5 ms·
Profit Profit Profit
- endlessvoid94 15y agoCan anyone point me to numbers regarding the app store revenue vs. hardware revenue? I'm surprised that the app store revenue would be "just a drop in the bucket" compared to the hardware revenue.
- DavidAdams 15y agoI think of it this way: the majority of iPad users probably spend less than $10 on apps, ever, and the same for media. And a big proportion of them spend $0, only using the iPad for Web, email, Facebook, etc. So on this group, Apple makes a couple bucks on apps and media, tops. Compared to the ~$100 they make selling the iPad.
- kirillzubovsky 15y agoI would disagree and say that the majority probably spends significantly over $10 on the apps. Remember, the "normals" who don't have the time to jailbreak their devices and such, those people actually pay money for games/apps ...etc. For somebody who was willing to pay ~$1,000 for an iPad, paying $10 for an app is not a terrible option, so I'd guess those people spend _significantly_ more than $10. On top of that, there's probably a smaller segment of users who spend _ridiculously_ more than $10 on applications, and then even more on in-app purchases.
- mikeklaas 15y agoiPads don't costs ~$1000.
- roc 15y agohttp://www.asymco.com/2011/01/21/65-of-apples-sales-from-ios-powered-devices-and-90-depends-on-its-own-os/ http://www.asymco.com/2011/01/21/65-of-apples-sales-from-ios... http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/iphones_ipads_are_nearly_70_of_apples_revenue.php http://www.readwriteweb.com/archives/iphones_ipads_are_nearl... Keep in mind those cite revenue; of which Apple retains only 30% on apps. In short: if the app store loses to HTML5 in the long run, but people continue to prefer iPads and iPhones at current rates, you'd need a microscope to see the effect on Apple's bottom line.
- ansy 15y agoApple has suggested the App Store is just above break even [1]. I personally find this believable. I download at least 15 free apps for every paid app. It might even be worse. Approving, hosting, and marketing all those free apps comes at a cost that adds up. By contrast Apple likes to mark up hardware at 100% over bill of materials. That is to say if $300 worth of components goes into an iPhone, Apples wants to sell it for at least $600. The major exception to this is the iPad which Apple takes less to keep pressure on the competition. Regarding iAds, I believe iAds was suppose to have sold around $65 million worth of ads for the initial launch. The revenue from that being split between Apple and the app maker. This is a tiny drop in the bucket. And there are reports Apple is having a hard time getting advertisers to renew. [2] [1] http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/apple_app_store_runs_just_above_break_even/ http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/apple_app_store_runs_... [2] http://www.macrumors.com/2011/02/10/apples-iad-program-struggling-to-fill-slots-and-renew-advertisers/ http://www.macrumors.com/2011/02/10/apples-iad-program-strug...
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoThe profitability of iAds should not be construed as a measure for the profitability of advertising in general.
- ansy 15y agoThe parent had a specific question about Apple's profits outside of hardware sales. Third party advertisements do not make money for Apple.
- cmhamill 15y agoApple's total software sales, which include but aren't limited to their cut of the App Store revenue, brought in $696 million this past quarter [1]. For comparison, their total hardware revenue was just under $28 billion [Ibid.]. Making software something like 2% of their total revenue. That is, more or less, a "drop in the bucket," as Gruber says [2]. [1]: http://images.apple.com/pr/pdf/fy11q3datasum.pdf http://images.apple.com/pr/pdf/fy11q3datasum.pdf [2]: Which doesn't of course, make Gruber any less of an insufferable ass, yada yada, so on and so forth.
- joaquin_win 15y agoRecently Steve announced 2 billion paid to devs. That makes apple's cut close to .9 billion. Meanwhile in a quarter Apple has profits of 7billion.
- ugh 15y agoAlso, that cut is revenue, not profit.
- jakewalker 15y agoApple has also said that they operate close to breakeven on iTunes / the App store. See http://allthingsd.com/20100225/apple-billions-of-songs-billions-of-apps-not-much-profit/ http://allthingsd.com/20100225/apple-billions-of-songs-billi...
- tptacek 15y agoOver what time period? Is that a top line of 30% of $2Bn over 10-12 quarters? That is a microscopic amount of money for HP.
- joaquin_win 15y agoAs I understood, thats since the beginning. So basically nothing compared to HP or even Apple
- mikeklaas 15y agoHow much did Apple make from your iPhone(s)? Let's say $300 every 2 years. How many apps have you purchased in that time? It's going to be less than $300 for most people, and Apple only gets 30% of that total, and has their own costs on top of it.
- r00fus 15y agoI have spent a decent amount on apps... but I spend to put on about 6 devices (iPhones, iPads, iPod touches for family members), and any new iDevices we buy. That Apple recognizes and allows this behavior really tells me that they don't care about profit from apps. Apps, for Apple, are features of the real product, the hardware. Hundreds of thousands of features where the competing hardware platforms don't compare as favorably. It was the same with AAC DRM music on the iPod (when few other players at the time supported AAC, and none supported FairPlay DRM)... these were little land mines in a music library that prevented users from switching or even considering it.
- joebadmo 15y agoI also disagree with Arrington on the Touchpad, but Gruber and other Apple acolytes' disregard for high-volume low-margin markets seems misplaced. Yes, Apple makes a lot of money by tailoring devices for high profit margin markets. That's clearly a lucrative way to do things, if you can pull it off. But, obviously, not everyone can. Surely there's room in the market at large for both models? And surely it's good for everyone to see competition at all levels?
- martingordon 15y agoThe difference here is that Apple has such a good supply chain that it's practically impossible for anyone else to undercut Apple without selling at a loss. It's quite likely that an inferior competing device has a higher manufacturing cost than the iPad.
- tptacek 15y agoThere is no room in the market for selling products at a loss, and without a clearly lucrative business model behind it, there's also no room in the market for selling products at cost. Those aren't pundit opinions; they're laws of physics. There's a back and forth to be had about the value of the app market for HP, but the best available evidence suggests that by itself it is nowhere nearly large enough to justify a strategic investment in tablets. So if you want to make the point that there are other strategies besides Apple's, sure. Nobody can argue with that; it's not falsifiable. To make your comment useful, propose a way for HP to make real money on those tablets.
- tghw 15y agoThe Xbox is sold at a loss but overall is a profitable division for Microsoft. There is room in the market for loss-leaders, it's just a question of where to build a revenue model from. Unlike Android, HP could have run an end-to-end product, controlling the hardware, software, and app ecosystem, but could have tried doing it at a lower price. There's no guarantee the market would have supported it, but seeing how eagerly people snatched up the fire-sale tablets, it's kind of disappointing not to even see them try.
- kirillzubovsky 15y agoYour short rant, on the other hand, is so elaborate, so unique, so daring and so enlightening!
- tptacek 15y agoDo you disagree with it? Why or why not? Or do you just want to share your emotional response to it?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- lotharbot 15y agoNot everyone needs to be Apple, or to do things the Apple way. Apple makes big margins on their $500 hardware. Why can't HP or some other company be profitable by making small margins on $200 hardware, moving a lot of units, and taking a cut of app sales?
- martingordon 15y agoI posted this in another thread, but it warrants repeating: The key factor everyone's missing from a loss leader strategy is that the consumables must be a requirement to use the device. Consoles, razors and printers can all sell for a loss because they are worthless without games, blades and ink. You can get by on a tablet (and I bet a majority of non-tech savvy users do) by just using the built-in apps and/or free apps. If HP went with this strategy with the TouchPad, it would require that a user spend $1000 on apps to make up for the $300 loss on each TouchPad. At an extremely generous $5/app, that's still 200 apps per user.
- tptacek 15y agoHPQ's top line is $31Bn/quarter. Cuts on app sales are a rounding error. Meanwhile, they're selling tablets at cost, devaluing the space they're competing for, and they remain at a structural disadvantage to Apple and Samsung, both of whom are handheld supply chain giants. How does this work out well for HP? It's easy to see how it works out well for Hacker News: there's a third viable tablet platform! Yay! But HPQ can't make decisions to maximize hacker morale; they are legally obligated to serve HPQ's bottom line. Incidentally, your comment addresses only half of Gruber's point; the other half is that a $500->$100 discount's success doesn't prove demand either for a $200 price point or for a product with a $200 BOM.
- gravitronic 15y agoThe tablets are being sold far below cost. BOM cost is ~$300 for the HP touchpad.
- borism 15y agoNot all of company's products need to be profitable all at the same, especially for the beast like HP. Obviously they need to be in the tablet business as it's direct threat to almost everything else they've got (well, except servers). So devaluing that space as long as they can thanks to their other businesses might just as well be the only viable tablet strategy for HP while it reinvents itself.
- ja27 15y agoI tried briefly to find actual numbers on the manufacturing run(s) of the Touchpad. I wonder how many of these are really out there. Is this just a blip on the chart compared to iPad numbers? I'm a bit concerned about what this will do to the real Android tablet market numbers. How many Touchpad buyers would have otherwise bought a low-end Android tablet? That market is already fragile enough without HP blowing out tablets well below cost. (It's not that different than the Borders liquidations hurting Barnes and Noble's numbers when they're already struggling.) Oh, and when does the RIM Playbook fire sale start?
- nazgulnarsil 15y agoyeah, even a million touchpads wouldn't be anywhere near apples numbers AFFAIK. I've heard numbers ranging between 250-350k for touchpad inventory.
- cbs 15y ago>"I knew Mike Arrington was a dummy" huh, interested. >(daringfireball.net) Oh, nevermind.
- jjm 15y agoWhile I agree with Gruber on HW sales being very profitable must he really resort to "dummy"? Its one thing to see Jersey Shore say things like this, but Gruber?
- mattparcher 15y agoThis is not out of character for him. John has a long tradition of calling out a "Jackass of the Week," generally awarded for idiotic Apple/tech punditry: http://www.google.com/search?q=jackass+site:daringfireball.net http://www.google.com/search?q=jackass+site:daringfireball.n...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- huxley 15y agoDummy is probably one of the most polite things Arrington has ever been called.
- steveb 15y agoI see Amazon and B&N taking a big chunk out of the low-cost tablet market, and it will be hard for anyone else to compete. They can sell direct to consumers and capture more revenue. They have a vested interest in locking customers into their ecosystem, so they can sell at cost. Finally, they are trusted brands and can use their online stores to promote product. A company like HP and Samsung would make most of their profits on the sale of the device. $200 tablets will never be profitable on their own, so unless you have another revenue stream, it's not worth doing. That leaves cheap clone systems probably running Android with crappy build quality and nonexistent engineering. You can be sure that Amazon noticed the frenzy over $99 Touchpads and the strong sales of the Nook color.
- bitsweet 15y agoI knew Mike Arrington was a dummy...didn’t think he was this big a dummy I usually discount any argument that begins with name calling
- arnemart 15y agoWell, it IS Michael Arrington he's talking about.
- Apocryphon 15y ago$99 tablets would be quite a boon to consumers. Having a viable competitor to the iPad would be good for the market. I wanna believe.
- patio11 15y agoThe average iDevice has less than ~$20 of software on it. (Simple math on earnings call stats.) 30% of $20 is $6. That's, well, rat spit.
- dkrich 15y agoThis all goes back to the Jack Welch theory: either be number one or two in your industry, or find something else to do. What the heck did HP hope to gain by building a crappy version of the iPad and charging the same price for it? The lack of innovation at these companies is truly confounding. If I had any HP stock I would be dumping it with both hands.
- jgh 15y agoGod tech bloggers are an insufferable bunch.