3 ms·
I could write it to properly log it to a user file, with reasonable default limits and take some of those as command line parameters etc, in a few hours. Runni
by Jensson 5y ago
I could write it to properly log it to a user file, with reasonable default limits and take some of those as command line parameters etc, in a few hours.
Running the program at start isn't programming, it is putting it in a "run on start" location, helping users do that is a part of managing the project and not programming.
Figuring out what settings a user would want for it is also project management and not programming.
Starting/stopping is just starting and stopping the program, every OS already provides that functionality. Maybe someone would want a better UX, but then you are doing UX work and not programming work.
So I don't really see it, almost all of the "gotcha" cases he talked about aren't programming problems.
- azhenley 5y agoBut I didn’t give the students a programming problem. I gave them a software project to solve a problem I have, which involves UX and PM work along with some coding.
- Jensson 5y agoRight, but was that what the students asked for? I doubt they thought that they could launch a successful product in 2 hours worth of work.
- skytreader 5y agoI'm sorry but I gotta call this out; this is just peak HN arrogance. All we have is an article relating an anecdote and the reaction to it is to second-guess the author's actions/interpretation of events. Surely, the author has more context of what was actually happening, what was actually being asked for? The actual words used were already vague enough ("ideas for a software project"). The answer to that would always be subjective. Why is there no trust in the author that he has a better read of the room? He definitely has more context of what the students were actually asking for. These are also, students; I'd give the author benefit of the doubt that he gave them a problem that would be most productive use of their time given their skill level. Maybe that's why he didn't consider web browsers or bug trackers. FWIW, I think the article makes a good point but is poorly illustrated, especially for this audience. I've no doubt your average HN commenter has projects/scripts under their belt more complicated than a clipboard logger, maybe even on far tighter time constraints. But c'mon, these are students! If you work in the industry there will definitely be different causes for project under-estimation.
- Jensson 5y agoBut the author gave a project idea where most of the project was figuring out UX concerns of non existing users. It is a horrible project no matter how you view it. If you do UX then you need users to actually test what you write on. If you don't do UX then this project is very easy. Sure these students might not have done it in 4 hours, but not because they would get stuck on whatever the author talked about, but because they would try to look up API documentation for whatever OS they work with or bugs in their URL detection code. And since the author teaches software engineering classes and not UX classes I assume this would be a software engineering project and not a UX project. Building out a lot of UX features without users is an anti pattern, better write a bare bones implementation first (start from command line, help first users set it up and see how they like it) and then work from there. For a hobby project that would likely be the end of the project, and a good student could get it in a few hours I'm sure.
- aniforprez 5y agoI think I have to agree about the "peak HN arrogance" bit Most things about software dev are never taught to college students. This is actually an excellent project to teach students beyond programming for computers and building things for humans. Not thinking about UX is what leads to most software projects failing because we are fundamentally different from computers (do I even need to explain this?) I wish I had teachers teaching me stuff like this in my software dev classes instead of the usual stuff. I wouldn't have had to waste years trying and failing to learn this
- Jensson 5y ago> I wish I had teachers teaching me stuff like this in my software dev classes instead of the usual stuff. I think this would be a great class project with the teacher acting as a fictive user. I think it is a horrible hobby project to suggest.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThis situation says a lot about attitudes to development in general. "It's just a hobby project, who cares?" is fine until it's useful enough to end up in production code without being production quality. Most of UNIX literally seems to have been built like this.
- chaxor 5y ago> Running the program at start isn't programming, it is putting it in a "run on start" location, helping users do that is a part of managing the project and not programming. I'm confused by this. Any program that doesn't automatically set up this 'autostart' capability in an OS/architecture independent manner is much more of scriptkiddie solution than a real program. If a program isn't made to run on any OS and any architecture without a multistep instruction set, it isn't really useful to many people at all. (And if your solution to this is Docker, re evaluate if you want anyone other than a handful of devs to use it)
- Jensson 5y agoThis was supposed to be a student hobby project, not a company product release. You are thinking of this problem from the perspective of an enterprise programmer, not of a hobbyist enthusiast.
- thom 5y agoI’m baffled by the level of offence you’re taking at the idea that this is all part of a programmer’s job. Nobody needs to go to college to become a hobbyist programmer, it serves students very poorly to treat them that way. It’s the same reason we teach algorithms instead of just how to google. Code doesn’t exist in a vacuum.
- Jensson 5y ago> I’m baffled by the level of offence you’re taking at the idea that this is all part of a programmer’s job. This is a strawman, I never said these things aren't a part of a programmer's job. > Nobody needs to go to college to become a hobbyist programmer Nobody needs to do enterprise programming on hobby projects, you learn that on the job. For a hobby project it is more important that the project is fun, and very few find enterprise coding fun.
- lodovic 5y agoThey are studying to become professional programmers. I think the enterprise perspective is correct, you don't want grad students with a hobbyist mindset.