3 ms·
Solar doesn't work everywhere, nor wind. What is the environmental impact to create all those batteries? Does that cost include converting heating systems to el
by verdverm 5y ago
Solar doesn't work everywhere, nor wind. What is the environmental impact to create all those batteries? Does that cost include converting heating systems to electric? Would better windows have a better ROI?
- rsj_hn 5y agoBetter windows certainly have a better ROI, but they do not get you to replacing fossil fuels. Nuclear or solar/wind + battery does. Nuclear fortunately works everywhere and does not require batteries. It does, however, take engineering skill in order to build and operate, whereas a solar panel can be ordered from China rather cheaply. In the future, I guarantee you that China will mass produce small, safe, relatively idiot-proof nuclear plants and export them all over the world in Belt and Road version 2.0. They will bring in an all Chinese labor force to build it and quite possibly also to operate it or at least provide immediate support. Many of the people angry at China for not making meaningful CO2 commitments will praise them for saving the planet. As the West continues to de-skill and dumb down, we may even need them to come to the U.S. and generate reliable power for us.
- varelse 5y agoFunny you should say that. So it turns out providing 40 kWh of battery backup to 128M homes would create about 500M tons of CO2. In comparison, the coal industry annually contributes 1.9B tons of CO2 and spews 120M tons of toxic waste which would be gone if we shut this industry down for the low low price of $12B. Conclusion: there really isn't a good argument against this other than people are being dumb. Or pray tell what that argument is. Also once again I already mentioned nuclear as part of the solution where solar doesn't work. I continue to be confused as to why people keep choosing to ignore that.
- verdverm 5y agoOne might note that getting solar roof panels can be a pain in certain localities and that insurance companies are dropping people for having large batteries or EVs due to fire risk. You can cherry pick a few numbers, but it does not come close to the full accounting required for a proper analysis. Not saying it's a bad goal to switch over, just that the true costs are not being expressed, and that it's not some simple thing you can just do
- varelse 5y agoYou can always naysay but sometimes you just need to set a goal and go for it. Coal comes at a tremendously detrimental cost. I don't get how anyone continues to make a case for it. It even generates more radioactive waste than nuclear power does. I just don't get it. Also if you don't like the numbers I just gave you then do the work to come up with a more accurate set of them rather than FUD them https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-radioactive-than-nuclear-waste/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-...
- varelse 5y agoI went looking for these insurance companies that are dropping insurance policies over battery backup systems or EVs and I couldn't find any. Do you have a source for this or did you just hear that somewhere?