't work in your case, so I'll expand with common resources and research from ten seconds worth of googling. "As global sea level rises, the action of waves at higher elevations increases the likelihood for extensive coastal erosion. " (https://toolkit.climate.gov/topics/coastal-flood-risk/coastal-erosion https://toolkit.climate.gov/topics/coastal-flood-risk/coasta...) "Sea level rise shown to drive coastal erosion" (https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1029/00EO00034 https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1029/00EO...) Please don't assume malice.
- Koshkin 5y agoIf the entire population is forced to emigrate, then what's the point?
- BurningFrog 5y agoDo I really have to be the one pointing out this is a well executed PR event? Tuvalu won't be submerged for centuries even in the worst case scenarios. They will have incrementally increasing problems from it decade by decade. But that press release will not go anywhere.
- prepend 5y agoI thought it really funny and disingenuous when the article quoted “We didn't think it would go viral as we saw over the last few days. We have been very pleased with that and hopefully that carries the message and emphasises the challenges that we are facing in Tuvalu at the moment," I’m sure they were completely shocked by their carefully staged and promoted photo op.
- aaron695 5y agoTuvalu is growing in size. So, I know most people on HN are just environmental junkies tied to the environmental industrial complex's teat. But it's pretty cool for the rest of us normies, we are making islands and will continue to make islands. Tuvalu will just keep on growing. It's important to keep them beautiful as they grow, that means not just filling in the atoll or something crazy but growing into the sea, but as technology gets better hopefully they will just get more beautiful. That's what we need to keep on top of. Continue to increase their size but keep them beautiful. FACT CHECK Is the Pacific island nation of Tuvalu growing, and not sinking https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-12-19/fact-check-is-the-island-nation-tuvalu-growing/10627318 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-12-19/fact-check-is-the-isl...
- mamborambo 5y agoThere is a large movement towards distributed statehood/citizenship built on the view that people should treat the government as a service or utility and not overlord. Cue micronations, charter cities, e-residency, and tax havens schemes. The fascinating idea that people can renegotiate and redefine their relationship with the land, the government, and the economy of that state, is a very 21st century concept, but one that is progressing rapidly on the back of Internet, global shipping, digital nomads, borderless visa areas, cryptocurrency, and metaverse. When this idea has developed to maturity, it is not inconceivable that states can be virtual, territoryless, and still represents a sizeable demography, collects tax and manages assets, and provides laws and order for that group.
- smsm42 5y agoSomething I'm missing here: Tuvalu is an island with a population of around 11,000 people and its highest point is just 4.5m (15 ft) above sea level. Since 1993, sea levels have risen about 0.5cm (0.2 inches) per year, according to a 2011 Australian government report. So they're talking about something that might happen in 900 years, if current trends hold (and we all know that all trends noted by the best scientists of 13th century totally proved to be accurate). And yet the article treats it as a problem that needs to be discussed right now, complete with a picture of an official standing knee-deep in water, and descriptions of how old people prepare to "go down with the land" (they must not be that old if they plan to live for several hundreds of years longer...) This looks like cheap theatrics using real events to present scenarios which aren't relevant and probably won't be anytime worth talking about. I mean, there's surely coastal erosion problem but not from the 0.5cm per year thing.
- haspoken 5y agohttps://archive.md/00LD8 https://archive.md/00LD8